The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Truncated Dodecahedron of Floor 333

MS 8550.39 · Practices and doctrines

The Truncated Dodecahedron of Floor 333 is a geometric solid proposed by the Lateralist School as an alternative to the Truncated Icosahedron of Floor 707 for the establishment of survey coordinates. It is a faceted object of ninety faces and one hundred and eighty vertices, stored since 611 in the Lateral Chamber on Floor 333 under a glass bell and a standing order that it not be rotated. It has never been adopted for general use. It remains, however, the object against which every lateral claim in the Tower is measured, and its supporters argue that this is the more demanding office.

Origin and description

The solid is first recorded in a survey return of the winter of 611, in which a party under Surveyor Adele Morn reported a ninety-faced object resting on a plinth in an unnumbered alcove of Floor 333. Morn's field note describes it as "icosahedral in manner, dodecahedral in fact, and truncated throughout" (Survey Return 333/4, Winter Series). The object is cut at every edge, so that no original face of the parent dodecahedron survives entire; each pentagonal face is ringed by ten-sided faces, and the corners are removed into triangles. It weighs forty-one pounds and a half, and is warm to the touch for the first hour after the chamber is opened.

Composition was settled only in 644, when a scraping was matched against the recipe in the Glassbound Folio 714 and found to agree in all respects but the proportion of ground slate. The Folio's compiler, Sinter-Master Ovel, had recorded the slate proportion as "to the taste of the caster," a phrase the Geometric Consistency Guild has twice declined to interpret.

The Lateralist claim

The Lateralist School holds that a coordinate system ought to proceed from an object whose faces cannot be mistaken for one another, and that the ninety distinct faces of the Floor 333 solid satisfy this where the Truncated Icosahedron of Floor 707 does not. The School's founding petition, lodged with the Concordance Office in 658, put the matter plainly:

"A surveyor who has measured one face of the 707 object has measured them all, and will not know it. A surveyor who has measured one face of ours will have measured one face, and will be obliged to go on."

— Petition of the Lateralist School, Clause 2

The petition was received, sealed, and filed. The Lateralists have consistently maintained that filing is a form of success. Base-707 Vectorial Addressing nonetheless spread through the Tower during the following century, largely because the 707 object could be carried by two porters and the 333 object could not.

Dispute over the face count

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether the solid has ninety faces or ninety-two. The Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, fixes the count at ninety and forbids its revision "by counting, however careful." The Seventh Concordance, Annex 9, fixes the count at ninety-two and appends a note that the two additional faces were "observed late, and are small."

Librarian Halvard Quince, who catalogued the Lateral Chamber from 702 to 719, attempted a reconciliation in his Remarks on the Small Faces (717), proposing that the discrepancy arose from the object's habit of resting on two of its faces rather than one, so that the underside faces were counted by some surveyors and not by others. Quince's proposal was accepted by the Guild, rejected by the School, and printed in the Annual Register with a footnote dissenting from itself. The current chamber practice is to record the count as "ninety, with the understanding that the matter is before the Concordance Office."

An earlier and now discredited reading, advanced in the Marginalia of Clerk Ostrey (c. 580), described the object as a Dodecahedron Lambda "gone wrong at the corners." Dodecahedron Lambda is a twelve-faced solid of heptagonal faces held on Floor 147, and no examination has ever found a correspondence between the two beyond the shared name of dodecahedron, which the Ninth Concordance notes is applied loosely in the lower floors.

Calibration and the Vault

The Floor 333 solid is not a calibration standard and the Guild has ruled three times that it must not be treated as one. The ruling of 688 followed an incident in which a junior surveyor, Emmer Rusk, used the solid to check a theodolite and returned a discrepancy of four minutes of arc that took eleven months to trace. The Guild's finding, recorded as Ruling 688/3, held that "the object is not wrong; the theodolite is not wrong; the four minutes are the property of the room." Calibration of the Truncated Icosahedron of Floor 707 continues to be performed monthly against the Master Icosahedron in the Vault of Floor 2001, and no lateral instrument is admitted to that floor.

Access and the Lateral Chamber

The Lateral Chamber is opened on the second and fourth Tuesdays of each month, between the ninth and eleventh hours, to persons holding a Writ of Provisional Tenancy on Floor 333 or above. Visitors are asked to leave hats with the attendant. The bell is not to be lifted. Since 744 the School has maintained a rota of two members present at each opening, one to answer questions and one to record them; the second member's ledger, the Register of Doubts, now runs to fourteen volumes and has been consulted twice.

The object was last rotated in 763, contrary to the standing order, by a party from Floor 441 who believed the order applied only to the bell. The chamber was closed for the remainder of that year. The School's account of the event, circulated as Circular 763/11, describes the rotation as "brief, unnecessary, and complete."

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Floor 333: where is it?

The floor is constructed from a porous, silicate-basalt composite, characterized by a dense, hexagonal cellular structure. This material exhibits pronounced acoustic damping properties, absorbing between 87-92% of incide…

Floor 333
Writ of Provisional Tenancy: what does it set out?

Writ of Provisional Tenancy (Form VP-1a, Revision 22) is the foundational document issued by the Vestibule of Provisional Tenancy to formalize the status of a provisional citizen within the Tower. It serves as a temporar…

Writ of Provisional Tenancy
Concordance Office: who are they?

The Concordance Office is the general clearing house through which concordances, amendments, annotations and recensions pass before deposit in the Central Register. It is not to be confused with any of the eleven sub-off…

Concordance Office
Lateralist School: how is it conducted?

Lateralist School refers to an analytical and interpretive tradition within the Tower that privileges the investigation of relationships, adjacency, and parallel systems over hierarchical or linear progression. Emerging …

Lateralist School

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.