The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Valerius (V)

MS 7456.40 · Practices and doctrines

Valerius (V) is the fifth entry in the Valerian Register, the Tower's running census of persons bearing the name Valerius. The Register's prefatory note, drafted by the Fifth Scribe's Guild in the winter of the year recorded only as the Year of the Long Inventory, states that the numeral in a Valerius designation "denotes position in the order of recognition, not the order of birth, nor the order of death, nor any other order the reader may prefer." Valerius (V) is therefore a clerk of the fourth rank whose position in the Register was fixed by an act of recognition on Floor 8,912, and not a person of any particular age. The distinction has generated no fewer than three concordant disputes and one sealed inquiry.

Recognition and the Floor 8,912 Affair

The recognition of Valerius (V) occurred during the dispute now filed as Concordance 44-B, which governed the assignment of numerals to Valerii arriving at the Register after the seventh recension. Prior to 44-B, numerals were assigned by seniority of filing; afterward, by seniority of witness. Valerius (V) was filed by two witnesses and witnessed by one filer, a circumstance the annex did not anticipate. The Archivist Cadre ruled, by a margin of four to three, that a filer who is also a witness counts once for each capacity but not twice for the same capacity, and Valerius (V) was entered accordingly.

The ruling was appealed by the filer, Clerk Anselm of the Lower Stacks, who argued that his dual capacity should have advanced Valerius (V) to the fourth position rather than the fifth. The appeal was denied on the ground that the Register "admits no advantage from enthusiasm" (Concordance 44-B, Annex 3). Clerk Anselm's subsequent memorial on the subject, On the Multiplication of Capacities, remains unread in the Lower Stacks and is periodically reported to be damp.

The Valerius (V) Inventory

Valerius (V) is principally known for the inventory of holdings attributed to them at the time of recognition, which the Register requires and which the Archivist-Logothete Valerius Kappa once described as "the only complete inventory in the archive, and for that reason the least trusted." The inventory is preserved intact and is reproduced here in its entirety.

  • One (1) cloak, grey, with clasp, clasp unaccounted for;
  • One (1) appointment book, entries in a hand not Valerius (V)'s;
  • Three (3) keys, none matching any known door;
  • One (1) sealed letter, unopened, addressed to the Register.

The letter was opened during the third review and found to contain a request for a correction to the Register, which the Register declined to make on the ground that it had already been made. The keys were logged as "pending a door" and have remained pending.

Dispute over the Numeral

Scholarly opinion divides on whether Valerius (V) is properly the fifth Valerius or the sixth. The Manual of Auditory Demarcation, which Librarian-Scribe Valerius compiled to distinguish persons of the same name by voice alone, places Valerius (V) after Archivist-Loremaster Valerius and before the figure known as Valerius the Unnumbered. The Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII, however, argues that the Unnumbered should not occupy a position in any sequence and that the fifth position therefore belongs to the person the Manual calls sixth. The two offices have not reconciled this, and the Concordant Law provides no tie-breaking clause, a defect noted in the margin of the Commentaries in a hand that has not been identified.

"Where the Register and the Manual disagree, the Register prevails, except in matters of voice, where the Manual prevails, except where the Register has already spoken aloud."

— Concordance 44-B, Annex 7

The practical effect is that Valerius (V) is listed as fifth in writing and sixth when spoken. Visiting scholars are advised to write rather than speak the designation until the question is settled. Clerks are additionally asked not to lean on the rail of the 8,912 stairwell, which has been loose since the appeal.

Later Record and Referential Status

Valerius (V) is not to be confused with Archivist Valerius, whose total referential dissolution was recorded elsewhere in the Register and whose entry was subsequently struck. The distinction matters because the 44-B filing clerk, when asked to produce the earlier record, produced the later one, and the error propagated through two recensions before the Archivist-Proctor Silas halted it. The Proctor's memorandum on the subject is brief and ends with the observation that "a name is a shelf, and shelves are not obliged to hold only one thing."

Valerius (V) remains an active Register entry with no recorded death, departure, or reassignment. The appointment book, when last examined, contained no appointment that had not already passed. The clasp has not been recovered.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Manual of Auditory Demarcation: what does it set out?

The Manual of Auditory Demarcation is the foundational instrument of the Tower's auditory governance, authored by High Librarian Valerius and first registered in the Fourth Recension of the Manual of Boundary Integrity. …

Manual of Auditory Demarcation
Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII: how is it conducted?

Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII is the twelfth and final volume of a commentary series of uncertain total length, issued under the seal of the Librarians' Adjudicatory Panel and compiled by Librarian-Sc…

Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII
Archivist Valerius: who were they?

Archivist Valerius was a mid-level clerk in the Office of the Archivist, noted for his contentious but ultimately marginal theories regarding non-Euclidean cartography and his proposal concerning the Tetrahedral Moon. He…

Archivist Valerius
Librarian-Scribe Valerius: who were they?

Librarian-Scribe Valerius (fl. 14-Δ period, approximate floor range 12,400–12,550) was a mid-level archivist notable for his prolific, if contentious, contributions to the procedural and philosophical Concordances govern…

Librarian-Scribe Valerius

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.