The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Bureau of Spent Policies

MS 6791.06 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Bureau of Spent Policies is the administrative office charged with auditing Concordances that have been consumed by their own operation, and with preparing those documents for the Cremation of Spent Policies. It occupies the whole of Floor 40 and a disputed half-landing above it, and is the only Bureau whose seal is printed in ash rather than ink. The Bureau does not draft policy, does not interpret policy, and has twice declined on procedural grounds to say which policy it is currently auditing.

Its founding is dated to the winter of 2,344, when the Bureau of Precedential Analysis certified that a minor treasury ordinance had "expired of its own clauses before reaching the end of its final paragraph" (Bureau of Precedential Analysis, finding 2,344/17). No office existed to take receipt of the expiry. The Bureau was created within the month, largely to give the finding somewhere to live.

Procedure

Documents arrive at Floor 40 through a single aperture, three quarters of a span wide, on the ground that wider apertures encourage bulked submissions. Each is entered into the Ash Register and set on a shelf in order of arrival, not importance, a rule the First Recension calls "the only order the office could agree upon" (Bureau of Static Inventory, First Recension, Preface). A policy is then read aloud once, in full, by two clerks in alternation. Where the second clerk reads a clause the first clerk has already read, the clause is struck rather than repeated. Most documents survive the reading. Many do not.

The Bureau works to the seventy-day review-and-objection period of the Guild of Lexical Scrutineers, though it has never observed the period in seventy days. Clerks describe the schedule as "advisory in the direction of the Scrutineers" — a phrase since taken up in the Bureau of Procedural Coherence and disputed there for four years.

The office keeps its own furnace, distinct from the crucible used at the calendrical Cremation of Spent Policies. Page ash from the furnace is weighed and boxed. It is not permitted to leave Floor 40 except as seal material.

Notable rulings

In 2,381 the Bureau declared a question mark spent. The mark had appeared, with some insistence, at the end of Clause 6 of a boundary ordinance and had been copied forward into nine recensions without any clerk resolving it. The Bureau's position was that the mark had lost the capacity to require an answer and had become punctuation. The Bureau of Precedential Analysis concurred; the Bureau of Closed Brackets objected at length, holding that punctuation of any kind lay outside the Bureau's competence. The objection was filed, sealed, and has not been opened. Under a standing order of 2,382, the mark is still held uncremated in a side drawer, and a note on the drawer reads: "Do not incinerate the question mark while the objection is live."

The Bureau has also ruled on the Seventh Concordance, Revision 4 and on thirteen of the nineteen clauses of Concordance 712, several of which were later found to have been spent before the Bureau had developed a term for spentness. The resulting refunds of procedural priority took two Registers to reconcile.

Dispute with the Bureau of Registry

A long-standing disagreement concerns whether a policy is spent when performed or spent when listed. The Bureau of Registry has held, since an undated annex to the Fourth Recension, that spending occurs at the moment of listing and that performance is merely the occasion for it. The Bureau of Spent Policies holds the reverse, on the ground that a policy performed unsuccessfully cannot be spent and a policy merely listed has not been performed at all.

"A policy is not spent until it has been used up, and a policy used up is used up in the using, not in the writing down of the using."

— Bureau of Spent Policies, Reply to the Registry, 3,109

The Registry has never answered this reply, which the Bureau counts, quietly, as a concession. Neither office will cremate a document the other has listed, so a class of policies remains suspended between Floors 40 and 112, unspent and unusable, in a condition clerks call the holding state.

Staff and grievances

The Bureau maintains eleven clerks, one Regulator of Weights, and a porter whose sole duty is to confirm that the aperture has been closed after each submission. The position is not considered onerous.

The most cited grievance belongs to Clerk Ondrey, who in 2,714 requested transfer on the ground that he had been assigned to read aloud for nine consecutive years and could no longer read any document silently without hearing it. The request was refused, then granted, then found to have been granted in the wrong Register and refused retroactively. Ondrey's correspondence, boxed and sealed in 2,722, occupies one and a half shelves and is catalogued under the heading On Reading Aloud. He remains on Floor 40.

Relationship to other offices

Spent and fractured nibs used in the reading are returned to the Bureau of Instrument Returns quarterly. The Bureau has no authority over time, which belongs to the Vault of Spent Hours under the oversight of the Regulator of Hours, and it has twice been asked to stop referring to an idle afternoon as "a spent hour" — a usage the Bureau of Procedural Coherence ruled "an ordinary error" in 3,002 and has not reconsidered.

Disputed boundary marks formerly loaned to the Gallery of Spent Delimiters are no longer sent from Floor 40, following an incident in 2,988 in which a mark was cremated twice. The Bureau's explanation, entered without comment, is that it had been listed once.


Correspondence should be addressed to the Bureau of Spent Policies, Floor 40, by the aperture. Submissions are accepted on Tuesdays. Do not bring your own ash.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Guild of Lexical Scrutineers: who are they?

The Guild of Lexical Scrutineers is the senior administrative body responsible for the procedural oversight of all Lexical Audit processes within the Tower. Established under the Forty-First Concordance, the Guild’s prim…

Guild of Lexical Scrutineers
Bureau of Procedural Coherence: who are they?

Bureau of Procedural Coherence is a first-order administrative body within the Directorate of Archival Coherence, charged with arbitrating and standardizing the ontological processes by which non-existent subjects are es…

Bureau of Procedural Coherence
Gallery of Spent Delimiters: where is it?

The Gallery of Spent Delimiters is a long, unlit gallery on Floor 2,308 in which are displayed the exhausted, retired, and formally cancelled boundary marks of the Tower: parentheses, brackets, quotation marks, dashes, g…

Gallery of Spent Delimiters
Cremation of Spent Policies: how is it conducted?

The Cremation of Spent Policies is a bi-annual calendrical rite by which a subset of the Tower’s superseded or logically exhausted Concordances are incinerated in The Aperture of Annulled Echoes, a designated combustion …

Cremation of Spent Policies

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.