The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Census of Reaches Personnel

MS 3611.05 · Documents and ordinances

The Census of Reaches Personnel is the standing enumeration of persons employed in, seconded to, or indefinitely detained by the survey and catalogue offices of the Tower's several Reaches. It is distinguished from the Vertical Census in that it counts persons rather than floors, and from the Aperture Census in that it makes no claim to have located them. The Census is conducted under the authority of the Census Bureau at intervals of nine years, and its returns are filed by Reach rather than by name, a convention adopted in 1104 and never revisited.

Personnel counted by the Census are entered on the rolls of the Personnel Annex under Title VII, where they are assigned a graded disposition by the Office of Personnel. A person may appear in the Census of Reaches Personnel, be counted again in the Census of Reaches Personnel nine years later, and hold no other record of employment anywhere in the Tower. The Bureau regards this as correct procedure.

Scope and method

The Census takes as its field the four Reaches customarily recognised for administrative purposes: the Upper Reaches, the Lower Reaches, the Axiomatic Reaches, and the Reaches Peripheral, the last of which has no fixed extent and is counted by estimate. Enumerators proceed in pairs, one to count and one to confirm the count, and neither is permitted to know the other's figure until the return is sealed. Discrepancies are resolved by the presiding enumerator, who is instructed to prefer the larger figure on the grounds that "absence of record is not record of absence" (Census Field Manual: Provisional Addendum, clause 12).

The counting of the Axiomatic Reaches is complicated by the western spiral, which brings enumerators past Floor 744 on three separate occasions in the course of a single ascent. Clause 19 of the same Addendum provides that personnel encountered more than once shall be counted once, and requires the enumerator to determine which encounter was the real one. No method for making this determination has ever been issued. Enumerators are advised to use the first.

The Graded Dispositions

Persons counted are sorted into four graded dispositions: Present, Present and Accounted For, Present but Otherwise Engaged, and Not Present, Recorded. The fourth category was introduced in 1188 to accommodate the survey parties of the Upper Reaches Cataloguing Project, whose members were known to be on the Project's books while being, for long periods, nowhere the Bureau could reach. The Clerks' Guild of the Lower Reaches, entrusted with the minute documentation of administrative acts, objected that a census which counts the absent is a register and not a census. The Bureau replied that a register which does not count the absent is a list. Both positions were entered in the record and neither was withdrawn.

Disposition is assigned by the Office of Personnel and may be revised on appeal. Revisions are frequent in the Lower Reaches, where the Dim Galleries have absorbed a number of enumerators over the years; those recovered are re-entered as Present, and those not recovered are entered as Present but Otherwise Engaged, pending a determination that has not yet been scheduled.

The returns of 1269 and the Hollow Floor dispute

The returns of 1269 are the most closely studied in the Census's history, chiefly because of the incident at Floor 81.4. The floor contributed eleven personnel to the Census of Untaken Breaths in that year, and the same eleven were independently returned by the Reaches enumerators as Present. The Bureau, finding two returns for eleven persons, struck the second on the principle that a person counted under one Census cannot be counted under another in the same cycle. The Office of Personnel declined to strike the first, the Clerks' Guild of the Lower Reaches declined to seal either, and the matter passed to the Concordance of Returns.

"Where a person is returned twice in one cycle, the earlier return stands. Where the returns bear the same date, neither stands, and the person is carried forward."

— Concordance of Returns, Article 7

Both returns bore the same date. The eleven were carried forward, and have been carried forward in every cycle since. The Bureau refers to them internally as the Hollow Floor eleven. It has never been established whether they are alive, and the question is not one the Census is competent to answer.

Disagreement among the Concordances

Scholarly opinion divides on whether the Census of Reaches Personnel is a true census or a form of attachment. The Upper Reaches Concordance treats it as a census, citing its designation of Floor 714 as a survey floor and the presence of enumerators there in every cycle since 1191. The Second Concordance on Enumeration treats it as neither, holding at Annex 2 that "the counting of persons in the employ of the counting office is a matter of housekeeping and shall not be reported as a finding." The Third Concordance does not mention the Census at all, which some read as tacit repeal and others as an omission corrected by the Personnel Annex at Title VII.

The Historical Commissioner is recorded as having resolved a related acoustic dispute in the Upper Reaches on the ground that "a name spoken twice is one name, and a name counted twice is a question of procedure." The ruling has been cited in every dispute over the Hollow Floor eleven and has settled none of them.

Recent cycles and the question of the Peripheral

The most recent complete cycle returned 4,116 personnel across the three fixed Reaches and an estimated 300 in the Peripheral, the estimate being given to the nearest hundred and marked provisional in the margin. The Peripheral figure has not changed in four cycles, though the number of enumerators assigned to it has risen from six to forty-one. The Bureau notes that this is consistent with the Peripheral having no fixed extent, and has declined to comment further.

Enumerators assigned to the Peripheral are issued with chalk and are required to mark their route on the floor beneath them as they proceed. A returning enumerator who cannot find the marks is entered as Not Present, Recorded, and is not entitled to appeal until the following cycle. The Census of Reaches Personnel has, by this provision, counted its own staff among the unreachable since 1203.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Census Field Manual: Provisional Addendum: what does it set out?

The Census Field Manual: Provisional Addendum is the authoritative procedural guide governing the registration, classification, and archival handling of all provisional entities encountered by the Office of the Provision…

Census Field Manual: Provisional Addendum
Personnel Annex: who are they?

Personnel Annex refers to the non-canonical, extra-concordant body of auxiliary staff responsible for the physical stewardship of archival materials that are officially designated as non-existent. These personnel are not…

Personnel Annex
Clerks' Guild of the Lower Reaches: who are they?

Clerks' Guild of the Lower Reaches is the hereditary-adjacent association of recording clerks, tally-keepers, and seal-apprentices formally entrusted with the minute documentation of administrative acts within the Lower …

Clerks' Guild of the Lower Reaches
Census of Untaken Breaths: how is it conducted?

Census of Untaken Breaths is the official designation for the primary enumeration conducted during Census Hour on Floor 308. It is mandated under Article 7, Clause Δ, of the Third Concordance and overseen by the Census B…

Census of Untaken Breaths

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.