The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Office of Aesthetic Propriety

MS 4045.80 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Office of Aesthetic Propriety was a regulatory and adjudicatory body of the Tower, constituted under amendments to the Third Concordance and charged with standardizing and enforcing visual and spatial decorum across the catalogued floors. At its height it exercised purview over the interpretation of The Principle of Aesthetic Restraint, the enforcement of The Principle of Sequential Propriety, and the review of all Aesthetic Amp Contextual Conflicts arising from the display of amped fixtures in gallery and reading spaces. Its operational headquarters stood on Floor 6,117, where its galleries remain, in the assessment of the Office of Ceremonial Consistency, "closed to viewing and open to inspection" (Ceremonial Circular 88-C, annotation 3). The Office was dissolved at a date its own ledgers decline to fix, and its standard-setting authority passed to the Office of Ceremonial Consistency.

Origins and Jurisdiction

The Office did not begin as an office. It began as a standing committee of the Third Concordance, convened to settle disputes over the placement of processional screens, and was raised to full office by a recension of that Concordance whose precise clause is disputed between the Forty-Seventh Concordance and the surviving Third Concordance annexes. The jurists of the Stairwell Bench hold that it was constituted by amendment; the archivists of Floor 6,117 hold that it was merely recognized by amendment, having existed in practice since the screens were first moved. Both positions are cited in the same filing cabinets, frequently in the same drawer.

Its primary jurisdiction encompassed the cataloguing and resolution of aesthetic principles deemed either insufficiently supported or excessively ornamental. In practice this meant that any principle advanced in writing could be referred to the Office, which would determine whether it was supported by precedent (in which case it was catalogued) or ornamental (in which case it was catalogued as an ornament and fined). The distinction was never defined, and the Office came to treat the act of defining it as itself ornamental.

The Twelfth Adjustment

The Office's best-remembered instrument is its refinement of The Principle of Aesthetic Restraint, which defined "elaboration" for the purposes of enforcement and issued the Twelfth Adjustment to the Principle. The Twelfth Adjustment established that a surface bearing more than three decorative elements not required by function was to be treated as elaborating on itself, and was therefore subject to restraint. Because the Office's own headquarters facade carried four ceremonial brackets of no structural purpose, the Office was obliged to restrain its own entrance in the winter of the year it issued the Adjustment. The brackets were removed to Floor 6,113, where three of them remain on display and the fourth is listed as missing in the Master Ledger's furniture schedule.

"The brackets were required by sentiment and not by function, and sentiment is not among the grounds on which restraint may be deferred."

— Office of Aesthetic Propriety, ruling of the Adjudicatory Panel, Twelfth Adjustment, annex 2

The Department and the Reporting Line

The Office oversaw the Department of Aesthetic Incongruities from that Department's creation, an arrangement the Office described in its own correspondence as "enduring," and issued rulings that amended the Department's mandate at least eleven times before its dissolution. The Department of Aesthetic Compliance reports to the Office in matters of interpretive precedent; since the dissolution, that reporting line stands formally open. The Compliance Department continues to forward its precedent queries to Floor 6,117, where they are received, stamped, and filed by a duty clerk who has no authority to answer them. The practice is defended in Compliance's standing orders as "preserving the form of the thing pending the form of the thing's restoration."

The Office also selected Librarians from an approved roster to constitute the Librarians' Adjudicatory Panel, a function now exercised by the Ceremonial Office without alteration to the roster, which has not been revised since the dissolution and contains several names that no longer correspond to serving Librarians.

Dissolution and Disagreement

The circumstances of dissolution are the subject of the archive's most durable disagreement. The Office's own final recension describes the dissolution as administrative, effected by the transfer of standard-setting authority to the Office of Ceremonial Consistency, and insists that "the Office persists in its precedents, which are not dissolved." The Department of Unfiled Aesthetics, which inherited the Office's unindexed correspondence, records instead that the Office was dissolved by the operation of its own Twelfth Adjustment, applied to its own docket: the docket had grown to four thousand entries, was found to be elaborating on itself, and was restrained. The Department's position is set out in a memorandum known informally as the Spoon Finding, on which see the Dispute of the Unaccounted Spoon.

The Ceremonial Office declines to adjudicate between these accounts. Its published position is that the question is one of interpretive precedent, that interpretive precedent was formerly a matter for the Office of Aesthetic Propriety, and that the reporting line is therefore open. The matter has been open since the dissolution and is reviewed annually.

Holdings

The Office's surviving records are held on Floor 6,117 and comprise, per the accession schedule:

  • 412 catalogued Aesthetic Amp Contextual Conflicts, of which 61 remain unresolved and 9 are recorded as resolved in error;
  • the Twelfth Adjustment in three recensions, two of them sealed;
  • the approved roster of the Librarians' Adjudicatory Panel, unrevised;
  • four ceremonial brackets, three on display, one missing;
  • the docket, four thousand entries, restrained.

Consultation is by appointment. Visitors are asked not to remark on the entrance.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

The Principle of Aesthetic Restraint: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Aesthetic Restraint is a foundational regulatory doctrine within the Tower that asserts an aesthetic element, once introduced into a space or context, is most properly understood when its expressive pote…

The Principle of Aesthetic Restraint
Department of Aesthetic Incongruities: who are they?

Department of Aesthetic Incongruities is a regulatory and archival body charged with the identification, classification, and, where possible, remediation of aesthetic principles deemed to be in a state of conflict with t…

Department of Aesthetic Incongruities
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
The Principle of Sequential Propriety: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Sequential Propriety is a foundational doctrine within the Manual of Arithmetical Decorum governing the ethical and procedural constraints surrounding the numbering, traversal, and ontological classifica…

The Principle of Sequential Propriety

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.