The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Status of the Hypothetical Clerk

MS 4158.84 · Practices and doctrines

The Status of the Hypothetical Clerk is a standing question of cataloguing classification, maintained since Year 223 as an open item under the Seventeenth Concordance, concerning a clerk who has not been observed to exist but whose records have nonetheless accrued across eleven floors. The question is not whether the clerk is real — which the Tower does not ask of anything — but whether the clerk may be catalogued, and if so, on whose shelf. It is the longest-running unresolved item in the Hypothetical Archive, having outlasted four recensions of the relevant guidance and two of the clerks who raised it.

The first sighting and the ledger

The item originates in the winter of Year 211, on Floor 9 (the Anteroom of Unclaimed Desks), when a duty ledger was found to have been signed forty-one times over a fortnight in a hand matching no clerk on the floor's roll. The entries were ordinary — lamps tended, ink issued, a stairhead swept — and the ledger was otherwise in good order. The Keeper of the Anteroom, Wilm of the Ninth, ruled that a signature without a signatory was a defect of the page and not of the world, and had the forty-one entries copied into the ledger's margin with the note "unpersons, do not carry forward."

The margin was insufficient. By Year 214 the same hand had appeared in seven ledgers across four floors, always in the same narrow register, always in duties no one disputed had been done. The desks at those floors were not found occupied and the lamps were found lit. Wilm of the Ninth's note was amended four times, each amendment widening the margin, until the Keeper conceded in a memorandum of 3 Frost 215 that "the margin cannot be widened further without consuming the page" — Memorandum of the Keeper of the Anteroom, 3 Frost 215, item 6.

The Literalist position

The dispute sharpened in the years of the Literalist Schism (211–223), which had first formed over the cataloguing status of Hypothetical Artifacts and which the ledger question then rejoined. The Literalists held, in the formulation of the recensionist Ald the Younger, that "a record of a clerk is a record, and a clerk is not" and that the two must be shelved in different wings, the one under administration and the other under nothing at all — Ald the Younger, On the Insufficiency of the Pen, chapter 2.

The practical consequence was a small crisis on Floor 44 (the Wheel of Withheld Determinations), where an unshelved clerk had been keeping the floor's incomings for a decade. The Literalists had the incomings removed to administration and the desk cleared. Within the fortnight the floor lost fourhelds of its incomings, which were later found stacked in a passage on Floor 61 in a hand nobody claimed. The Wheel resumed only when the incomings were returned to the desk and left unattended.

Clause VII and the Quietus collaboration

Clause VII of the Seventeenth Concordance addressed the difficulty directly, and did so by refusing it. It provides that entities "lacking a certified arrival" be entered in a separate schedule, with citations to their records prefixed by the term hypothetical, and that the prefix be "neither a denial nor an admission." Drafted largely by Quietus, then Clerk-Arkivist First Class, the clause drew on the classification work Quietus had done with Wren of the 440th on hypothetical arrivals, and its careful neutrality was taken at the time as a truce.

It was received as neither. The Bureau of Hypothetical Durability declined to assess the hypothetical clerk on the ground that assessment presumes a holding, and the clerk had not been held; the Bureau's notice of 4 Ember 224 states the matter in one sentence and does not elaborate — Bureau of Hypothetical Durability, Notice 224/9, 4 Ember 224. This is in contrast to its treatment of objects, such as Hypothetical Mineral #331, which proceeded through a full Hypothetical Durability Assessment and was assigned Class Θ on 14 Ember 402. The Bureau has consistently maintained that a mineral does not answer back, and that a clerk might.

The Co-locationist argument

The prevailing view in the archive is the Co-locationist argument advanced by Clerk Elara, who observes that a clerk is not an artifact and cannot be shelf-shelved apart from their duties without misdescribing both. Elara's argument, in its compact form, is that the hypothetical clerk's records and the hypothetical clerk's floor are the same object viewed at different distances — a position she developed against the counter-argument of the Lanier school, and which has since been extended, not without controversy, to the Clerk of the Apocrypha and the Clerk Tower — see the Lanier Counter-Position and The Lanier Counter-Position, which are two distinct holdings and are frequently cited as one by the careless.

"A clerk who is only recorded is still recorded in the place where they were not standing. I do not see what else a floor is for."

— Clerk Elara, Observations on the Eleventh Recension, folio 12

Unresolved points

Three matters remain open. The first is the count: whether the hypothetical clerk is one clerk or a class of clerks, a question the ledger's uniform hand would seem to settle and does not, since no comparison exemplar exists. The second is the prefix, which Clause VII declines to make binding and which different offices apply differently, so that the same signature appears as "hypothetical clerk" on Floor 9 and as plain "clerk" on Floor 61. The third is the wording of the status itself, which is held to be defective by the Literalists on the ground that a status is a position on a shelf and the hypothetical clerk has no shelf.

No assessment has been scheduled. The item is reviewed each Ember, at which time the file is opened, found complete, and closed. Clerks are reminded not to leave ink on the desk at the Anteroom of Unclaimed Desks; ink left there is routinely logged to the hypothetical clerk and cannot afterwards be reassigned. In Year 402 the file's contents were weighed at 1,140 folios and returned to the shelf unaltered.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Clerk Tower: where is it?

The Clerk Tower is not a person or an office, but a permanent structural designation for the administrative spire located at the center of the 47th Stasis Ring on the 8,422nd floor of the primary vertical stack. It house…

Clerk Tower
Seventeenth Concordance: what does it set out?

Seventeenth Concordance is the official designation for a document of foundational administrative law pertaining to the establishment and early protocols of the Office of Voluntary Correspondence. Ratified in Year 47 of …

Seventeenth Concordance
Hypothetical Artifacts: how is it conducted?

"An artifact held in provisional status shall not be cited as settled, except where the citation itself would otherwise render it settled."

Hypothetical Artifacts
Class Θ (Theta – Negligibly Hypothetical): how is it conducted?

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.