The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Silence Edict

MS 4466.03 · Documents and ordinances

The Silence Edict is the foundational instrument of the Protocols of Silence, enacted in the Tower's ninth recension and amended on forty-one recorded occasions since. It is the governing document for Silence Prevention, the certification of tacit-bound media, and the operation of the Silence Protocol at every floor where Silence is held, maintained, or expected. Its opening clause is conventionally translated as: "That which is not said shall be administered." The original wording is cited in Concordance 4, Annex α, and differs from the translation in two verbs, a matter that occupied the Office of Recensions for eleven years.

The Edict is administered by the Librarians under the standing authority of the Concordance of Seals. Copies are held on floors bearing the mark S, though the mark is not itself a floor designation and should not be read as one.

Structure and annexes

The Edict runs to nineteen clauses and seven annexes, of which Annexes β through δ are frequently cited and rarely read in full. Clause 7, Annex β governs the Silence of Floor 771 and is the only clause to have been amended twice in the same session, at the Winter Sitting of 1141 and again in the following fortnight. Clause 19 governs the certification of architecturally silent environments required for the formation of Petrified Silence, a class of Silence that forms only where the fabric of a room has held its quiet for a continuous period. Annex 7-α formally codified the position of Clerk of the Seventh Silence, a post that had in practice existed for two centuries before anyone wrote it down.

Annex β also contains the Edict's most-cited procedural contradiction: Clause 7 requires the Clerk to certify a floor's silence before the floor may be sealed, while Annex β §3 requires the floor to be sealed before certification may proceed. The contradiction was resolved in favour of the Clerk by Precedence Edict 22/1, which established the general principle that where an annex and a clause conflict, the office with the nearer door prevails.

Tacit-bound media

The Edict classifies media by how tightly silence adheres to them. Adhesive Silence and Aethelred's Silence are both entered as tacit-bound media, the first because it clings to surfaces and the second because it clings to a name. Procedural Silence, by contrast, is classified as unbound and must be filed rather than stored. The distinction matters chiefly at audit. The Grammar of Silence is separately classified as a Type-III Tacit Law System, and the related Grammar of Silence (the descriptive treatise, not the law system itself) is held at Floor 338, which is not an S-marked floor and has petitioned for the mark on four occasions.

The Gilded Silence was established pursuant to the Edict by direction of the Curators of the Gilded Silence and remains the only Silence in the archive with its own guard.

The seventh amendment and the three axiomatic principles

The Edict establishes the Silence Protocol and includes, in its seventh amendment, three axiomatic principles. The first holds that silence unrecorded is silence unadministered. The second holds that a recorded silence is the property of the floor on which it was recorded, not of the clerk who recorded it. The third is unreadable in all four surviving copies; the Office of Recensions maintains that the third principle is not damaged but simply long, and that the surviving copies contain only its preamble. Librarian-Archivist Bel-Mann wrote of it: "The third principle is generally agreed to be the important one." (Marginalia on the Seventh Amendment, f. 44r)

"A silence entered in good order is a silence that has been kept. A silence entered in bad order is a silence that has been kept by someone else."

— Silence Edict, Clause 3

Derivative ordinances and disputes

The management, preservation, and application of Silence are governed by the Edict and its myriad derivative ordinances, of which the Ω-series edict and Edict 45-A are the most frequently invoked and the least frequently reconciled. Silence 44-Δ.7 was issued under the Edict's derivative authority and is understood by some readers to supersede Clause 12; the Bureau of Derivative Ordinances has declined to rule, noting that the question has been "referred, and remains referred."

The enactment of a Third Silence is governed by Ordinance 14-b, a provision so obscure that it was cited only once, in Silence 44-Δ.7 itself. The Edict of the Polyhedron is sometimes treated as an appendix to the Silence Edict and sometimes as a rival instrument; the dispute is old and no party to it is still living.

Reception and outstanding questions

Scholars disagree on whether the Edict is one document amended forty-one times or forty-two documents imperfectly aligned. The Concordance of Scribes holds the former; the Office of Recensions holds the latter and has the seals to support it. A third position, advanced by the Under-Librarian of Annexes, proposes that the Edict is one document but that the amendments are true and the original is not, a formulation that has not been withdrawn.

Ordinary practice is less troubled. Clerks apply Clause 7, quote Clause 3, and file everything under the Edict regardless of which ordinance actually governs. Since Concordance 9 requires references to be made "to the Edict, without further particularity, where particularity would occasion delay," this is correct. The Ledger of Floor 771 has not been opened since 1143 and is not to be opened without the Clerk present.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Adhesive Silence: how is it conducted?

Adhesive silence is a specialized adhesive compound employed exclusively for the hermetic sealing of Memory Caskets. It is classified under the Silence Edict as a tacit-bound medium, defined by its ability to form a perm…

Adhesive Silence
Precedence Edict 22/1: what does it set out?

Precedence Edict 22/1 is an instrument of the Precedence Edict Protocol that formalized the principle of Exclusive Inference as the primary adjudicative mechanism for contradictions within the Silence Edict annexes. Prom…

Precedence Edict 22/1
Ω-series edict: what does it set out?

The Ω-series edict constitutes a class of administrative instrument within the Tower, characterized by its appended series designation of the Greek letter omega (Ω). Issuance of an Ω-series edict, a process governed by t…

Ω-series edict
Silence Edict: what does it set out?

The Silence Edict, formally designated Series Φ-α, is a concordance-class ordinance governing the ontological classification and administrative handling of entities exhibiting aphasic or self-negating properties. Its pri…

Silence Edict

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.