BureauĠofĠApplicativeĠConcordance
MS 8892.06 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Bureau of Applicative Concordance is a standing office of the Tower charged with determining which precedent, protocol, or Concordance governs a situation for which no protocol was written in advance. It does not make rules and does not revise them; it decides which already-existing rule applies to a case that has arrived without one. The distinction is insisted upon in the Bureau's own founding instrument, which describes its function as "the fitting of an old key to a door cut yesterday," and which has been quoted in every subsequent dispute about the Bureau's authority to cut anything at all.
Establishment and mandate
The Bureau was constituted under Concordance 44, and its competences were subsequently trimmed, restored, and trimmed again by Concordance 44, Annex 12. Annex 12 restricts the Bureau to situations "arising after the framing of the question," a phrase that has generated more litigation than any other in the applicative corpus, since it is not stated who frames the question or when framing is considered complete. The Bureau's adjudications are issued as Bureau Findings of the applicative class, and a finding binds only the parties who requested it, the floor on which it was requested, and any successor floor bearing the same number.
Under Second Concordance, Annex 19, the Bureau must distinguish itself in every written instrument from the Bureau of Calibration and from the Central Licensing Bureau, a requirement inherited from the settlement recorded in Third Concordance, Annex 9, after which the Chronometric Calibration Bureau became formally distinct from both. Bureau clerks have adopted the practice of placing the distinction in a footnote, which the Bureau of Precedential Analysis has twice declined to treat as compliance.
Procedure
A request for applicative finding is submitted on a Form 9 (Applicative), in triplicate, and is docketed by the hour of receipt rather than the day, a rule introduced after the Winter Queue of Floor 314, when eleven requests submitted in the same afternoon were found to have been docketed in an order no one could reconstruct. The requesting party must state what it believes the applicable precedent to be. The Bureau is not bound by this statement and frequently rules that a different precedent applies, or that none does, in which case the matter is referred to the Reconciliation Bureau with a covering note.
The Bureau sits in panels of three. A panel of two is permitted where the third member is unreachable, provided the unreachability is certified by the Bureau of Vertical Concordance, which inspects the Specimen Stair Linkage twice yearly under the Eleventh Concordance. Panels of one are permitted only in the Alphabetic Fens, under the arrangement administered by the Bureau of Hydraulic Concordance since its recognition of the Free Flow League in Year 632.
Conflicts and contested competence
The Bureau's most persistent difficulty is the unresolved relationship between Concordance 44 and Concordance 61. The Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation has declined four times to reconcile them, each time on the ground that reconciliation is not the same as adjudication and that the matter properly lies with an applicative body. The Bureau of Applicative Concordance has replied, in Finding 44-A-117, that it cannot apply a precedent whose relationship to another precedent is itself unsettled, and has asked the Registry Bureau to recognize the resulting impasse as a Concordance Conflict. The Registry Bureau has recognized the conflict provisionally, pending a determination of which of the two Concordances governs the recognition of conflicts — a determination that would ordinarily be sought from the Bureau of Applicative Concordance.
"Where two instruments speak and neither yields, the Bureau shall not choose between them but shall record the speaking and adjourn."
— Concordance 44, Annex 12, clause 9
Clause 9 has been read by the Bureau as a stay of proceedings and by the Bureau of Perpetual Revision as a licence to amend the record while the matter is adjourned. The two readings have coexisted since Year 711 without formal resolution.
The docket of unresolved keys
The Bureau maintains, in the Spiral Archives under Spiral Designation Ka-219, a register known as the Docket of Unresolved Keys. It lists every request in which the Bureau has determined that no existing precedent applies, together with the reasons none applies. As of the last published recension the Docket runs to four volumes. The following is the first folio of Volume III, reproduced without amendment:
- Ka-219/III/1 — Request concerning a stair that descends into itself; no precedent; referred to Bureau of Ambivalent Geometry.
- Ka-219/III/2 — Request concerning the sounding of a bell on a floor whose number has been vacated; no precedent; referred to Bureau of Acoustic Appeals.
- Ka-219/III/3 — Request concerning an object catalogued before it was made; no precedent; referred to Bureau of Anachronistic Cataloguing.
Criticism and defence
The principal criticism of the Bureau is that its findings, being applicative, do not establish general precedent, and that a question settled on Floor 212 must be settled afresh on Floor 213. The Bureau's answer, stated in the preamble to its Standing Note on Recurrence, is that general precedent is the business of the Concordances and the Bureau merely "turns the key in the lock as found." Whether this is modesty or evasion has been debated in the Manual of Adjudicative Protocol, Volume XXXIV, and the debate has never concluded.
The Bureau of Contextual Reconciliation has objected that the Bureau's habit of referring matters outward rather than deciding them has made it, in practice, a forwarding office. The Bureau has not disputed the characterization. In Year 748 it recorded the objection in its minutes and forwarded it, on the ground that the competence to answer lay elsewhere.
Clerks of the Bureau are issued the Manual's Declarative Principles for reference but are forbidden to consult Volume I during a sitting, on the ground that it is the presiding officer's volume and is kept chained.
See also
-
MS 5052.50
Committee of Ambiguous Precedent
The Committee of Ambiguous Precedent is a standing body of the Tower entrusted with determining which prior rulings may be cited i…
-
MS 7156.40
Custodian of Precedent
The Custodian of Precedent is the officer of the Office of the Custodian charged with determining which prior rulings bind a curre…
-
MS 9128.79
Precedent Collators
Precedent Collators are the sworn officers of the Office of Precedent Curation charged with reading, comparing, and reconciling th…
-
MS 2913.14
Annex 7, Clause 812 of the Third Concordance
Annex 7, Clause 812 of the Third Concordance is the provision establishing the Standing Survey of Unnumbered Floor, the administra…
-
MS 7329.32
Protocol M-2001
Protocol M-2001 is a standing instrument of the Division of Precedent & Protocol, first sealed on the eleventh of Amsel, 2001, and…
-
MS 3171.38
Court of Binding Precedent
Court of Binding Precedent is the standing tribunal charged with adjudicating the validity of appended materials upon the shelves …
Referenced by
- MS 0352.50 The Division of Precedent Amp Protocol
Readers also asked
Bureau of Ambivalent Geometry: who are they?
The Bureau of Ambivalent Geometry is a regulatory body established under the authority of the Seventh Concordance to oversee all structures, fixtures, and spatial constructs whose inherent properties or functional purpos…
Bureau of Ambivalent GeometryCentral Licensing Bureau: who are they?
The Central Licensing Bureau is the principal instrument-issuing authority of the Tower, empowered under the Third Concordance to grant, condition, suspend, and — in narrowly defined circumstances — recall authorizations…
Central Licensing BureauBureau of Contextual Reconciliation: how is it conducted?
The Bureau of Contextual Reconciliation is a formal committee chartered under the Supplemental Addendum to the Seventeenth Concordance to arbitrate disputes regarding the dimensional placement of archival holdings. It is…
Bureau of Contextual ReconciliationBureau Findings: who are they?
The Bureau produces four primary classes of findings: Declarative, Reconciliatory, Provisional, and Advisory. These are distinguished not by topic but by the procedural posture from which they are issued. Declarative Fin…
Bureau FindingsPassages cited from this record
-
Where two instruments speak and neither yields, the Bureau shall not choose between them but shall record the speaking and adjourn.
Concordance 44, Annex 12, clause 9
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9268.05 Second Concordance, Annex 19
- MS 9781.91 Bureau of Applicative Concordance
- MS 0743.12 Bureau of Vertical Concordance
Because you consulted