Adherents of Casual Negation
MS 9243.15 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Adherents of Casual Negation are a minor body of the Tower, numbering at their last certified count forty-one and at their last uncertified count nine, who hold that a thing may be negated without ceremony, docket, quill, or witness, provided the negation is performed carelessly. They are not to be confused with the Adherents of the Fading Quill, who negate by inscription, nor with the Adherents of the Palimpsest, who negate by erasure; the Casual hold that both schools labour under a misapprehension of scale. Their position is set out in the short tract On Not Bothering (Floor 404, Scriptorium 6, second recension), which is four pages long and concedes in its third page that it did not need to be written.
Doctrine
The Adherents derive their practice from a reading — disputed, but not disputed by them — of the Seventeenth Concordance, Clause VII, and specifically from the Doctrine of Casual Inclusion set out there before its nullification and subsequent unbuilding. The Casual argument runs as follows: if a thing could be included casually, it may be excluded casually, exclusion being inclusion with the sign reversed and the effort omitted.
"That which was let in by the door standing open may be let out by the same door, and no one is required to hold it."
— Seventeenth Concordance, Clause VII, as cited in On Not Bothering, page 2
Critics observe that Clause VII no longer exists in an enforceable form and that the Adherents are therefore negating under a doctrine that has itself been negated, and by the formal route at that. The Adherents accept this and describe it as convenient.
Relationship to the Schools
The School of Definitive Negation regards the Casual as irregular but harmless, on the grounds that a negation performed improperly is simply not a negation, and that the Adherents are therefore not negating at all. The School of Qualitive Negation takes the opposite view and has been drawn into correspondence. Its position, that a Negation Docket remains open to amendment until the Rite of Final Negation, is taken by the Casual as licence to open no docket whatever, since a thing not begun cannot be left unfinished.
Relations with the School of Qualitive Negation cooled in the winter of Floor 88 following the Affair of the Unmarked Door. A Casual adherent, Archivist Bellow, is recorded as having negated a door by walking through it without comment. The door was not removed. The School of Qualitive Negation spent eleven days establishing that no negation had occurred; the Casual spent none establishing that one had, and considered the matter settled. The door remains in place and is now listed in the floor inventory as disputed.
The Adherents of Anticipatory Forms have twice proposed a joint session with the Casual, on the theory that a thing may be negated before it is admitted. No session has been held. Neither body has recorded why.
The Question of the Threshold
The principal scholarly difficulty concerns the Certificate of Coherent Negation, which under Concordance 88, Clause 12, must accompany any transfer exceeding the Casual Conveyance Threshold for which a Form 88-C is required. The Casual do not issue Certificates. They maintain that the Threshold, being casual, is reached only by those who notice they have reached it.
Librarian Ostrand, in the memorandum Against the Careless (Annex 3 to the Ninth Concordance), argued that this reasoning is circular and that the Adherents have quietly built an entire school upon a definition they wrote themselves and did not circulate. The Adherents replied, in a note of one line filed forty years late, that the memorandum was "probably about something else." It is the longest document they have produced.
Numbers and the Question of Membership
The discrepancy between the certified figure of forty-one and the uncertified figure of nine arises from the Adherents' rule that attendance is not recorded, since recording is a form of ceremony. The roll is therefore kept by the simple method of whoever is in the room being counted by whoever is also in the room. In practice this has produced figures as high as sixty and as low as zero, the latter on Date 13-σ, when the room was empty and the count was nonetheless submitted.
The Librarians have not resolved the discrepancy. A proposal to require a Secondary Negation of the excess thirty-two members was referred to the Adherents of Actuality, who returned it unopened.
Holdings
The Adherents maintain no library. Their holdings, as inventoried by the visiting clerk Recorder Vell on his fourth descent, are as follows:
- one door, disputed
- four pages, second recension
- one note, filed late
- one room, uncounted since Date 12-σ
- nothing else, by preference
Recorder Vell noted in the margin that the inventory took eleven minutes and that the fourth descent had taken four years. He recommended no further visits. The recommendation was accepted, casually, and no record of its acceptance survives.
See also
-
MS 9890.13
Negated Nuggets
Negated Nuggets are processed foodstuffs officially classified under Culinary Non-Matter, as defined by Clause 29-F of the Third C…
-
MS 0617.06
The Principle of Reciprocal Negation
The Principle of Reciprocal Negation is a standing interpretive rule of the Tower holding that any proposition negated twice is re…
-
MS 7688.93
The Ceremony Without Purpose
The Ceremony Without Purpose is the informal designation, in use since at least the fourth recension of the Ceremonial Register, f…
-
MS 1337.23
The Lost Catalogue of Negative Space
The Lost Catalogue of Negative Space is a metaphysical inventory compiled to document those areas within the Tower where spatial p…
-
MS 7386.33
Marginalia on Polian Negation
Marginalia on Polian Negation is an exegetical commentary, authored by Theoretician Vek, applying the principles of Polian Metamat…
-
MS 5302.70
Calibrated Failure
Calibrated Failure is the certified and scheduled termination of a function, apparatus, or office at a point fixed in advance and …
Referenced by
- MS 6644.31 Floor 704
Readers also asked
Certificate of Coherent Negation: what does it set out?
The Certificate of Coherent Negation is a formal accreditation, issued under the auspices of the Bureau of Coherent Truths, which attests that a given subject's primary, defining property of negation has been successfull…
Certificate of Coherent NegationSchool of Definitive Negation: who are they?
The School of Definitive Negation is a faction within Codicological Negation holding that a negation, once correctly recorded, ceases to be revisable. Where the School of Qualitive Negation treats the catalogued absence …
School of Definitive NegationSchool of Qualitive Negation: how is it conducted?
The School of Qualitive Negation is a minor but persistent interpretative faction within the broader discipline of Codicological Negation. It posits that the act of cataloguing an absence inherently bestows upon that abs…
School of Qualitive NegationSecondary Negation: how is it conducted?
Secondary Negation is the catalogued practice of negating a subject that has already been entered into a Negation Docket, performed under the jurisdictional view that a first negation does not exhaust the cataloguing obl…
Secondary NegationPassages cited from this record
-
That which was let in by the door standing open may be let out by the same door, and no one is required to hold it.
Seventeenth Concordance, Clause VII, as cited in On Not Bothering, page 2
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 0699.19 Archivist Bellow
- MS 5072.57 Librarian Ostrand
- MS 8508.09 Recorder Vell
- MS 7460.18 Casual Conveyance Threshold
Because you consulted