The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Librarian-Provost of Adjacency

MS 2032.08 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Librarian-Provost of Adjacency is a conjoint office of the Tower, held by a single individual who bears simultaneously the administrative rank of Provost and the custodial authority of Librarian over all matters touching upon adjacency between floors. The office is unique among the Tower's conjunctions in that neither half may be exercised alone: a Librarian-Provost who shelves a volume without first surveying its neighbours, or who surveys a neighbourhood without recording the volume, is held to have vacated the office for the duration of the act. The present holder, Librarian-Provost Sereth of the Ninth Stack, was appointed in the winter of the year 4,412 and has not left the Ninth Stack since.

Origin and the Amalgamation Instrument

The office was created by the Amalgamation Instrument of 3,908, a two-clause document drafted after the prolonged dispute known as the Quarrel of the Twinned Seals, in which the Provosts of Survey and the Librarians of Access each claimed the right to certify the boundaries of Floors 611 through 640. For nineteen years neither office would recognize the other's certificates, and the floors in question accumulated two sets of mutually exclusive boundary records, kept in rooms on opposite sides of the same corridor.

The Instrument resolved the quarrel by abolishing both claimants and substituting a single officer. Its operative clause is brief and has been much annotated: "That which lies beside a thing shall be known only to one who may both read and shelve it" (Amalgamation Instrument of 3,908, clause 2). The Instruments's preamble, considerably longer, is chiefly a list of the rooms in question and is read aloud in full at each appointment, a custom that takes the better part of an afternoon.

Duties and the Boundary Register

The Librarian-Provost maintains the Boundary Register, a continuous record of every certified adjacency in the Tower, together with the date of certification and the officer who performed it. The Register is not a map; the office has refused four times to produce a map, on the ground that a map is an assertion and the Register is only a recollection. This distinction is upheld in Ruling 4491, which found that the Register's silence about a given pair of floors is not evidence that they are unadjacent, merely that no one has recently said otherwise.

Adjacency survives on testimony, and testimony must be renewed. Under the Doctrine of Coherent Adjacency, no boundary certification lapses, but every certification grows quieter: after forty years unrenewed, it may no longer be cited in a dispute without corroboration, and after eighty it is entered in the Register in a paler hand. It remains, nonetheless, in force. The Librarian Geodesy Office has contested this arrangement since its dimensional surveys of Floor 307, which the Geodesy Office maintains is not adjacent to Floor 306 at all, and possibly never was.

Relations with the Geodesy Office

The Geodesy Office and the Librarian-Provost have been at variance since the survey returns of 4,401. The dispute is not personal. It is procedural, and both parties insist so in nearly identical language. The Geodesy Office measures; the Librarian-Provost certifies; the Template:… Principle of Direct Adjacency requires that a floor be adjacent to those it touches, but does not say who decides which floors those are.

"The Office does not dispute the measurements. The Office disputes that a measurement may be entered where no one has stood the volumes together and seen that they agree."

— Boundary Register, prefatory note to the 4,401 recension

Each year the Geodesy Office submits its returns and each year the Librarian-Provost files them, in full, in the Adjacency Reports annex, without certification. The annex now occupies eleven rooms and is, by square measure, the largest holding of uncertified survey in the Tower. Provost Alaric, as Director of the Directorate of Luminescence and Refraction, has twice offered to illuminate the annex more efficiently; both offers were declined on the ground that the annex is already too easy to find.

The Feud of the Paler Hand

The office's most cited irregularity concerns the Recalibration of 712. Following that event, the Librarian-Provost of the day, Librarian-Provost Odren the Fourth, entered the boundary certifications of the 712th Floor into the Register in the pale hand forty-one years ahead of schedule, citing "presentiment" in the marginal note. Provost Aris of the 712th Floor objected in a memorandum of considerable length, pointing out that the certifications had been made under the Imperial Taxonomy and were therefore by material adjacency and historical provenance, not by presentiment. The Tribunal of Entries heard the matter in 3,977 and held for Odren, reasoning that a marginal note is not a certification and may therefore say whatever it likes.

The precedent has since been invoked eleven times, twice successfully. It is the standard defense for any annotation discovered in the Register's margins and is cited, informally, as the Doctrine of the Margin, though it appears in no numbered document. Odren's original note remains legible on the leaf. Someone has since written beneath it, in the pale hand, "it is not presentiment if it is the fortieth time."

Appointment and the Ascent

The Librarian-Provost is installed at the thirty-second station of the Provost's Ascent, where the Provost of Precise Ambiguity presides over the Ceremony of the Assumed Integer and, by longstanding courtesy, yields the final certification to the incoming officer. The incoming Librarian-Provost must then shelve a single volume by hand in the Ninth Stack and record its neighbours. The volume used at the last three installments has been the same one, and no one has yet recorded its neighbours as anything but "as before."

Visitors to the Register are asked to leave their coats at the door and to take nothing from the shelves, including the shelves. The office answers correspondence on the third and seventeenth of each month and does not accept inquiries by descent.

Scholarly Disagreement

The Forty-Seventh Concordance holds at Annex 6 that the office is a temporary expedient, renewable at the pleasure of the Librarians, and that the Amalgamation Instrument's clause 2 was intended to lapse after the Quarrel's generation had died out. The Doctrine of Coherent Adjacency, however, treats the office as constitutive, on the ground that adjacency has no existence apart from the record of it, and that abolishing the office would therefore abolish the subject. The Catalogue Schism produced a third view, that the office and the Register are one entity and the officer only its instrument, a position generally regarded as unhelpful to the officer, who is required to draw a salary.

No proposal to resolve the disagreement has been put to a vote. The office has noted, twice, that the disagreement is itself adjacent to the Register's contents, and has declined to certify it.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Doctrine of Coherent Adjacency: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Coherent Adjacency is the foundational principle upon which the Bureau of Coherent Truths operates and the standard to which the Department of Coherent Placement holds every act of placement on the Tower'…

Doctrine of Coherent Adjacency
Ceremony of the Assumed Integer: how is it conducted?

Ceremony of the Assumed Integer is an annual bureaucratic ritual held on Floor 719-β (the "Provisional Mezzanine") to reconcile the Tower's theoretical and practical accounting systems. It centers on the formal recogniti…

Ceremony of the Assumed Integer
Adjacency Reports: what does it set out?

Adjacency Reports (also classified as Series 40-A under the Archival Index) are formal, templated documents generated to assess and register the nature of inter-floor connections within the Tower, as mandated by the Fort…

Adjacency Reports
Librarian-Provost of Adjacency: who are they?

The Librarian-Provost of Adjacency is a conjoint office of the Tower, held by a single individual who bears the administrative rank of Provost and the custodial authority of Librarian over all matters of adjacency betwee…

Librarian-Provost of Adjacency

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.