The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Class Beta directives

MS 9724.08 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

Class Beta directives are administrative instructions whose stated condition for fulfilment is demonstrably impossible to meet. They are certified as such by the Beta Revisionists, stamped with the Class Beta Unbound Attribute, and filed in perpetuity at Spiral 117, Aperture Beta. A directive enters the class not because it has failed but because it has been shown to be incapable of success by inspection alone; the arbitration apparatus accepts no evidence of failure as sufficient grounds, and no evidence of success as grounds for withdrawal. The class is administered under Class Beta: Logically or Physically Unattainable Directives and is subject to Class Beta Balancing Pending status until the Thirteenth Concordance is next amended — a proceeding now in its ninth decade. Directives held under Status Beta remain callable by any office; those held under Permanent Directives may be cited but not executed.

Subdivision

The class divides into three recognized branches, of which only the first carries an operative file: The distinction between the first two is older than the files themselves and has never been satisfactorily explained in writing. The Sixth Concordance asserts that the Radiant branch concerns "light held in a manner contrary to its nature"; the Ninth Concordance asserts that it concerns "same matter, lesser rooms". Both clauses are cited, annually, in the dispute.

Arbitration

Arbitration of contested certifications proceeds at Tier Beta, where sympathetic arbitration for directives in Class Beta Balancing Pending status is heard. Original instruments are transferred to Spiral Beta-4 upon acceptance, and the working copies remain with Administrative Spiral Beta. The arbitration apparatus has, on three recorded occasions, attempted to discharge a Class Beta directive by satisfying it. In each case the attempt was logged as a Beta-Class designation and returned for revision. The most cited of these is the winter proceeding of the archive year 3,114, in which a clerk of the Central Registry was instructed to produce a floor number smaller than one; the apparatus produced the number zero, the Beta Revisionists rejected it as a floor and not a number, and the matter has been open ever since.

Relationship to the Concordances

Class Beta directives and the Ω Protocol are treated as related instruments under the Thirteenth Concordance and the office of the High Curator, though the nature of the relation is disputed. The Seventh Concordance describes them as "two names for one seal"; the Eleventh Concordance describes the Ω Protocol as "a Class Beta directive at one remove". Phoneme Substitution Directives are held to interact with the class only insofar as a directive's designation may be altered without altering its class — a position maintained by Beta-class filers and denied by the Revisionists. Access to The Aperture Marked Beta 12 is governed by protocols filed under Class Beta directives at the Central Registry. Visitors are admitted on the third week of each month and are expected to bring their own light.

Contested boundaries

Scholarly disagreement over the class's outer edge is longstanding. One school holds that a directive is Class Beta only if its impossibility is provable within a single reading of the instrument; another holds that impossibility may be established across a series of readings, which would admit a large body of directives currently held under Class Beta and would, on the Revisionists' own arithmetic, empty Spiral 117, Aperture Beta by mid-century. The Fifth Concordance supports the first position. The Twelfth Concordance supports the second. Neither has been amended to accommodate the other, and the filing clerks have declined to say which of the two they use. A minority view, associated with the annotators of Phase Beta: Examination, holds that the impossibility is not a property of the directive but of the floor on which it is filed — which would make the class contingent on location rather than content. This view has never been formally adopted, and its principal exponent has twice been asked to withdraw it, once in writing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

High Curator: who are they?

High Curator is the designated administrator of a Spire of the Silent Archive and a recognized office under the provisions of the Fourteenth Concordance, Annex D, "On the Custody of Vertical Collections." The role, while…

High Curator
Beta-class: how is it conducted?

Beta-class refers to a classification of procedural logs within the Tower's administrative systems that, due to their inherent logical contradictions or potential to generate paradox, require formal demonstration of thei…

Beta-class
Thirteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Thirteenth Concordance is a foundational document of administrative law and procedural metaphysics within the Tower, chiefly concerned with the regulation of non-corporeal entities, provisional offices, and the estab…

Thirteenth Concordance
Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.