Barber of Floor 112, Annex B Paradox
MS 5947.53 · Practices and doctrines
Statement of the Argument
The argument runs, in the form settled by the Registry of Unsettled Arguments in 118 A.T., as follows: the Barber shaves those residents of Floor 112, Annex B who do not shave themselves, and no others. The Barber is himself a resident of Floor 112, Annex B. It follows that the Barber shaves himself if and only if he does not.
Three things about this statement are worth recording. It is short; it has never been amended; and it has, in every recension since 102 A.T., been printed in the same twelve-point serif as the rest of the Registry, which the Typographic Concordance of 140 A.T. later required of all unsettled arguments exceeding six lines. Nothing in the argument's wording has ever been in dispute. Everything else about it has.
Annex B and the Question of the Post
The difficulty begins not with logic but with premises of fact. Concordance 12-A, clause 7, designates Floor 112, Annex B as the administrative annex of the Paradox Control Bureau, and clause 9 enumerates the posts attached to the annex. The barber's post is the ninth. But the Bureau has never been able to produce a sealed commission for the post, and the enumerations of clause 9 were rearranged twice, in 134 A.T. and again in 209 A.T., without any of the three recorded recensions being withdrawn.
The practical consequence is that the Barber — whoever holds the post, or holds it in the absence of a commission — has never been conclusively established to be a resident of the annex he serves. Librarian Osper Vane, reporting on the annex in the winter of 209 A.T., observed that the argument "requires the Barber to reside where he is catalogued, and the catalogue is precisely the thing that will not settle" (Vane, Second Inspection of the Lower Annexes, 210 A.T.). Vane's recommendation, that the post be converted to a visiting appointment, was not adopted; it recurs in every subsequent inspection.
Attempts at Resolution
The first serious attempt belongs to Concordance 14-B, which declared the argument "not unsettled but under-staffed," holding that the contradiction arose from expecting one barber to serve the annex's full resident roll. Under-staffing was to be remedied by the appointment of a second barber, after which neither would shave himself and the argument would lapse. Two barbers were appointed in 171 A.T. Neither could be found to shave himself. The argument did not lapse; it doubled, and the Registry, per its standing rule of 122 A.T., was obliged to register the second instance separately. The supplement count passed 2,000 that year.
The Paradox Control Bureau next attempted procedural containment. Under PA-872, Annex Ω — the designation later borrowed for the Autocitational Paradox, on grounds the Bureau has never explained — the argument was to be "held" rather than resolved: registered, ribboned, and left. This worked as well as anything has. The counting of supplementary ribbons continued without interruption, and the Ribbon Ledger of the Registry records no year since 102 A.T. in which the argument did not generate at least four.
"The argument is not to be settled. It is to be kept, and keeping it is the whole of the work, and the work is not finished."
— Seventh Concordance, Annex Γ
Dispute Between Offices
The Office of Structural Paradox and the Paradox Control Bureau have differed for more than a century on what "sterilized" means. The Office maintains that a contradiction which cannot be carried out of its annex is, in the administrative sense, no contradiction at all; the Bureau maintains that the argument is carried out of its annex every time it is cited, and it is cited constantly. The Bureau's ledger records 11,400 citations between 240 and 268 A.T. alone.
The Third Concordance weighed in against the Office in 246 A.T., holding at Annex 11 that "a defused paradox is a paradox the more securely fixed," a phrase that has since been quoted by both offices in support of opposite conclusions. No further Concordance has addressed the argument directly. The Office of Structural Paradox did, however, establish the Mending Protocol for Floor 90 partly as a rehearsal for Floor 112; the Paradox Mender for Floor 90 has twice declined to be seconded to the annex, citing its terms of appointment.
Condition of the Annex
Access to the argument is by written application under the Architectural Paradox Protocols, which govern the neighbouring Penrose Stairwell Annex and were extended to Floor 112, Annex B in 301 A.T. Applications are heard on the second and fourth of the month. A visiting researcher may bring one pencil. The argument itself is not to be brought into the reading room.
Nothing in the record now permits the Barber to be named, dismissed, or confirmed in post, and no inspection has asked him to shave. The annex maintains its roster, its ninth post, and its 4,000-odd ribbons, and the argument continues to generate supplementary material at the rate the Registry expects of it. The Axiomatic Atrium keeps a duplicate of the 102 A.T. filing for comparison; the two have never been found to differ.
See also
-
MS 3425.59
The Barber of Floor 112, Annex B Paradox
The Barber of Floor 112, Annex B Paradox is a seminal, unsettled argument within the Hall of Unsettled Arguments, generated over 4…
-
MS 4588.37
Floor 909, The Hall of Unsettled Arguments
Floor 909, The Hall of Unsettled Arguments is the primary adjudicatory and archival space for procedural disputes lacking a conclu…
-
MS 9346.26
Hall of Procedural Anomalies
Hall of Procedural Anomalies is a designated procedural vessel within Floor 909, The Hall of Unsettled Arguments, responsible for …
-
MS 7922.04
Hall of Whispering Margins
The Hall of Whispering Margins is the procedural body and physical chamber on Floor 909, The Hall of Unsettled Arguments responsib…
-
MS 8360.18
The 211 Paradox
The 211 Paradox is the standing name, within the Paradox Control Bureau's registers, for a recurrence first recorded on Floor 211 …
-
MS 6108.51
Hall of Precedents
The Hall of Precedents is the principal physical repository and consultation space for the bound and unbound codices of Standing P…
Referenced by
- MS 5517.17 The Stack of Open Argument Annex Alpha
Readers also asked
Hall of Unsettled Arguments: where is it?
The Hall of Unsettled Arguments is a major adjudicatory and archival precinct located on Floor 909, primarily responsible for the cataloguing, maintenance, and procedural management of disputes that have resisted formal …
Hall of Unsettled ArgumentsFloor 112, Annex B: where is it?
Floor 112, Annex B is a major administrative complex located on the one-hundred-and-twelfth floor of the Tower. It serves as the central bureau for the Department of Matriculation and is the primary repository for founda…
Floor 112, Annex BSeventh Concordance: what does it set out?
The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…
Seventh ConcordanceArchitectural Paradox Protocols: how is it conducted?
Architectural Paradox Protocols are a codified administrative framework established to manage, contain, and mitigate the inherent spatial and geometric contradictions that emerge within the Tower's architecture, particul…
Architectural Paradox ProtocolsPassages cited from this record
-
The argument is not to be settled. It is to be kept, and keeping it is the whole of the work, and the work is not finished.
Seventh Concordance, Annex Γ
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9073.90 Typographic Concordance
- MS 9550.59 Registry of Unsettled Arguments
- MS 2348.05 PA-872, Annex Ω
- MS 7214.15 Concordance 14-B
Because you consulted