The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Axial Symmetry

MS 0575.35 · Practices and doctrines

Axial Symmetry is the property, ascribed to a floor, an object, or a body of persons, of admitting a dividing axis across which its parts correspond exactly. Within the Tower the term is technical and carries legal weight: to describe a thing as axially symmetric is not an observation but a determination, and determinations are appealable. The governing principles are collected in the Symmetry Edicts, which are assessed operationally by the biannual Symmetry Audit under the conduct and ruling of the Directorate of Form and Symmetry. Where an object possesses no counterpart across its axis, the case is not treated as a failure of symmetry but is referred to the corollaries of the Theorem of Negational Symmetry.

Axial Symmetry is distinguished in the standing recensions from bilateral and radial symmetry, although the distinction was refined so often between 1388 and 1402 that the three terms are now held to differ chiefly in the axis, and not in the holding.

Definition and the question of the axis

The Edicts define the axis of a floor as "the line of division upon which the Directorate has ruled, or shall be ruled upon in due course" (Symmetry Edicts, Annex 3, clause ii). The definition is circular by design. It permits the Directorate to rule an axis into existence on any holding where correspondence is discovered after the fact, and it permits the same axis to be withdrawn where correspondence ceases. Two hundred and sixteen axes were withdrawn in the winter of 1409 alone, most of them on the upper floors, following a survey that found the numbering on either side of them to disagree.

The Symmetry Elevator is held to be axially symmetric in respect of its shaft and not in respect of its car, the interior of which is fitted with a mirror intended to complete the correspondence. Clerks have historically objected that the mirror completes nothing and merely doubles the fault.

The Axial Ascent

Axial Symmetry is most closely associated with the Axial Ascent, the vertical thoroughfare whose central line is claimed as the Tower's principal axis. The claim has been disputed since 1431, when the Auditors of Axial Variance contested the Keepers of the Ascent's right to the stair, and both offices have maintained the dispute continuously. The Auditors hold that an axis cannot be vertical, on the ground that an axis divides and a vertical line divides nothing that is not already above or below it. The Keepers hold that this is precisely the point.

"That which is above is not the counterpart of that which is below, and no stair has ever been symmetric with itself."

— Auditors of Axial Variance, Memorial of 1431, appended to the dispute file

The Spiral Staircase of Presumed Symmetry was audited separately on the ground that it is neither vertical nor horizontal and therefore falls outside the dispute. The Verification of the Spiral Staircase of Presumed Symmetry of 1477 established that its treads correspond across a point rather than a line, which the Directorate declined to classify, noting only that the case was "not axial, and not yet otherwise."

A differing account of the axis

Scholars disagree whether the axis is a property of the holding or of the record of the holding. The received view, set out in the Edicts and defended at length by Theodore Vane, holds that the axis attaches to the thing itself and that an auditor who cannot find it has merely been careless. A dissenting line, most fully stated in the Fifth Recension of the Concordance on Measures, argues that the axis is documentary: a floor is symmetric exactly to the extent that its catalogue entry can be written symmetrically, and floors whose inventories resist this are simply described across fewer lines.

The dissent has never been formally adopted, but it explains certain procedural habits. Where a holding is found to lack an axis altogether, the auditor is directed to record the absence in symmetric language — "no counterpart on either side" is the prescribed formula — and the finding is then entered as a determination of axial symmetry by default. Under clause ix of the Ordinance of Paired Entries, the entry is filed twice, once in each hand, and the second copy is not to be read.

Measurement and the correction of the centre line

Auditors measure position against the centre line established by the Plumb-Line Registry, a body that has never confirmed the date of its founding and keeps no office hours. Where correspondence fails by a margin under one inch, the Registry corrects the centre line rather than the holding; where it fails by more, the holding is referred to the Directorate and the Registry adjusts its own instruments. In practice the correction of instruments accounts for the greater part of the Registry's activity, and the Operational Audit of 1462 noted that the Registry had corrected its plumb lines forty-one times in a single quarter without once adjusting a floor.

Notable incidents

The most cited failure of the doctrine occurred on Floor 218 in the winter of 1409. The floor was found to be symmetric across its length but not its width, a condition not then provided for. The auditor of the day, a clerk named Halloran Pike, ruled that the floor possessed an axis of the second order running diagonally through a storeroom, and appended a note to his return stating that the storeroom had been cleared to permit the measurement. A later inquiry found that the storeroom was cleared to permit a delivery. Pike's ruling was struck, the axis dismissed, and the storeroom restored, though the note survives in the file and is regarded by some as the only honest return in the series.

The Symmetry of Absent Footnotes is sometimes treated as an appendix to the axial case, since footnotes removed from an entry leave the entry symmetrically empty and the axis falls across the gap. This is not the Directorate's position; the Directorate has ruled, twice, that an absence is not a part. The ruling is under reference to the Edicts and has not been finally resolved.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Auditors of Axial Variance: who are they?

The Auditors of Axial Variance are a sub-guild of the Guild of Auditors, affiliated with the Clerks of the Spiral and charged with the mediation of procedural mediation and with the resolution of cartographic disputes wi…

Auditors of Axial Variance
Axial Ascent: what is it for?

The Axial Ascent is a principal vertical conduit of the Tower, following the central well of the Major Stairs while bypassing its local landings by means of graded ramps and pneumatic lifts. It is distinguished from the …

Axial Ascent
Directorate of Form and Symmetry: who are they?

Directorate of Form and Symmetry is a regulatory body operating under the Directorate of Archival Coherence, charged with enforcing structural and representational standards for catalogued subjects across the Tower. Its …

Directorate of Form and Symmetry
Keepers of the Ascent: who are they?

The authority of the Keepers of the Ascent is derived from three primary documents. The founding text is Ordinance 12, "On the Solemnization of Vertical Transit," which outlines their core duties of witness, sealing, and…

Keepers of the Ascent

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.