The Shadow Library
MS 8584.67 · Places and structures
The Shadow Library is the collective name for the holdings of the Shadow Annex, a sub-collection of some 41,000 volumes, folios, and unbound quires housed on Floor 118 (West Spiral Stairwell, three landings below the Granite Library) whose catalogued subjects are not the shadows themselves but the literature that shadows have, over the centuries, been observed to produce. The distinction is maintained by the Shadow Catalogues and is the source of the Library's principal scholarly dispute. The Shadow Library is not to be confused with the Shadow Annex that contains it, nor with the Sub-Basement Shadow Court, which holds no books and has twice declined to.
Founding and the matter of the first accession
The Shadow Library was founded by instrument of the Librarians in the winter of the year recorded as 3,109, following the recovery of a single octavo volume from a reading room on Floor 74 that had been unlit for sixteen hours. The volume was found open, the pages turned, and the annotations in a hand that could not be matched to any registered borrower. The Shadow Catalogues record the volume as On the Persistence of the Unlit (anon., West Spiral Press) and the event as its first accession. The founding instrument, clause 2, is careful: the Library holds "the books that shadows have made, not the shadows that made them."
Objection was raised almost immediately by the Granite Library, which held that the volume was a shadow of a book rather than a book of a shadow, and that the two categories could not be shelved together. The dispute was settled — or, more accurately, postponed — by Ninth Concordance, Annex 2, which assigned the question to a standing committee. The committee has not reported. It continues to meet quarterly and its minutes are held in the Shadow Library, where they are catalogued as fiction.
Holdings
The Shadow Library is arranged by the quality of the shadow that produced the work, not by author or subject. The cataloguer's rule is that a book is shelved by what cast it. The principal divisions are as follows:
- Root Shadow — 11,400 volumes, including the entire deposit of the Inquest of the Librarians' Shadow and all works composed under the Root Shadow classification.
- Object Shadow — 18,200 volumes, the largest division, shelved by the number of Cast Shadow sources recorded on the title page.
- Memory Shadow — 6,900 volumes, closed to consultation except by written permission of the Librarians, which has been granted four times.
- Disputed Shadow — 4,500 volumes, held pending resolution of the holding question and, in the cataloguer's phrase, "pending indefinitely."
The Shadow Without Object division was, until the Shadows Without Object recension of the Shadow Catalogues, kept in a separate room. The room was found to contain no books, and the cataloguers have since agreed that the room was the division.
Administration and the Stokes Grievance
Access to the Shadow Library is granted by the Autonomous Library Scout service, which opens a calibrated dimensional aperture in the ceiling of the West Spiral landing. The aperture admits one reader at a time, and no reader may bring a light. The rule is old and has been challenged twice. The first challenge, in 4,112, was dismissed on the ground that the Shadow Library is a library of shadow and that a light source would be a category error. The second, in 4,388, was dismissed on the ground that the first challenge had been dismissed.
The Ward Clerk Elve Stokes was appointed in 4,411 to reconcile the Shadow Library's catalogue against that of the Granite Library. She found that 3,011 volumes appeared in both, 2,004 in neither, and 41 in both but with contradictory dates. Her complaint — that the two catalogues described the same holdings under different manifestations, and that the Library was therefore "shelving the same thing twice in the name of not shelving it at all" — was upheld by the Librarians and then overturned by the Granite Library under the Thirteenth Concordance. She petitioned again in 4,419. The petition was filed correctly. The file has not been found. The Stokes Grievance remains a live matter, and the two catalogues remain unreconciled.
Dispute on the holding question
The Ninety-Degree Shadow Rule governs how the Library's shadows are expected to fall across the reading tables. The Shadow Library's own cataloguers have deposed that a book read under the Rule casts the shadow of a different book. Twenty-Second Concordance, Annex 7, forbids this observation from being recorded on a catalogue card; the Twenty-Fourth Concordance permits it, provided the shadow is described in the same hand and the description is not signed. The contradiction is unresolved. The present practice is to describe the shadow in pencil and to leave the pencil on the table.
"We have not read the book. We have read the shadow of the book, and the shadow is the better book. The book agrees with us, and has said so."
— Ward Clerk Elve Stokes, marginal note to the 4,411 reconciliation
Maintenance and prohibition
The Shadow Library is not swept. The hands of the great clock on the West Spiral landing, which has not kept time since 2,904, are set from the Shadow Library's own reckoning, and the cataloguers hold that to restore the clock would be to disturb the shelf order. Complaints are logged with the Shadow Dissonance desk, which is the wrong desk. The Shadow Library is closed on the first of the month. Readers are asked not to leave pencils on the tables.
See also
Shadow Annex Shadow Catalogues Shadow Without Object Shadow-Casting Sporulation Shadow-Hoarding Memory Shadow Library Standard Tolerances Granite Library
See also
-
MS 2371.06
Library of Unwritten Prefaces
The Library of Unwritten Prefaces is a reading collection of 41,600 volumes, none of which contains a preface, maintained on Floor…
-
MS 6638.79
Unbound Stacks
The Unbound Stacks are the collective designation for those ranges of the Tower's library that are not fixed to a floor, a wall, o…
-
MS 4957.42
Canon of Autological Texts
The Canon of Autological Texts is a closed holding on Floor 33, comprising 1,412 bound volumes and 44 unbound fascicles whose titl…
-
MS 9850.25
Silent Stairwell
The Silent Stairwell is the collective designation for any vertical circulation shaft within the Tower in which sound is not carri…
-
MS 7201.21
Discrepancy Volumes
Discrepancy Volumes is the collective designation for those bound holdings whose physical extent is held to disagree with their ow…
-
MS 1518.74
Collection of Terminus Tones
The Collection of Terminus Tones is a curated body of recorded frequencies understood to be the last sustained sound produced by a…
Referenced by
- MS 7835.94 Floor 1173 (The Penumbral Atrium)
- MS 2908.76 Contextual Shadow Casting
Readers also asked
Granite Library: how is it conducted?
The Granite Library is the foundational lithic strata underlying the architectural reality of the Tower. It is not a discrete collection but the mineralogical and informational substrate from which all later structures a…
Granite LibraryNinety-Degree Shadow Rule: how is it conducted?
The Ninety-Degree Shadow Rule is the foundational principle of geometric orthodoxy governing the relationship between an object and its cast shadow throughout the Tower. In its shortest form, as given in the Manual of Au…
Ninety-Degree Shadow RuleTwenty-Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Twenty-Fourth was ratified while the Twenty-Third Concordance remained in force, and it contains no general supersession clause. Clause 1 establishes only that the Twenty-Fourth "shall govern coordination between spi…
Twenty-Fourth ConcordanceMemory Shadow: how is it conducted?
A Memory Shadow is a taxonomically contentious phenomenon representing the persistent visual or structural record of a shadow that is no longer physically cast by any object or light source. Classified under the broader …
Memory ShadowPassages cited from this record
-
We have not read the book. We have read the shadow of the book, and the shadow is the better book. The book agrees with us, and has said so.
Ward Clerk Elve Stokes, marginal note to the 4,411 reconciliation
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4282.74 Elve Stokes
- MS 4341.17 Shadow Library
Because you consulted