The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Procedural Silence

MS 1889.06 · Practices and doctrines

Procedural Silence is the condition under which a matter before the Tower is held to have been settled by the deliberate absence of its record. It is not the same as quiet: the Silence Edict distinguishes at clause 4 the silence of an empty room from the silence that a document makes when it is withheld, and only the second is procedural. The Tower recognises the condition chiefly because so much of its administration depends on knowing what was not written down, by whom, and under which seal.

The term entered general use after the Silence of '73, when the Silence Protocol was applied and the intervening eleven months were reclassified, under the Silence Edict, as a period of Procedural Tacitness. Clerks of the Vowed Librarians of Silence maintain that the phrase itself is older, appearing in a recension of the Ordinance of Procedural Silence held on a floor whose number the recension omits.

Taxonomy and its uses

Annex 7-B of the Protocols of Silence sets out the seven-tiered taxonomy of procedural silences, from the mere unrecorded omission at the first tier to the wholly administrative silence of the seventh, in which a matter is held to have been settled precisely because no office will admit to having raised it. The Doctrine of Administrative Silence governs how documentation concerning such matters is to be composed, and it is here that most disputes arise, since a document may not describe a silence without producing one.

The Register of Procedural Silences records each declared instance with its tier, its date of recognition, and the office that first noticed the gap. Annex 7 of the Register stipulates the standardized phrasing for declaring an Echoing Silence, which is the fourth tier and the only one that may be declared by a single clerk without countersignature. The phrasing is not recorded in the Register itself, on the grounds that to set it down would be to fill the silence it describes.

The Motes Question

A persistent scholarly difficulty concerns the relationship between procedural silence and Motes of Preserved Silence, the particulate matter that retains measurable quantities of institutional quiet. The Doctrine of Administrative Silence holds that motes are a consequence of procedural silence — that the condition sheds them the way a lamp sheds soot — while the Grammar of Silence treats them as the raw material from which silences are built. The disagreement is not trivial. Under the first reading, a floor may be swept and its silence left intact; under the second, sweeping disperses the silence into the stairwells, and Maintenance of Architectural Silence must be notified before any brush is used above the ninth tier.

"Where a silence has been declared and no mote recovered within the quarter, the declaration shall stand, the absent mote being itself a silence of the second tier."

— Protocols of Silence, Annex 7-B, clause 12

Clerk-Adjunct Ilseph Marran, attached to the Register between the winters of 40 and 46, argued for nine years that clause 12 renders the taxonomy circular. Her memorandum of 44 — three pages, of which two are blank and defended as such — was itself declared a silence of the third tier before it could be answered, and Marran's subsequent complaint that the declaration had swallowed her argument was recorded as evidence that the declaration had been correct.

Contradiction between the Concordances

The Fourth Concordance provides at Annex 9 that a procedural silence, once declared, may be lifted only by the office that declared it. The Eleventh Concordance provides at Annex 2 that no silence may outlast the office that declared it, and that all such declarations lapse automatically when the declaring office is dissolved, amalgamated, or merely renamed. The two have never been reconciled in writing. The Silence Edict is itself an annex containing procedural contradictions, and these were resolved — in the sense that they were made to stop being asked about — under Precedence Edict 22/1.

In practice the Eleventh prevails, because offices are renamed more often than they are persuaded. When the Office of the Prolocutor was reconstituted as the Office of the Prolocutor (Second Seal) in the winter of 61, some four hundred and ten declared silences lapsed by operation of Annex 2 and were immediately redeclared under the same tier by the reconstituted office. The lapse and redeclaration were recorded in the same entry, a procedure the Register permits and the Ordinance of Procedural Silence does not forbid.

Prevention and certification

Silence Prevention is the deliberate forestalling of a procedural silence before it forms, and is distinguished from Enforced Silence, which is imposed by decree, barricade, or acoustic nullification field for purposes of order. Certification of either condition falls to Silence Certification, which issues a seal of three impressions; the third impression is made on a separate sheet and immediately destroyed, the sheet being retained.

The condition may be observed in its extreme form at the Gilded Silence on Floor 17,419, whose architectural and procedural precursor was the Gilded Quire, and in the graded instances catalogued at Silence of Floor π and Silence of Floor 771. Visitors to any declared silence are asked to remove their boots at the threshold and to leave the door ajar by the width of a hand.

The Charter of Inalienable Silence grants the Office of the Prolocutor authority to "intercede for procedural clarity" in any matter touching a declared silence. The phrase has never been defined, and the Office has never exercised the authority without first being asked not to.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Silence Prevention: how is it conducted?

Silence Prevention is the administrative and practical discipline, governed under the Silence Edict, dedicated to identifying, mitigating, and pre-empting the formation of unregulated silence. It is distinct from the mai…

Silence Prevention
Doctrine of Administrative Silence: how is it conducted?

Doctrine of Administrative Silence is a procedural framework, codified within the General Administrative Protocols as Annex Sigma, governing the creation, amendment, and retirement of official Tower documentation concern…

Doctrine of Administrative Silence
Enforced Silence: how is it conducted?

Enforced Silence is a condition of quietude imposed by administrative decree, physical barricade, or acoustic nullification field for purposes of security, punishment, or the maintenance of procedural order within the To…

Enforced Silence
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.