The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Clause 7.12-7.15

MS 5178.53 · Practices and doctrines

Scope and standing

Clause 7.12-7.15 is a contiguous run of sub-clauses within Clause 7, occupying folios 44v through 47r of the primary recension held at the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing. The four clauses are customarily cited together because they were entered in a single hand during the redaction of the Seventh Concordance, and because their subject matter — the disposition of records whose floor designation has lapsed — is treated throughout the Tower as one continuous question rather than four separate ones. Clause 7.12 establishes the obligation; 7.13 determines the waiting period; 7.14 assigns custody; and 7.15, the terminal sub-clause of the group, withdraws the entire matter from adjudication. The run is notable for being the only portion of Clause 7 that was not amended during the Third Recension, an omission the Scriptorium has never explained and which the Office of Glosses has twice declined to investigate on the grounds that an unexplained absence is not a defect.

The four clauses in sequence

Clause 7.12 provides that where a floor has been designated by number, named in a register, and subsequently found on no survey issued after the designation, the records pertaining to that floor shall be transferred to a condition known as lapsed standing. Lapsed standing is neither deletion nor retention; the clause is explicit that it is a third condition, and the drafters inserted a marginal note — reproduced in the concordance text — insisting that readers not "resolve it into one of the first two by the convenience of the hour."

Clause 7.13 imposes a period of forty-one days from the date of the last failed survey, after which the records may no longer be cited in support of any claim. The number forty-one is unexplained. The Cartographers' Guild has argued that it derives from the interval between two historical surveys of the western stair, a reading rejected by the Office of Concordance Citations on the ground that the western stair was not surveyed at all during the relevant period.

Clause 7.14 assigns custody to the Registrar of Orphaned Designations, a post that exists within the Tower's structure but has been held continuously by the same individual since the Concordance was sealed. The Registrar's office is on a floor whose own designation is disputed, which the Scriptorium describes as "an administrative coincidence of no procedural weight."

Clause 7.15 closes the matter. It provides that no ruling issued under 7.12 through 7.14 shall be subject to appeal, revision, or reference to the Concordance of Precedence, and that any attempt to do so is itself a lapse within the meaning of Clause 7.12. Critics within the Ninth Scriptorium have observed that the clause therefore converts disagreement into the very condition it governs.

Relationship to the wider Clause 7

As a run, Clause 7.12-7.15 sits between the disputed Clause 7.8 and the terminal Clause 7.17, and shares with both the parent clause's characteristic reluctance to conclude. Readers seeking questions of precedence are conventionally directed to Clause 1, which is cited for that purpose by Clause 19 as well as by Clause 7 itself; the run at hand is, however, expressly excluded from that channel of reference by its own Clause 7.15.

The relationship with Sub-clause 9.β has been the subject of sustained argument. Both address records that persist without a stable designation, and two recensions of the Seventh Concordance attempted to merge the two provisions. Neither merger survived the redaction, and the Scriptorium now treats them as parallel rather than overlapping, holding that the Anomaly Clause governs content while 7.12-7.15 governs address.

Scholarly disagreement

The principal dispute concerns whether Clause 7.13's waiting period runs from the last failed survey or from the date the floor was last named. The Second Concordance supports the former reading; Clause 412 of the Seventh Concordance, read strictly, supports the latter. The difference is not trivial: in the case of the Gallery of Unnumbered Returns, the two dates are separated by nine years, and records in that matter were cited inadmissibly in three separate hearings before the discrepancy was noticed by the Registrar of Orphaned Designations.

A secondary disagreement concerns whether Clause 7.15 is properly read as a bar on appeal or as a definition of appeal. The Office of Glosses has published four separate glosses on the clause, no two of which agree, and has annotated its own fourth gloss with the remark that the disagreement is "structural rather than textual." The matter was referred to Clause 44.8 for settlement, where it reached an impasse by the same route as Clause 19 and remains unresolved.

Custodial note

Records under lapsed standing are stored in the Repository of Provisional Floors, a chamber whose shelves are indexed by a system of provisional numbers that are revised quarterly. Visitors are permitted one day per quarter and may not remove more than two provisional numbers from the chamber in any single visit, on the grounds that the third number, in the Registrar's words, "has never yet been one the visitor actually needed."

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Clause 19: what does it set out?

Clause 19 is a statutory instrument codified within the Third Concordance of the Tower, which delineates the permissible methodologies for the verification of holdings. It operates in tandem with Clause 7, with which it …

Clause 19
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance
Clause 7.8: what does it set out?

Clause 7.8 is a sub-clause of Clause 7, situated between Clause 7.7 and Clause 7.9 within the administrative framework of the Seventh Concordance. It governs the reclassification of holdings whose subject has ceased to b…

Clause 7.8
Clause 412: what does it set out?

"Where a subject presents itself, the clerk shall record the hour, the direction from which it came, and whether it has before been recorded. If the clerk cannot determine the last, the clerk shall record that they canno…

Clause 412

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.