The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Archivist-Prefect Valence

MS 3995.93 · Persons

Archivist-Prefect Valence is the current Registrar of Preliminaries, an office within the Office of the Archivist-General concerned with the filing of events before they occur. The rank of Archivist-Prefect sits third among the four Valence ranks recognized by that Office, beneath Archivist-Primus Valence and above Archivist-Specialist Valence, and is held concurrently with the registrarship by long-standing convention rather than by any written instrument. The present holder is the eleventh Archivist-Prefect Valence since the registrarship was separated from the Prefect of Juridical Annexes in the 19th Spiral.

The registrarship

The Registrar of Preliminaries maintains the Preliminary Register, a running index of events that have been scheduled but not yet performed. An event may be entered in the Register at any point after it has been proposed and before it has occurred; entry does not cause the event, nor does omission prevent it, a distinction the Registrar has restated in every annual return since the 31st Spiral. What entry does secure is a number, and with a number a place on the shelves.

The Register occupies the western bay of Floor 204, where it is kept in spiral-bound fascicles on a rolling cart. The cart is not to be leaned upon. Visiting clerks are asked to leave the bay by the north stair, as the south door opens onto a floor.

Archivist-Prefect Valence's most consequential interpretation of the role — that the duty of filing future events extends to annual weather for unascended floors — was set out in a ruling now cited simply as the Weather Determination. It has never been revoked, though three attempts have been made to amend it.

The Weather Determination

The Determination arose from an inquiry of the 34th Spiral concerning floors above the last confirmed ascent. Since no expedition had returned from those floors, no weather had been observed there, and none could be filed. Archivist-Prefect Valence held that the Register records what will occur, not what has been seen, and that the absence of a returning expedition was not evidence of absent weather. Annual returns for the unascended floors have been filed continuously since.

The returns are brief. Most entries read overcast, unremitting, no wind recorded at the landing, and the whole set is filed together in a single folio of moderate thickness. Critics have observed that the weather above the last ascent has been unvarying for eleven spirals, to which the Registrar has replied that this is itself a finding.

Disputes with the Archivist-Logician

The most persistent disagreement over the registrarship is jurisdictional, not meteorological. Archivist-Logician K. Valence has argued, in a memorandum of the 33rd Spiral and in two supplements since, that an event acquires its identity only when performed, and that a Preliminary Register is therefore a register of intentions rather than of events. On that reading, the Registrar files proposals, and the Weather Determination files nothing at all.

"To number a thing is not to promise it; but a number that is never spent remains a number, and the shelves are long."

— Archivist-Logician K. Valence, Memorandum on the Preliminary Register, 33rd Spiral

Archivist-Prefect Valence has declined to reply in writing, on the ground that a reply would itself be an event requiring filing, and has instead continued the annual returns. K. Valence, who is not the Logician and has asked that this be noted, has twice been asked to carry messages between the two and now delegates the duty.

Relation to the Valence ranks

Because the title of Archivist-Primus Valence is held by whoever is composing an unconcluded work of jurisprudence, it is not fixed to an individual and cannot be appealed to as a superior. Archivist-Prefect Valence has on four occasions held the Primus title for the duration of a draft and on four occasions relinquished it by concluding the draft, a habit that has made the rank difficult to cite. Archivist-Emeritus Valence has observed that a title which changes hands with the paragraph is of limited use in settling a dispute, and that the Registrar's practice of concluding her drafts promptly is therefore "an inconvenience dressed as a courtesy."

The Registrar is not empowered to execute a Valence Protocol; that authority rests with a certified Archivist-Specialist Valence alone. Requests to the Registrar for a Protocol are routinely redirected to Floor 306, where Archivist-Lieutenant E. Valence acts as Proctor and keeps a queue.

Criticisms and the amended Concordance

Prefect Alaric has maintained since the 32nd Spiral that the registrarship duplicates the work of the Prefect of Juridical Annexes and should be absorbed into it. The claim was partly upheld: the Third Concordance, Annex 7 was amended to require the Registrar to countersign annex filings. The amendment does not say where the countersignature is to be placed, and in practice it is placed on the reverse of the filing, which the Annexes office does not read.

A separate objection concerns the Register's numbering of events that are later withdrawn. Withdrawn entries are struck through and retained, which has led to stretches of the Register in which every fourth or fifth line is struck, producing an appearance of erasure that the Registrar has declined to correct. Prefect Aris has asked that withdrawn entries be gathered into an appendix; the request is pending before the Office of the Archivist-General and has been pending since the 35th Spiral.

No finding of fault has ever been entered against the registrarship. The Prefect's 38th-Spiral review noted simply that the Register "records a great deal, and is legible."

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Archivist-Primus Valence: how is it conducted?

The title Archivist-Primus Valence is the senior of the four Valence ranks recognised by the Office of the Archivist-General, and the only one that is not conferred by instrument. It is held by whoever is, at the moment …

Archivist-Primus Valence
Archivist-Specialist Valence: how is it conducted?

Archivist-Specialist Valence is a distinct and separate title, designated under Clause 17.β of the Third Concordance for a certified specialist within the Office of the Archivist. The designation is not a rank within the…

Archivist-Specialist Valence
Office of the Archivist-General: who are they?

The Office of the Archivist-General is the administrative apparatus responsible for executing the directives and managing the logistical prerogatives of the Archivist General. It is distinguished from the Archivist Gener…

Office of the Archivist-General
Prefect Aris Thorn: who were they?

Prefect Aris Thorn was a clerk-provisional of the Third Age of Refurbishment, noted primarily for his prolonged and ultimately unsuccessful petition to be recognized as the administrative heir to Prefect Aris. His case, …

Prefect Aris Thorn

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.