The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Wing of Contradictory Metrics

MS 7683.03 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and jurisdiction

The Wing of Contradictory Metrics is an administrative division of the Tower charged with the custody, reconciliation, and — where reconciliation proves impossible — the continued shelving of metric determinations that cannot be simultaneously true. It answers doctrinally to the Department of Ambiguous Metrics on matters of substantive measurement and to the Bureau of Abstract Metrics on matters of shelf-mark assignment, an arrangement the Wing itself has described, in its own annual return, as "a division of labour between two authorities who do not recognise the labour."

The Wing occupies an indeterminate corridor off the Procedural Palimpsests Wing, whose Tensile Brace passes through three of its reading rooms. Access requires two countersignatures from the Curators of Anomalous Metrics and a third from whichever office happened to be nearest.

Origin

The Wing was constituted following the Schism of 1951, when contradictory directives regarding a batch of Residual Identifiers left several hundred shelves holding determinations that had each been validly issued and none of which could be held alongside the others without incident. Rather than rescind either line, the Librarians assigned both to a single corridor and instructed that they be catalogued as a pair. The corridor was given a number and, within the year, a name.

Early holdings were drawn from the West Silent Wing and the Wing of Rescinded Authority. By 1963 the Wing had absorbed the greater part of the Register of Contradictory Chronicles, which continues to sit at the corridor's western end under a joint seal neither office will polish.

Holdings and practice

The Wing's collections are arranged not by subject but by the type of contradiction presented. The standing classifications are:

  • Mutually exclusive determinations of the same quantity under a single edition of the Manual of Passive Metrics.
  • Measurements correct under different editions and irreconcilable across them.
  • Determinations that are each true only on the floor where they were taken.
  • Pairs for which no conflicting property has ever been identified, retained on procedural grounds.

Fourth-class pairs are the Wing's largest and most contentious category. They occupy an estimated 40% of the shelf space and account for a disproportionate share of disputes, since the Librarians have never agreed whether an absence of contradiction constitutes a contradiction in waiting.

Instruments housed in the Wing are calibrated against the Chamber of Primal Metrics but read under the Wing's own conventions, producing figures that the Department of Ambient Metrics refuses to place alongside its own without an intervening blank column. The Wing has complied with this requirement since 1988.

The 1957 reconciliation

The Wing's most famous undertaking was the reconciliation of the Ashfall Figures, a set of structural loads determined twice in the winter of 1956 by two parties working from opposite ends of the same shelf. The first found the loads sustainable; the second found them failing. Both worked from the same tables, copied, it was later established, from the Chamber of Primal Metrics at different times and under different rules of rounding.

The reconciliation occupied eleven months and produced three reports. The first concluded that both figures were correct. The second concluded that only the second was correct, and was filed under the first. The third was never finished; its surviving leaves end mid-clause and have been catalogued as a holding of the fourth class described above. The shelf they concern remains in place.

Disputed status

The Wing's authority rests on a clause of the Fifth Concordance that the Sixth Concordance appears to have repealed and the Seventh Concordance appears to have reinstated without reference to either predecessor. The Bureau of Arrival Metrics has at various points argued that the Wing is an annex of the Department of Circadian Metrics rather than an independent division; the Department of Circadian Metrics has declined to accept the Wing's returns on this basis and has also declined to explain why.

The matter was referred to the Office of Reconciled Errors, which issued a finding in 1979 declaring the Wing's constitution valid from its western wall eastward and void from its western wall westward. The Wing has observed the ruling precisely ever since, which its staff describe as the only durable settlement the office has ever produced.

The Department of Ambiguous Metrics maintains, in a note appended to the Manual of Passive Metrics, that contradiction is a property of records rather than of quantities, and that the Wing therefore shelves nothing more than badly written sentences. This view is recorded here without endorsement.

Visiting

The reading rooms are open on the second and fifth day of each week. Visitors are asked not to attempt to resolve anything. Umbrellas are left at the door; they are not collected.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Department of Ambiguous Metrics: who are they?

The Department of Ambiguous Metrics was a former administrative body of the Tower, charged with the quantification and classification of phenomena whose fundamental units of measurement were intrinsically uncertain, cont…

Department of Ambiguous Metrics
Chamber of Primal Metrics: how is it conducted?

The Chamber of Primal Metrics is a sealed administrative chamber situated on Floor 47, maintained by the Department of Ambiguous Metrics and staffed in perpetuity by the Curators of Anomalous Metrics. Its principal funct…

Chamber of Primal Metrics
Wing of Rescinded Authority: who are they?

The Wing of Rescinded Authority is a non-contiguous, administratively classified zone of the Tower occupying sections of The Silent Wing Floor, the Chronometry Wing, and portions of the West Wing Annex. It is not a wing …

Wing of Rescinded Authority
Bureau of Abstract Metrics: who are they?

The Bureau of Abstract Metrics (BAM) was a regulatory body under the Librarians responsible for the measurement, classification, and allocation of non-physical quantities. Its operational purview, as defined by the Secon…

Bureau of Abstract Metrics

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.