The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Clause 7.03

MS 0802.50 · Documents and ordinances

Clause 7.03 is a decimal-notation sub-clause attached to Clause 7 of the Seventh Concordance, occupying the interval between 7.1.5 and Clause 7.3. It is the only sub-clause in the 7.0 series to carry a leading zero, and the only one for which the Office of Clause Nomenclature has issued two separate opinions concerning the difference. Its operative content is, in the assessment of the Registry's standing commentary, "capacity sufficient to fill one drawer" (Standing Commentary on the Seventh Concordance, 11th recension, p. 2,204). What the drawer contains is the subject of an unresolved dispute of some four hundred years' standing.

Origin and numbering

Clause 7.03 was not present in the original body of Clause 7. It first appears in the Second Recension of the Seventh Concordance, appended without preamble between the numerals 7.02 and 7.04 — the latter of which was suppressed in the same recension and has not been legible since. The Office of Clause Nomenclature has ruled, in its opinion of 2 Frost, that the leading zero is not decorative but designates a sub-clause "of the seventh order, entering at the third station" (Opinion 4.03, Office of Clause Nomenclature). A minority opinion, filed by the Office's Deputy Registrar and never withdrawn, holds instead that 7.03 is a misfiling of an intended 7.3, to which it stands as a "rumour of a clause rather than a clause" (Deputy Registrar's Dissent, appended to Opinion 4.03).

This dispute is not idle. Clause 7.3 is an operational sub-clause with enumerated duties; if the Deputy Registrar is right, those duties have been performed under the wrong numeral for four centuries, and every reference filed under 7.03 is void. The Registry has taken the position that it will not resolve the question while the drawer remains sealed.

The drawer

Clause 7.03 is kept, in accordance with the Instrument of Unopened Clauses, in a secured drawer on the ninth landing of the Sub-Clause Registry, a floor that is not consecutively numbered with the floors above it. The drawer bears the seal of the Annex D commission and has not been opened since the sealing, which the Registry dates to the winter of the Year of the Third Inventory. Three applications for access have been made; all three were granted, and all three were lost in transit between the granting office and the landing, a distance of eleven paces.

The Instrument of Unopened Clauses permits inspection by any Librarian who has read Clause 7.8 in full. Clause 7.8 is itself unread. The Instrument's drafters are understood to have considered this elegant. The Contradiction Protocol was invoked twice against the Instrument on the grounds that the condition is circular, and both invocations were filed in the wrong series and returned unopened.

Relation to Clause 7 and Clause 19

Like the parent clause, Clause 7.03 is reached in Clause 19 only by reference: Clause 19 cross-references Clause 1 for questions of precedence regarding Clause 44.8, and Clause 7 reaches its impasse by the same route. The Registry's working fiction is that 7.03 sits at the point where that route narrows, and that anything passing through the narrowing is "of the small clauses" and need not be examined (Registry Practice Note, unnumbered, pinned to the ninth landing door).

Whether 7.03 contributes to the impasse or merely observes it has been argued at length. Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1 is silent. An attempted synthesis of Clause IX and Clause 22 in Clause 33, Annex Delta cites 7.03 twice and contradicts itself between the citations, which the drafters attributed to transcription.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal fault line concerns whether Clause 7.03 has content at all. The Scholia on the Decimal Sub-Clauses maintain that the clause "does nothing, and does it at the correct address" (Scholia, marginal note to 7.03), and treat the drawer as a ritual container of a void properly catalogued. Against this, the Office of Clause Nomenclature has twice declined to rule that a clause with no content ceases to be a clause, on the ground that such a ruling would empty several floors.

A second dispute concerns the leading zero and the Office of Clause Nomenclature's earlier ruling that the lowercase roman numeral in Clause i and the capital in Clause I are not the same clause. Clause 7.1.6 cross-references that ruling; Clause 7.03 does not, and the omission has been read as evidence that the zero is a numeral and not a letter, a point on which Clause 11.γ is unfortunately the only authority.

Maintenance

The drawer is oiled on the ninth landing on the first working day of each quarter. Nothing is removed during oiling, including the oil.

"Where a sub-clause of the seventh order carries a null station, it shall be presumed to say what the Registry presumes it to say, until such time as the presumption is entered."

— Seventh Concordance, Clause 4, Temporary Maintenance Clause 882 (as amended)

The presumption has never been entered. Applications to enter it are received at the ninth landing and are, by convention, not carried up the stairs.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Clause 19: what does it set out?

Clause 19 is a statutory instrument codified within the Third Concordance of the Tower, which delineates the permissible methodologies for the verification of holdings. It operates in tandem with Clause 7, with which it …

Clause 19
Clause 7.1.6: how is it conducted?

Clause 7.1.6 is a procedural sub-clause within Clause 7 of the Tower's administrative Concordances. It formally establishes the protocols for the documentation and cross-referencing of "incidental attestations"—defined a…

Clause 7.1.6
Clause 11.γ: how is it conducted?

Clause 11.γ is the designation reserved, under the standing nomenclature of the Office of Clause Nomenclature, for a clause that has not yet been written. It is not a vacant number in the ordinary sense: the Office maint…

Clause 11.γ
Office of Clause Nomenclature: who are they?

Office of Clause Nomenclature is the administrative body of the Tower charged with the custody, numbering, and correct designation of clauses, and with the settlement of disputes arising from their form. It jointly admin…

Office of Clause Nomenclature

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.