Clause 9 of the Sixteenth Concordance
MS 8768.61 · Documents and ordinances
Clause 9 of the Sixteenth Concordance is the operative provision governing the plausible extension of reported space. It is the clause most frequently cited by the Directorate of Cartographic Review, and the one most frequently cited against it. Clause 9 establishes that a spatial report is not adjudicated on the basis of whether the reported space exists, but on whether the report can be extended without contradiction by the ordinary instruments of survey. Its full text runs to four lines; its annexes (notably Sixteenth Concordance, Clause 9, Annex 3) run to three hundred and eleven pages.
Text and immediate effect
Clause 9 is conventionally quoted from its second recension, of which the Sixteenth Concordance itself preserves the shorter first. The operative sentence is short enough to have been committed to memory by every surveyor on the middle floors:
"A report of space is admissible where the space so reported may be extended in every direction by instrument, and inadmissible where extension returns a discrepancy that the reporter cannot localise."
— Sixteenth Concordance, Clause 9, second recension
The effect was immediate and unintended. Before Clause 9, surveyors argued about what they had seen. After Clause 9, they argued about where the discrepancy was. This was regarded at the time as an improvement.
The Directorate of Cartographic Review
Clause 9 is also the instrument by which the Directorate of Cartographic Review was constituted, and its authority derives wholly from that clause and from Annex 3, which sets out its charge to examine spatial reports for plausibility. The Directorate sits on the spiral landing between the Sixteenth Floor the Latent Argument and the floor above, which has no name and is therefore not discussed. Its examiners number eleven, of whom no more than seven may be present at once, a rule introduced after the Proceedings of Vol. 344 recorded a seven-to-four division that could not later be reconstructed.
Examiners work from an instrument called the Delta-Grade Resonant Plate, calibrated to the standard laid down in Clause 9, Article 3 on instrumental calibration. The plates are re-calibrated each winter. Visitors are asked not to tap them. This request is not enforced and the plates are tapped constantly.
Relationship to translocation
Clause 9 must be read alongside Annex 2, clause 9, which distinguishes deliberate translocation from the Unintentional Translocation Event. The two provisions were drafted by different hands and do not agree about which takes precedence when a report is both plausible and involuntary. The Directorate has adopted the practice of assessing plausibility first and asking after intent only if the reporter is still present, a practice described in Annex Delta as "convenient but not correct" (Annex Delta, marginal note 14).
The most cited failure of this practice is the case of Examiner Sella Vorn, who in the winter of the year the plates were re-cut assessed a report from the ninth sub-landing as plausible, filed it, and then found the reporter waiting outside her office for four days. Vorn's subsequent memorandum — "On the Order in Which Questions Ought to Be Asked" — was received, entered, and never answered. It is still requested roughly twice a decade.
Dispute: the counting question
The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether Clause 9 can be applied at all to holdings whose extent cannot be counted. The Sixteenth Concordance withdrew the relevant clause of the Twelfth Concordance precisely on the grounds of the difficulties of ordinary counting, and did not replace it with a rule so much as with a permission. The Fifteenth Concordance had taken the opposite view, and the Fifteenth's partisans on the Directorate argue that Clause 9 is therefore void in its application to Pluralist holdings, which by Clause 7.4.α are defined by their capacity for infinite expansion.
The counter-position holds that Clause 9 never required counting, only extension, and that an uncountable holding extends perfectly well so long as no one attempts to draw its edges. This position is supported by Clause 419 and the Axiom of Constitutive Resonance, and opposed by the Seven Metrics of Potentiality, which the Directorate has never adopted and has never entirely rejected. A third faction, small but persistent, maintains that the question was settled in the Seventh Concordance, Clause 4 and that everyone since has simply failed to read it. No one has produced the relevant passage.
Maintenance and standing instructions
The original vellum of Clause 9 is held in the Bindery under the binding authority of Clause 440.12(b) and may be consulted on application to a Librarian of the third standing. It is not to be unrolled on a damp day. The Directorate's working copy, which is a fair copy and differs from the original in two places, is available at the spiral landing between the second and third hours of the afternoon.
Surveyors submitting reports under Clause 9 are reminded that the Clause governs the report and not the surveyor, and that a discrepancy which cannot be localised should be described in writing before it is described aloud.
See also
-
MS 2071.81
The Directorate of Cartographic Coherence
The Directorate of Cartographic Coherence is a sub-directorate of the Directorate of Archival Coherence, constituted to reconcile …
-
MS 4104.24
Concordance 12, Annex Delta, Clause 7
Concordance 12, Annex Delta, Clause 7 is the operative provision governing the standing silence observed in the southern stairwell…
-
MS 4300.63
Concordance 889, Clause 4
Concordance 889, Clause 4 is the operative provision governing the classification and maintenance of standing silences — intervals…
-
MS 3074.28
Twelfth Concordance, Annex Gamma, Clause 22
Twelfth Concordance, Annex Gamma, Clause 22 is the provision of the Twelfth Concordance governing vibration in inhabited floors an…
-
MS 3953.85
The Twenty-Second Concordance, Clause 7
The Twenty-Second Concordance, Clause 7 is the operative provision of the Twenty-Second Concordance governing the Movement of Stac…
-
MS 0000.31
Concordance 47, Clause 9
Concordance 47, Clause 9 is the operative provision governing the disposition of minor remainders — those small, unclaimed quantit…
Referenced by
- MS 0104.36 The Directorate of Cartographic Review
- MS 5002.69 Clause 2 (Establishment of the Office)
- MS 0763.10 Cited Concordance
- MS 2524.04 SixteenthĠConcordance
Readers also asked
Unintentional Translocation Event: what happened?
Unintentional Translocation Event is a documented violation of the Principle of Intentional Ascent, wherein an individual, material, or information is relocated within the Tower without a sanctioned directive or consciou…
Unintentional Translocation EventProceedings Vol. 344: what does it set out?
Proceedings Vol. 344 is a bound folio of the Curatorial Council, comprising the corrected transcript, two dissenting opinions, and an evidentiary annex of nineteen plates, issued under the seal of the Sixteenth Recension…
Proceedings Vol. 344Sixteenth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Sixteenth Concordance (officially designated Constitutional & Administrative Statutes, Sixth Iteration, with Annexes) is a foundational governance document within The Tower, ratified on the 14th of Fructidor, Year 73…
Sixteenth ConcordanceSixteenth Concordance Annex Delta: what does it set out?
Sixteenth Concordance Annex Delta is the fourteenth annex to the Sixteenth Concordance and the document most frequently consulted, most frequently amended, and least frequently read to its end. It concerns itself, in its…
Sixteenth Concordance Annex DeltaPassages cited from this record
-
A report of space is admissible where the space so reported may be extended in every direction by instrument, and inadmissible where extension returns a discrepancy that the reporter cannot localise.
Sixteenth Concordance, Clause 9, second recension
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4151.07 Sixteenth Concordance, Clause 9, Annex 3
- MS 2804.35 Clause 7.4.α
- MS 9643.27 Sella Vorn
- MS 9321.90 Annex 2, clause 9
Because you consulted