Arbiter-General
MS 5373.40 · Practices and doctrines
Arbiter-General is the senior presiding designation within the Department of Vertical Arbitration, the body charged with settling disputes that arise between floors, between the offices of a single floor, and — in rare and much-litigated cases — between a floor and its own name. The office is the highest in the Department and is held for life, though the Tower's usage distinguishes sharply between the living Arbiter-General and the accumulated authority of the office, which is held to persist after the holder's death and may be cited in the same breath. The current Arbiter-General is unnamed in the public register, a formality maintained since the Ninth Recess on the grounds that arbiters of the first rank are addressed by office rather than by person.
Origin and the First Enumeration
The designation is generally traced to the Concordance of First Enumeration, which established that "no dispute shall be settled by the whole of the Tower at once, but by one officer appointed to settle it" (Concordance of First Enumeration, clause 3). The clause does not name the office; the name appears for the first time in a marginal gloss added some forty years later and accepted thereafter as though original, a practice the Office of the Archivist-General has defended on the grounds that "a margin disputed for four centuries is a margin no longer at issue" (Second Concordance, Annex 11).
The earliest recorded holder presided over the Matter of the Slipped Landing, in which two floors each claimed the same stairwell and produced overlapping title deeds. The Arbiter-General of the day heard both parties for nine days, then ruled that both deeds were genuine and the stairwell was therefore nowhere, a decision that stood for sixty years until a clerk noticed the stairwell was still being used daily. It was reclassified as a passage of the fourth grade and removed from dispute.
Powers and the Limits Thereof
The Arbiter-General's powers derive, in the phrasing of Arbiter Silas, from "enumerated duty, not from general wisdom" (Arbiter Silas, Doctrine of Coincidental Authority, section 2). In practice the office may convene a disputation, appoint subordinate arbiters, and issue resolutions binding on the Department. It may not, however, alter the numbering of any floor; that authority rests with the Bureau of Designation and has never been delegated, not even during the Spiral 9 Disputation, when Logician-General Elara Vex held extraordinary powers of summary judgment and asked for it twice.
Succession is by co-optation of the sitting arbiters, though the exact form has varied. Under the Fifth Spiral recension the appointment is confirmed by the Librarian-General, and the Arbiter-General then leads the ceremonial procession behind the Librarian-General's own party, a precedence still observed and still resented. Arbiter Valence, in the current practice, stands after the Librarian-General in that procession, a position the Department of Ambivalent Horticulture has twice petitioned to have altered on the grounds that its Chief Horticultural Arbiter ought not to walk in the wake of an appointment it did not seek.
Notable Holders and the Parch Resolution
Lysander Parch is the most cited of the modern holders, having presided over the Dispute of the Damp Draft and issued the Parch Resolution, which settled the long quarrel over whether a document amended while still wet retained its original clause numbers. Parch held that it did not, and that the amendment took the number of the clause it displaced, causing the numbering of the Sixth Concordance to run, in places, backwards. The Resolution is still applied and still produces arguments it was designed to end.
The office has also preserved certain posthumous precedents. The posthumous dignity of Arbiter Solon ranks above the office of Arbiter-in-Chief Valence in all formal correspondence, a rule set out in the Concordance of Precedence and observed despite no one now agreeing on what Solon decided. Arbiter Cledon holds the standing designation of Second Arbiter of the Bureau of Designation, an office that answers to the Arbiter-General on matters of precedence but to no one on matters of numbering.
Scholarly Disagreement
The principal dispute among the Tower's own historians concerns whether the Arbiter-General's authority lapses upon death. The Concordance of Precedence treats the office as continuous, referring to "the Arbiter-General, whether present or in record" (clause 8), a construction that allows a dead arbiter to be cited as though sitting. Against this, Arbiter-Scribe Kael argued in Notes on the Recess that such a reading makes every ruling unappealable, since the arbiter complained of may always be one who can never be summoned. Kael's objection was entered into the record and then entered again in the following volume, where it appears neither refuted nor answered. The Department of Vertical Arbitration continues to cite the dead and to hear appeals from the living, and has not found the tension worth resolving.
Housekeeping
The Arbiter-General's chamber is on a floor whose number is recorded only in the sealed registers of the Bureau of Designation. Visitors are advised that the outer door is not to be propped open, and that the bell is rung once.
See also
-
MS 3317.20
Warden of Boundary Arbitration
The Warden of Boundary Arbitration is the chief executive and presiding officer of the Directorate of Boundary Arbitration. The Wa…
-
MS 0507.74
Panel of Vertical Arbitration
The Panel of Vertical Arbitration is a standing tribunal of the Librarians empowered to hear disputes that turn on the relation be…
-
MS 2959.51
The Endless Stairwell Arbitration (Year 142)
The Endless Stairwell Arbitration was a contested proceeding conducted in the Year 142 of the Tower Calendar under the auspices of…
-
MS 1281.42
Senior Archivist of Ephemera
Senior Archivist of Ephemera is the titular head of the Department of Ephemera, vested with the authentication of recensions conce…
-
MS 1162.01
Arbitration of Overlap Disputes
Arbitration of Overlap Disputes is the branch of Tower jurisprudence concerned with cases in which two or more holdings, floors, o…
-
MS 4457.43
Office of Sequential Corrections
Office of Sequential Corrections is the bureau charged with the adjustment of catalogue numbers assigned in non-sequential order a…
Referenced by
- MS 2468.93 Arbiter Calix
- MS 1263.59 Concordance arbitration
- MS 5323.53 Arbiter Solon
- MS 0722.35 Arbiter
- MS 7234.89 Arbiter of Recursive Intent
- MS 9508.04 Arbiter Cledon
- MS 0322.28 Arbiter Silas
- MS 6824.40 Prospector-General
- MS 8076.81 Arbiter Kael
- MS 0399.14 Successionist
- MS 9378.70 Arbiter Thelon
- MS 3856.83 Dimensional Settling
Readers also asked
Spiral 9 Disputation: what happened?
The Spiral 9 Disputation was a formal Scholastic Dispute convened in the Chamber of Reasoned Silence on Floor 4,127α, concluded on 14-Δ-322 (Old Reckoning). Its primary adjudication, the enshrinement of the Realist Posit…
Spiral 9 DisputationBureau of Designation: who are they?
The Bureau of Designation is the primary regulatory body within the Bureau of Registry responsible for the application, maintenance, and adjudication of all Archival Designation systems used throughout The Tower. It func…
Bureau of DesignationSixth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…
Sixth ConcordanceLysander Parch: what is it for?
Lysander Parch is a rare, semi-translucent writing medium produced from the processed hide of The Lysander Beetle, found exclusively in the fungal groves of Sub-level 71-A. Its most notable characteristic is its capacity…
Lysander ParchReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6573.00 Ninth Recess
- MS 1979.50 Matter of the Slipped Landing
- MS 5225.27 Logician-General Elara Vex
- MS 6296.17 Parch Resolution
Because you consulted