The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Role of the Winnowed Manuscript

MS 1132.19 · Practices and doctrines

The Role of the Winnowed Manuscript is a standing procedural designation within the Manuscript Ecosystem, denoting not a document but the fixed set of functions and constraints that attach to the Winnowed Manuscript wherever it is held, consulted, amended, or dormed. The designation was coined in the Concordance of Registries, Annex 11, which distinguishes the role of a manuscript from its custody: the Winnowed Manuscript may change hands, floors, and bindings, but its role travels with it, "as a seal travels with the wax and not with the table" (Concordance of Registries, Annex 11, clause 9). The distinction was necessary because the Manuscript had, on four separate occasions prior to 1108, been consulted in a manner appropriate to an ordinary log and inappropriate to a governing instrument.

Formulation

The role is stated in three unnumbered paragraphs at the head of every approved codex in the Index of Amendments, prefaced by the note that they are "to be read aloud before first use and not thereafter." In substance they fix the Manuscript's double character for the Manuscript Ecosystem: it is the official log of contested entries maintained by the Review Chamber, and it is a principal governing and record-keeping document within the Foundational stratum. The tension between these — a log records, a governing instrument binds — is the whole content of the role, and the Office of Final Disposition has twice declined to resolve it.

"A log that is consulted is a log. A log that is cited is an instrument. The Manuscript is neither until the reader has decided which he is doing."

— Office of Final Disposition, Guidance Note 4 (unrevised)

The dormancy provision

The role's most consequential feature concerns inquiry. Where the original custodians of an inquiry fail to advance it within eleven sessions, the Manuscript's role shifts from log to notice, and a formal Notice of Procedural Dormancy is issued in its name. The notice is the Manuscript; that is, it is not a document filed inside it but an act performed by it, which has caused persistent difficulty at Floor 1801 (the Review Chamber), where clerks must endorse the notice both as authors and as the instrument through which it issues. The standard endorsement bears the same signature twice, the second time with the words "on behalf of itself" appended, a formula introduced by the clerk Marren Vey during the winter of 1106 after an attempt to endorse in a single hand was struck down as "an inquiry conducted by the inquiring thing" (Committee for Ontological Review, Ruling 1106/14). Vey's formula remains in use. Vey has not been consulted since.

Sub judice and the read-aloud rule

Where the Committee for Ontological Review declares an inquiry sub judice, the Manuscript's role narrows to the keeping of a record that cannot itself be read aloud except before the Committee, notwithstanding the codex-head instruction requiring reading aloud before first use. Readers of the Tower have noted the contradiction. The Index of Amendments resolves it by amendment: the read-aloud rule applies to the role and not to the document, so that a sub judice codex is read aloud before use and the reading is not of the Manuscript. Two Librarians of the Foundational stratum have resigned over this sentence. Both later returned; neither asked to be assigned the Winnowed holdings again.

Disputed extent

Scholarly disagreement turns on whether the role extends to the Catalogue of Winnowed Manuscripts or stops at the boundary. The Office of Final Disposition maintains the distinction between the two and treats the role as terminating with them, "at the covers" (Guidance Note 9). Against this, Archivist-Liaison Forrester has argued in an unpublished memo (Floor 1801, memo shelf 12) that the Catalogue is the role's index and cannot be separated from it "any more than a hand from its reach." The First Librarian is reported to have ruled on the question in 1089, but the ruling survives only in the form of a marginal note reading "yes, but not in winter," and its application to the Catalogue is therefore not settled. The Pilaster Manuscript cites the note as authority; the Perpetual Manuscript does not.

Role-Primary

Deputies and liaisons acting on Winnowed business are designated Role-Primary for the duration of the act, a status that confers standing to cite the Manuscript and obliges the holder to carry the sealed folio from the Index of Amendments to the point of citation and back within the same session. The folio weighs four and a half pounds when dry. A three-day rain in 1113 swelled the seal cord on the return journey and the folio arrived back forty minutes late; the custody entry records the delay without comment, as is customary. Deputies are reminded of the carrying requirement by a notice nailed to the inner door of Floor 1801, and are not reminded of anything else.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Index of Amendments: what does it set out?

The Index of Amendments is the central, physical repository for the approved, bound volumes of the Winnowed Manuscript, constituting the only legally binding corpus of amendments to the Tower’s Concordances. It is housed…

Index of Amendments
Archivist-Liaison Forrester: who were they?

Archivist-Liaison Forrester is a historical role of the Liaison for Indeterminate Verticals, held continuously for forty-seven years and chiefly remembered as the office that oversaw the dimensional buffering of Interfac…

Archivist-Liaison Forrester
The Catalogue of Winnowed Manuscripts: what does it set out?

The Catalogue of Winnowed Manuscripts is the Tower's principal register of material formally struck from the floor catalogues — entries judged irrecoverable, self-contradictory, or (in the phrase favoured by the Review C…

The Catalogue of Winnowed Manuscripts
Pilaster Manuscript: how is it conducted?

Pilaster Manuscript designates a class of archival document whose text is not written onto a support but is instead struck into the plaster, stone, or composite facing of a pilaster — the shallow rectangular column appli…

Pilaster Manuscript

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.