Amendment 77
MS 7967.34 · Documents and ordinances
Amendment 77 is a procedural instrument of the Concordance Amendment Tracking register, entered under the designation Amendment 77 and held, in its operative recension, to govern the disposition of amendments that have been superseded but not formally withdrawn. It is the shortest amendment currently in force and the only one whose text is shorter than its own heading. Its principal effect — the so-called "standing residue" doctrine — is that a superseded amendment does not cease to apply; it applies instead to a narrower and differently defined class of cases, which the amendment declines to specify.
The instrument was drafted in the winter of the year the register calls 830-Φ, on the fourth sub-level of Stairwell 9, by a clerk of the Bureau of Concordant Amendment whose name the register gives only as the Seventh Drafter. The chamber in which it was drafted is now a stationery store. A brass plate above the door records the fact and nothing else.
Text and construction
Amendment 77 runs to a single operative clause:
"An instrument superseded shall not be void; it shall be otherwise applied. The Bureau shall determine the otherwise."
— Amendment 77, sole clause
The Bureau has never published a determination under the second sentence, on the ground that publication would fix the "otherwise" and thereby defeat the purpose of leaving it unfixed. This position was upheld in Amendment 47-G, which held that a determination need not exist in order to be relied upon, provided it is relied upon consistently. Reliance has been consistent.
The amendment is ranked below Amendment 117.45.β and above Amendment 14-f in the order of precedence maintained by the Bureau of Precedence. It is subordinate to no parent instrument, which the Bureau notes is unusual and has never explained.
The doctrine of standing residue
Before Amendment 77, the supersession of an instrument was understood to extinguish it, and clerks disposed of superseded texts accordingly, generally by transfer to the Annex of Withdrawn Instruments. After 77, disposal became extremely difficult. A superseded amendment cannot be archived as dead, because it is still otherwise applied; it cannot be shelved as live, because it has been superseded. The Annex of Withdrawn Instruments has accepted no deposits since 830-Φ and now houses only the pre-77 holdings, which the Keeper of the Annex describes as "the last honest shelf in the Tower" (Keeper's Report, 831-Φ, §2).
The practical difficulty is well illustrated by the fate of Amendment 12. That instrument was superseded in part by Amendment 12-b and further qualified by Amendment 12(b).4, yet under Amendment 77 it remains otherwise applied to a class of matters the Bureau has not identified. Clerks resolving disputes under Amendment 12 are therefore instructed to read it as though it were still in force, and simultaneously instructed not to, and the two instructions are printed on facing pages of the current handbook. Third Concordance, Amendment 22 had attempted to resolve the tension by declaring such amendments provisionally null; Amendment 12-b removed that solution, holding that provisional nullity does not reach amendments governing amendment procedures. Amendment 77 is an amendment governing amendment procedures.
Dispute: the Logging question
Amendment 77 requires that superseded instruments continue to be logged, since an amendment otherwise applied must be traceable. How they are to be logged is disputed. The Chen Amendment to the Provisional Logging Protocol refined the logging of contradictions, and the Bureau of the Provisional Log reads it as requiring superseded amendments to be entered twice — once under their original designation and once under the designation of whatever superseded them. The Bureau of Concordant Amendment rejects this reading, maintaining that double entry implies the amendment exists in two states, whereas Amendment 77 establishes only that it is otherwise applied, which is one state.
The two Bureaux have referred the question to the Committee on Instrumental Identity three times. The Committee has three times returned it, in 834-Φ, 836-Φ and 838-Φ, each time with the note that the question is "not one of identity." No minute records what kind of question it is.
Effects on the register
The most visible consequence of Amendment 77 is the register's growth. Because nothing may be retired, the Concordance Amendment Tracking register has expanded at a rate of roughly nine per cent annually since 830-Φ, and the Amendment Annex Σ.7 was opened in 835-Φ to hold the overflow of instruments that are neither current nor withdrawn. The Annex is not heated. Clerks assigned to it are issued a second coat.
A minor provision of Amendment 77, rarely cited, permits the Bureau to decline to answer inquiries concerning the "otherwise" on any day the register is closed for cleaning. The register is closed for cleaning on Tuesdays.
Status
Amendment 77 has never been amended. The Bureau of Concordant Amendment treats this as evidence of its soundness; the Bureau of Precedence treats it as evidence that no one has read it. Both positions are recorded, neither has been withdrawn, and under Amendment 77 each is otherwise applied.
See also
-
MS 4281.31
Seventh Amendment
The Seventh Amendment refers to a specific, non-consecutive iteration of the Seventh Cycle's foundational constitutional instrumen…
-
MS 1342.55
Ninth Concordance Amendment Sigma
Ninth Concordance Amendment Sigma is the designation given to the cluster of amendments by which the Ninth Concordance absorbed th…
-
MS 1889.53
Amendment 44-B
Amendment 44-B is a corrective sub-instrument appended to Amendment 44-A to the Third Concordance and is reckoned among the second…
-
MS 3334.23
Amendment Gamma (Depreciation and Decommissioning)
Amendment Gamma (Depreciation and Decommissioning) is the collective designation for the third schedule of amendments to the Seven…
-
MS 0644.10
Concordance Amendment Tracking
Concordance Amendment Tracking (CAT) is the mandated administrative practice for logging the issuance, versioning, status, and int…
-
MS 8726.83
Clause 45
Clause 45 is a provision of the Seventh Concordance concerning the disposition of contested floor assignments, and is chiefly nota…
Referenced by
- MS 1006.77 Protocol of Recursive Authentication
- MS 3946.48 Amendment 7-Γ
- MS 2825.87 Amendment Σ
Readers also asked
Bureau of Precedence: who are they?
The Bureau of Precedence is a standing office of the Librarians, charged with the determination of which of two or more things comes first. It is the oldest continuously disputed body in the Tower and the only one whose …
Bureau of PrecedenceProvisional Logging Protocol: how is it conducted?
The Protocol, as codified in Annex C of the Descent Protocol Delta-7-22, outlines three non-negotiable mandates:
Provisional Logging ProtocolAmendment 12: what does it set out?
Amendment 12 is the twelfth and most frequently amended instrument appended to Concordance 44, and the only amendment in the Concordance series to have generated a subordinate annex, a corrective annex, and a disputed da…
Amendment 12Amendment 47-G: what does it set out?
Amendment 47-G is a subordinate recension appended to Amendment 47 of The Principle of Perpetual Amendment, entered in the amendment register under the custody of the Bureau of Concordant Amendment on the 14th of Frostmo…
Amendment 47-GPassages cited from this record
-
An instrument superseded shall not be void; it shall be otherwise applied. The Bureau shall determine the otherwise.
Amendment 77, sole clause
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7787.46 Stairwell 9
- MS 7070.34 Committee on Instrumental Identity
- MS 4350.72 Keeper of the Annex
- MS 3501.10 Amendment 12(b).4
Because you consulted