Clause 45
MS 8726.83 · Documents and ordinances
Clause 45 is a provision of the Seventh Concordance concerning the disposition of contested floor assignments, and is chiefly notable for having been superseded, reaffirmed, and superseded again within a single administrative year. It is the shortest clause in the Concordance to carry an annex, and the only one whose annex is longer than the floor it governs. Clerks of the Office of Vertical Records refer to Clause 45 less by its number than as "the hinge," on the grounds that everything before it opens and everything after it does not close.
Text and enactment
Clause 45 was entered into the Seventh Concordance in the winter of the year the archive records as 4,112 by the Registry of Stairwells, under the authority of Clause 7 and with the concurrence of the office then administering Clause 14. Its operative sentence is brief enough to be quoted whole:
"Where two or more floors claim the same subject, the claim shall lie with the floor whose number the subject can be made to divide evenly, and where no floor divides the subject, the claim shall lie with none of them."
— Seventh Concordance, Clause 45
The final movement of that sentence — the "shall lie with none of them" — is the source of every difficulty the clause has since caused. It was drafted, according to the surviving minutes of the Sub-committee on Numeric Claims, as a formality. No case had ever reached the sub-committee in which a subject could not be divided by at least one candidate floor number.
The Marrow Incident
In the eleventh month of 4,147, a consignment of catalogued floor ledgers was submitted to the Registry of Stairwells by three floors simultaneously: Floor 91, Floor 273, and Floor 455. Each claimed jurisdiction over the material, which concerned the maintenance schedule for the north aperture. Under Clause 45 the Registry divided each candidate floor number into the ledger's accession figure, 46,410, and found that all three divided it evenly. The clause is silent on ties.
The Registry resolved the ambiguity by classifying the accession figure as the disputed subject rather than the ledgers themselves. This gave a tie of three, and the tie could not be broken, and so by the clause's own last movement the claim lay with none of the three floors. The ledgers were returned to the Unassigned Shelves on Floor 455, which then filed a separate objection, noting that the Unassigned Shelves were themselves on its floor and that it could not therefore be said to have lost the claim.
The objection was upheld. The Marrow Incident, as it came to be called — after the Clerk Marrow who first lodged the tie — occupied the Registry for fourteen months and produced nine recensions of a single procedural note. The note's current form runs to two paragraphs, the second of which reads in full: "Where a claim has been found to lie with none of the floors, it shall be filed on Floor 455."
Aperture and stairwell operation
Clause 45 governs not only floors but apertures, which are numbered on a separate register and cannot be divided by anything. The Aperture Calculus adopted in 4,160 attempted to extend the clause by treating aperture numbers as reciprocals, so that Aperture 12 divided a subject in the same way Floor 12 would not. The Calculus was withdrawn after Clause 412 was amended to forbid reciprocal reasoning in matters of vertical jurisdiction, and the apertures reverted to the "none of them" rule, under which they have operated without recorded complaint since.
Stairwells proper are not subject to Clause 45 at all. They are covered by Clause 14.7.δ, which disclaims the clause explicitly, and by the Duration and Review Clause, which requires that any stairwell dispute be reviewed at intervals not exceeding eleven years. The eleven-year figure was chosen, per the Annex, because it exceeded the working life of the stairwell surveyors then in post.
Scholarly disagreement
There is no agreement on what Clause 45 divides. The Precedence School holds that the clause applies only to accession figures, and cites Clause 19 and its dependent Clause 19.β as evidence that the drafters used "subject" in a narrow, numeric sense throughout. The Broad Reading, which controls the Registry's practice, holds that "subject" means any catalogued thing and adduces Clause 7.03 — which divides a document, not a number — as proof that the drafters could not have intended the narrow sense.
A third position, associated with the Marginalia of Floor 6, argues that Clause 45 has no subject of its own and applies only to claims already made under Clause 4.11.γ. This has never been adopted by any office, but it is reprinted in every edition of the Concordance Digest because no one has been able to show it is wrong.
Status
Clause 45 was superseded by Clause 47 in 4,155, reaffirmed by Clause 812 in 4,158, and superseded again by the same Clause 47 in 4,159, which left its status dependent on which recension of the Concordance is consulted. The Librarians have declined to rule, on the ground that Clause 45 still governs, and that ruling either way would require dividing the question. The clause is presently on the docket of the Standing Committee on Supersession, which has not sat since the Marrow Incident. Its members' appointments lapse in the spring.
What survives without dispute is the clause's practical effect: any subject contested by more than one floor is, by default, filed on Floor 455. The Unassigned Shelves now occupy four bays, a corridor, and part of the stairwell surveyors' old canteen.
See also
-
MS 5490.39
Clause 22.d
Clause 22.d is a subordinate provision of Clause 22 of the Seventh Concordance, governing the disposition of contested floor assig…
-
MS 4501.65
Clause 44 of the Twelfth Concordance
[[Clause 44 of the Twelfth Concordance is the provision concerning the disposition of unfinished business. It is the longest claus…
-
MS 3886.52
Clause 704.1
Clause 704.1 is a standing provision of the Seventh Concordance concerning the disposition of objects that have been catalogued tw…
-
MS 3326.46
Clause 178 of the Fourth Concordance
Clause 178 of the Fourth Concordance is a provision concerning the disposition of shelfmarks issued to volumes that have been with…
-
MS 9919.33
Fact Reaffirmed
Fact Reaffirmed is the formal, adjudicatory process by which the Tower’s executive administrative body, the Curatorium of Verifica…
-
MS 7967.34
Amendment 77
Amendment 77 is a procedural instrument of the Concordance Amendment Tracking register, entered under the designation Amendment 77…
Referenced by
- MS 4491.85 Office of Assessment
Readers also asked
Duration and Review Clause: how is it conducted?
"The Clause is a duration, not a clock."
Duration and Review ClauseClause 4.11.γ: how is it conducted?
Clause 4.11.γ, colloquially known as the Ambient Taxonomy Principle, is a procedural sub-clause of Clause 4, Annex C within the Seventh Concordance. It formally authorizes the categorization of environmental phenomena—sp…
Clause 4.11.γSeventh Concordance: what does it set out?
The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…
Seventh ConcordanceClause 47: what does it set out?
Clause 47 is a short-form clause of the Seventh Concordance concerning the disposal of unclaimed floor inventories. It is among the least cited of the Concordance's operative provisions and among the most frequently invo…
Clause 47Passages cited from this record
-
Where two or more floors claim the same subject, the claim shall lie with the floor whose number the subject can be made to divide evenly, and where no floor divides the subject, the claim shall lie with none of them.
Seventh Concordance, Clause 45
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 1355.09 Broad Reading
- MS 0219.17 Precedence School
- MS 4481.74 Annex
- MS 2059.73 Marginalia of Floor 6
Because you consulted