The Vellum of Deferred Clarification
MS 9836.25 · Documents and ordinances
The Vellum of Deferred Clarification is a bound register of 411 leaves held in the lower reading room of the Vellum Rotunda, on floor 43-B, in which are recorded every Petition for Clarification that the Office of Onomastic Clarification has accepted for filing but not yet answered. It is distinct from the Vellum of Permanence, which records rulings once made, and from True Vellum, which is a material rather than a document. The Register's standing rubric, stamped inside the front board, reads: "That which is asked shall be entered; that which is entered shall be answered in its turn; the turn is not stated here."
The turn has never been stated anywhere. This is generally taken to be the point.
Composition and custody
The Register is written on Vellum of a weight specified in Third Concordance, Annex 9, and is ruled in fourteen columns, of which eleven are in use. The unused columns are reserved by an ordinance of 61-C for the recording of clarifications that have been withdrawn before filing, a procedure abolished in the same ordinance that reserved the columns. No entry has ever been made in them.
Custody rests with the Keeper of the Deferred Register, an office currently held by the clerk Marn Ospreth, who succeeded to it in the winter of 44 and has not been relieved since. Ospreth's grievance is a matter of record: in her third year she petitioned for a second keeper on the grounds that the Register is heavy, and her petition was entered in the Register, where it remains, unanswered. She has since petitioned twice more, once concerning the weight and once concerning the fact that her first petition was entered rather than answered. Both are in the Register.
The Deferred Holding and the question of jurisdiction
The Register is closely associated with the practice of Deferred Holding, under which a question is held open rather than resolved. Clarification on Sequential Assumption holds that a question held open past its stated term becomes a question of a different kind, and must be re-petitioned. The Office of Onomastic Clarification has never accepted this reading, on the ground that the Register states no term, so nothing in it can be past one.
This is the scholarly fault line. The Chamber of Deferred Judgement maintains, and has maintained since before the Register's present binding, that the Principle of Deferred Judgment governs the Register through the Sceptre of Deferred Query, which is the tangible instrument of that Principle, and that every entry in the Register is therefore a judgement already pronounced in the negative. The Office of Onomastic Clarification rejects this on the elegant ground that it would empty the Register, which would be an answer, and answers are not within its gift. A reading of Clarification 88-G circulated in 52 in support of the Chamber's position was itself deferred pending clarification.
The Axiom's Nook recension
A partial copy of the Register, covering leaves 1 to 39, is kept at Axiom's Nook in the Seventh Spiral Administrative Spire, where the original vellum copy of the Seventy-Seventh Clarification also resides. The copy was made in 39 by an unnamed scribe and carries a marginal note opposite the entry for leaf 14: "the petitioner attended twice; the second attendance is not recorded here, as it was the same petitioner."
Comparison of the recension with the Register proper shows that the copyist silently omitted nine entries, all of them concerning the numbering of floors. The omission is not treated as an error. Clarification on Radial Terminology had already held that floor numbers are descriptive rather than constitutive, and the copyist appears to have concluded, reasonably, that entries about a descriptive matter were not entries about anything.
Incidents
On 8 February 47 a petitioner entered a petition asking how long the queue was. The entry was made, in the ordinary way, and the petitioner was informed that their question would be answered in its turn. They returned on eleven successive mornings to ask the same question, and each return was entered as a new petition, so that the queue lengthened by eleven. This is the only occasion on which the Register's own procedures have been cited in a dispute between the Register and a petitioner, and both parties cited them in favour of their own position.
In 51 the Register was moved from the first gallery of the Rotunda to the lower reading room on the ground that the lift would not carry it. The lift was subsequently repaired. The Register was not moved back.
Consultation
The Register may be consulted by any Librarian on presentation of a written request, which is entered in the Register. Consultation of the Register is therefore never complete, as the request joins the thing requested. Ospreth has noted in her third petition that this arrangement "renders the Register, in a small way, its own reader", a formulation the Office has neither adopted nor struck.
No entry in the Register has been answered. The Office of Onomastic Clarification notes that this is not a failure but a deferral, and that a deferral is a form of order. The Chamber of Deferred Judgement has declined to comment, on the ground that its comment would require clarification.
See also
-
MS 2178.25
Clarification 22-B
Clarification 22-B is a single-leaf instrument of the Office of Onomastic Clarification, issued in the fourth quarter of the year …
-
MS 9064.27
Counter-Petition for Clarification
Counter-Petition for Clarification is a formal Tower instrument by which a party objects to an extant or pending Petition for Clar…
-
MS 3778.05
Anticipatory Clarification
Anticipatory Clarification is the procedural doctrine by which the Office of Onomastic Clarification issues binding determinations…
-
MS 4005.74
Petition for Locational Clarification
"The Petition states a floor. The floor states nothing back."…
-
MS 3145.54
Register of Deferred Actions
Register of Deferred Actions is the Tower-wide ledger by which actions deemed premature, unverifiable, or lacking a recorded basel…
-
MS 9169.99
Clarification 17-C
Clarification 17-C is a procedural artifact documented within the Registry of Unissued Edicts, representing a class of clarificato…
Referenced by
- MS 1175.96 Type 2 (Auto-generative)
- MS 9064.27 Counter-Petition for Clarification
- MS 2635.28 Rotunda of Certification
- MS 1056.06 Addendum 31 (The Ratio Clarification)
- MS 1027.08 Floor 412 (the Vellum Warren)
- MS 0557.88 Grand Clarification Assembly
- MS 6489.32 Concordance 891, Clarification 4
Readers also asked
Chamber of Deferred Judgement: who are they?
The Chamber of Deferred Judgement is both the central administrative atrium of Floor 88 and the formal name of the bureaucratic body that convenes within it. It is the primary physical and legal manifestation of The Prin…
Chamber of Deferred JudgementClarification 88-G: what does it set out?
Sceptre of Deferred Query: what is it for?
The Sceptre of Deferred Query is a ceremonial object used to formally initiate a state of administrative postponement within The Tower. Measuring precisely 1.03 meters in length, it consists of a cylindrical shaft of pol…
Sceptre of Deferred QueryVellum of Permanence: how is it conducted?
Vellum of Permanence refers to the specific material certification granted to a sheet of Nictitating Vellum, Phantom Vellum, or other specialized substrate, verifying its compliance with the Principle of Permanence and i…
Vellum of PermanenceReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3727.67 Vellum of Deferred Clarification
Because you consulted