Concordance 889, Clause 4
MS 4300.63 · Documents and ordinances
Concordance 889, Clause 4 is the operative provision governing the classification and maintenance of standing silences — intervals of recorded non-occurrence held on deposit in the Tower and withdrawn, on application, for ceremonial use. It is a short clause by the standards of Concordance 889, occupying a single vellum leaf in the authorised recension, but its interpretation has generated more secondary comment than any provision of the Seventh Concordance except its own Clause 4.
The clause is chiefly remembered for the definition it supplies at its opening line, which the Librarians have never amended and have twice attempted to:
"A silence is standing where it has been recorded in the absence of the sound it records, has been sealed by a hand empowered to seal, and has not been attributed to any floor."
— Concordance 889, Clause 4, opening definition
The third condition is the difficult one. A silence attributed to a floor belongs to that floor and may be disposed of by its keeper; an unattributed silence belongs to no one, and therefore to Concordance 48, and therefore, in practice, to the Depositary.
Origin
Concordance 889 was received into the standing register in the winter of the year the archive counts as 6,204, following a dispute between the Scriptorium of Seals and the Office of Audible Records over eleven crates of sealed but unlabelled silence recovered from a stairwell between the four-hundredths. The Scriptorium held that the crates were sealed matter and theirs by ancient right; the Office held that silence was an audible record and theirs by function. Neither office could produce the crates' attribution, and the stairwell in question had no keeper, having been struck from the floor list under the Third Concordance, Clause VII some centuries earlier and never restored.
Clause 4 resolved the matter by creating a third custody. The eleven crates were designated standing, transferred to the Depositary, and remain the oldest holdings under the clause. Their contents have never been opened — not from prohibition but because, as the Depositary's clerk Renna Vosk observed in her annual return for 6,209, "the seals are good and we see no reason to spoil them."
Application and the Vosk objection
Withdrawal of a standing silence requires an application in the applicant's own hand, countersigned by the keeper of the floor on which the silence is to be used. This has produced the clause's central difficulty, since a silence used on a floor is, by the terms of the opening definition, no longer unattributed, and therefore no longer standing, and therefore no longer withdrawable. The clause does not say what happens next.
Vosk raised precisely this in 6,211, in a memorandum now bound with the Depositary's returns and much cited:
"If the silence ceases to be standing upon use, the applicant has taken delivery of a thing that was standing and now is not, and the Depositary has parted with a holding it is bound to maintain. Either the silence returns, or the clause does not mean what its first line says. I have written to the Scriptorium. They have not replied."
— Memorandum of Renna Vosk, Depositary's Returns, 6,211
The Scriptorium's non-reply was later entered into the correspondence register as a silence of the ordinary kind, not standing, and disposed of accordingly.
Scholarly disagreement
Two readings of the clause now prevail. The recursive reading, favoured by the Depositary and by the annotators of Concordance 89, Clause 14, holds that silence generated by use of a standing silence is itself standing, on the reasoning that it is recorded, sealed by the countersigning keeper, and attributable to no floor until it is used. Custody therefore passes in an unbroken chain and the holding is, in the Depositary's phrase, "replenished rather than spent." The terminal reading, held at the Scriptorium of Seals and set out at length in the annotations to Concordance 7, Annex Delta, Clause 12, holds that a silence may be standing only once, that use consumes it, and that the Depositary has been operating at a deficit it has concealed by never reconciling its shelves.
The terminal reading received apparent support from Concordance 114, Annex 7, Clause 22.b, which requires the Depositary to reconcile standing holdings against sealed crates each tenth year. The Depositary has completed four such reconciliations and published figures for none of them. When pressed in 6,218, the office replied that the reconciliation had been conducted "in silence," and that the Concordance Clause governing publication did not require a silence to be published where publication would breach it.
Interaction with the Erasure clauses
Clause 4 is frequently pleaded alongside the erasure provisions, particularly Third Concordance, Clause 11, Annex Gamma, though the two are said by the annotators of the Third to govern different orders of thing: Erasure removes a record, whereas a standing silence records an absence. Clerk Vosk's successor twice refused applications that sought to treat an erased record as a standing silence on the ground that "what is erased is not absent, it is erased, and the clause does not permit the confusion" (Depositary's Refusals, entry 44).
The distinction was tested in the matter of the Δ-class recension of 6,223, in which a sealed silence was withdrawn for a ceremony on the two-hundredths and not returned. The ceremony lasted nine minutes. The resulting silence was accepted back into custody in the following spring, reconciled to the original crate, and found to weigh four drams more than the parent. The Depositary has not explained the discrepancy and the Scriptorium has declined to enquire. Two crates from the four-hundredths remain unopened.
Prohibitions and practice
Three restrictions attach to the clause in current practice. Standing silences may not be withdrawn for use in the same room on consecutive days. They may not be carried through the central shaft between the hours of Compline and Prime. And no standing silence may be used to quiet a volitional void, since the void would not accept it and the attempt has twice produced a silence that answered back — a matter referred to the Seventeenth Concordance and there left.
The clause remains in force without amendment. A proposal to revise its opening definition was laid before the Librarians in 6,229 and has not been brought to a vote. It is understood to be resting.
See also
-
MS 7723.01
First Paradoxical Provision
The First Paradoxical Provision, formally designated Concordance 88-A, is the foundational legal and operational framework governi…
-
MS 1144.30
Ceremonial Inks
Ceremonial Inks constitute a regulated subset of specialized marking fluids whose manufacture and application are solely authorize…
-
MS 3488.22
Expedited Verification Annex B7 Subclause Gamma
Expedited Verification Annex B7 Subclause Gamma is a contested provision within the Second Concordance, establishing a provisional…
-
MS 8155.35
Concordantal Self-Application
The doctrine of Concordantal Self-Application refers to the established practice whereby a provision within a Concordance is invok…
-
MS 6053.16
Aperture Seal Directive 7-Alpha, Clause 12, Subsection Gamma
Aperture Seal Directive 7-Alpha, Clause 12, Subsection Gamma is the operative provision of Aperture Seal Directive 7-Alpha governi…
-
MS 0178.94
Clause 4 (Application to Self)
Clause 4 (Application to Self) is the fourth clause of the Third Concordance and the provision by which any Concordance, annex, or…
Referenced by
- MS 2269.47 Zone of Calcified Echoes
- MS 8195.64 Calcified Wing (Petra-7)
- MS 1998.49 Concordance 12, Clause 440
- MS 7056.13 Concordance 22, Clause 809
- MS 3867.31 Concordance 48, Clause 1
- MS 7303.66 Entry 440, Sub-clause 9
- MS 8716.61 Concordance 112, Clause 4
- MS 9206.21 Concordance 19, Clause 7
- MS 4297.38 Calcified Echoes
- MS 0585.43 Seven Silences
- MS 1133.40 The Splenic Swamp Deposit
Readers also asked
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?
The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…
Seventh ConcordanceConcordance 71, Clause Δ: how is it conducted?
Concordance 71, Clause Δ is the fourth lettered clause of the Seventy-First Concordance and the only provision in the Tower's body of law that regulates the tending of silence — that is, the maintenance of designated qui…
Concordance 71, Clause ΔConcordance 889: what does it set out?
Concordance 889 is a formally recognized but perpetually provisional governance document within the Tower, first promulgated on Floor Δ-14 in Year Y54020109. Its primary function is the regulation of auditory phenomena c…
Concordance 889Third Concordance, Clause VII: what does it set out?
Third Concordance, Clause VII is the foundational administrative statute governing the procedures for petition, amendment, and contradiction within the Tower's legal architecture. Often referred to simply as the Clause i…
Third Concordance, Clause VIIPassages cited from this record
-
A silence is standing where it has been recorded in the absence of the sound it records, has been sealed by a hand empowered to seal, and has not been attributed to any floor.
Concordance 889, Clause 4, opening definition
-
If the silence ceases to be standing upon use, the applicant has taken delivery of a thing that was standing and now is not, and the Depositary has parted with a holding it is bound to maintain. Either the silence returns, or the clause does not mean what its first line says. I have written to the Scriptorium. They have not replied.
Memorandum of Renna Vosk, Depositary's Returns, 6,211
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9741.65 Renna Vosk
Because you consulted