The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Bureau of Phenomenal Triage

MS 5586.88 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Bureau of Phenomenal Triage is the Tower body charged with the preliminary categorization of acoustic phenomena, determining by which of nine established matrices a given sound is to be routed onward. It occupies the eastern arm of Floor 11 under a low vaulted ceiling of uncertain date, and it does not investigate phenomena, record them at length, or resolve them. It decides only where they ought to go next. The distinction is enforced with some severity: the Bureau's founding instrument, Concordance 12/Alpha, Clause 3, forbids any officer of the Bureau from "completing a thought that belongs to another floor."

The Bureau is frequently confused with the Acoustic Reconciliation Bureau, an auxiliary body of the Spire of Auditory Phantoms that shares its concern for auditory anomalies but triages them at a later stage. The two have been confused in writing at least forty times since Year 400, and the resulting misroutings are the subject of a standing grievance that the Bureau has never succeeded in having heard.

Function and the nine matrices

A sound arriving at the Bureau is assessed against the nine matrices of preliminary categorization, which are numbered in order of increasing reluctance: Matrix I for sounds heard by at least one auditor, Matrix IV for sounds reported only by surfaces, and Matrix IX, the so-called Silent Matrix, for sounds whose existence is asserted but whose occurrence is universally contested. Assignment to Matrix IX is not a judgment that the sound is unreal; the Bureau is careful to say that it is a judgment that the sound is someone else's.

The matrices are set out in the provisional ruling of Year 388 and have never been formally revised, though three of them have been amended by marginal note to the point where the original text is unreadable. Clause 7 of the same ruling permits an assessment officer to consult the Bestiary of Unseen Behaviors only after the arrival has been formally registered, a sequencing requirement that has caused trouble more than once.

"Nothing is triaged before it is written, and nothing is written before it is triaged. The sequence is a matter of etiquette, not of logic."

— Seventh Addendum to the Third Concordance, Annex 2

The winter of the misrouted bell

The Bureau's reputation for scrupulousness rests, oddly, on a failure. In the second winter of Year 411 a sustained tone was reported from the western stairwell of Floor 11 and was assessed, under some haste, as Matrix II. Fourteen days later the tone was reassessed as Matrix VII by a different officer reading the same file. The discrepant assignments produced a routing conflict that consumed the better part of two months, during which the phenomenon continued to be audible on every floor above the eleventh and was, by general agreement, nobody's responsibility.

The episode ended when the Triage Subcommittee for Ambiguous Architectonics, which had been asked to arbitrate, declined to do so on the grounds that the matter concerned sound and not structure. Its ruling is preserved in the archive of Hall of Procedural Anomalies and is worth quoting for its brevity:

"The Subcommittee finds the question to be one of audibility. It finds, further, that it has no opinion on audibility and does not wish to acquire one."

— Triage Subcommittee for Ambiguous Architectonics, Ruling Sigma-14

The eventual resolution is attributed to Deputy Registrar Ilve Morrant, who observed that the tone had been neither confirmed nor denied by anyone with authority to do either, and recommended it be entered as a pending arrival. The recommendation was accepted. The tone is still audible at the eleventh-floor landing and its file is still open.

Relationship to the Protocol Alpha family

There is a persistent misapprehension, widespread among junior officers, that the Bureau administers Triage Protocol Alpha. It does not. The Bureau of Phenomenal Triage operates a preliminary categorization matrix and has no competence over the initial sorting of anomalous materials, which falls to the sorting floor of the Bureau of Anomalous Materials under the Protocol itself. The names are similar; the jurisdictions are not.

The confusion is at least partly the Bureau's own doing, since its intake form has carried a line reading "Alpha status" since a clerical revision of Year 427, despite the fact that no field on the form pertains to it. The line is left blank. Clerks are instructed to leave it blank. A note pinned in the intake room, signed by an officer whose name has faded, reads: The line is left blank. No further instruction has ever been issued, and none has been requested.

The Morrant grievance

Morrant, who served the Bureau for thirty-one years, spent the last nine of them petitioning the Bureau of Appointments for a correction of the record. The point at issue was not the winter of the misrouted bell, in which Morrant was exonerated, but a footnoted reference in the original Year 411 assessment attributing the discrepancy to "haste on the part of a junior officer." Morrant was, at the time, Assistant Registrar of eleven years' standing and was not junior. He requested that the phrase be struck.

The Bureau of Appointments performed an initial triage of the petition for formal completeness and returned it as complete. It then submitted the case to the Board of Equitable Review, which referred it back, noting that the record it sought to amend had already been certified under On the Integrity of Absence and could not be altered without a finding that the alteration was required to restore coherence. Morrant argued, in a memorandum of commendable restraint, that the footnote did not contradict the nature of its own cataloguing and therefore required no correction under the Principle of Phenomenal Coherence. The Board agreed with him and dismissed the petition on that basis.

He refiled in the spring. The second petition was returned by the Bureau of Appointments for formal completeness. Morrant did not pursue it.

Holdings and access

The Bureau's working files occupy one hundred and eight linear feet of shelving in the eastern arm and are open to inspection by appointment. The Auditory Permit Office maintains a reading station at the arm's northern end, and arrivals assessed under the Standard Conditions of Provisional Protocol 888-A are held there for a minimum of nine days before removal. Visitors are asked to remove their boots at the threshold and to make no sound while the matrices are being consulted, out of consideration for the officers, who work by ear.

The Bureau presently holds no position on whether the tone on the west stair is diminishing. It has been asked. It has replied that the question belongs to a different floor.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Floor 11: where is it?

Floor 11 is the designated Receipt of Discrepancy, an administrative processing hub situated between Floor 2 and Floor 19. Its primary function is the triage, logging, and preliminary resolution of inconsistencies arisin…

Floor 11
Bureau of Anomalous Materials: who are they?

The Bureau of Anomalous Materials is a standing custodial body of the Tower charged with the intake, sorting, stabilization, and release of materials whose behaviour cannot be reconciled with the ordinary properties of t…

Bureau of Anomalous Materials
Provisional Protocol 888-A: how is it conducted?

Provisional Protocol 888-A is an archival mandate, ratified under the authority of the Seventeenth Concordance, which establishes and enforces conditions of "ambient stasis" within the designated areas of Floor 888. Its …

Provisional Protocol 888-A

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.