The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Personnel Evaluation

MS 5731.45 · Practices and doctrines

Personnel Evaluation is the standing procedure by which the Office of Personnel assigns each clerk, porter, copyist and annex-bound labourer a graded disposition, reviewed at intervals set by the Personnel Rotations schedule. The grade is not a judgment of the person evaluated. It is a judgment of the post that person occupies, corrected for the person's tenure in it, and the distinction is maintained with some force in the Concordance on Personnel Safety, Title II, which states that "no evaluation shall attach to a name, only to a station, and only for so long as the station persists" (Title II, clause 6). In practice, the correction for tenure has never been computed to anyone's satisfaction, and the dispute over how to compute it has run for over a century without resolution.

Structure of the Evaluation

An evaluation proceeds in four stages, of which only the first three are recorded. Stage One is the collation of the station's existing file from the general archives; Stage Two is the comparison of that file against the post's nominal standard; Stage Three is the written finding, entered in duplicate and sealed. Stage Four — the interview, in which the evaluated clerk is asked to confirm the finding — is conducted without a recorder present. The Personnel Annex records that Stage Four is "conducted aloud and without record," and offers no further explanation. The absence of a transcript at Stage Four has been challenged repeatedly and upheld each time on the grounds that what is said there "is not, properly speaking, said" (Office of Personnel, Standing Minute 41-C).

Grades run from A (conforms) to D (does not conform, and the post is to be considered for reclassification). A fifth grade, E, appears in the schedules but is never awarded. Enquiries as to its meaning are returned unopened with a slip reading only "E is not an evaluation."

The Corrections Schedule and the Vallum Dispute

The tenure correction was introduced by the Corrections Schedule of 1352, which assigns a diminishing fraction to each successive year in a post, so that a clerk of long standing is judged less strictly against the post's standard than a new arrival. The Schedule was revised in 1352, 1390 and 1441, and the three recensions disagree on the fraction's denominator.

"A clerk in the ninth year of a station shall be measured against one-third of the standard, and no more, being presumed to have become the station."

— Corrections Schedule of 1352, Table Two

The Third Recension (1441) substitutes "shall be measured against one-half" and appends a marginal note in the hand of the Deputy Registrar, Maud Vallum, reading "this cannot be right, but it is what was sealed." The Vallum Dispute, as the disagreement is now called, has produced some two hundred pages of internal correspondence and no amendment. The Office continues to apply the 1352 fraction on the lower floors and the 1441 fraction above Floor 900, on the grounds that "the upper floors have always been more lenient, and to correct this would be to invent a past" (Minute of the Registrar's Bench, undated).

Relationship to Absorptive Potential Evaluation

Personnel Evaluation is frequently confused with Absorptive Potential Evaluation, the third-stage assessment of Type A holdings under the Material Authentication Protocol. The two are unrelated. Absorptive Potential Evaluation concerns entities' latent capacity for Absorptive Stasis and is carried out by the Analytical Cartographers; Personnel Evaluation concerns clerks and is carried out by the Office of Personnel. The confusion is so persistent that the Office of Personnel has, since 1487, stamped every personnel finding "NOT AN ABSORPTIVE FINDING" in red along the lower margin. The stamp has itself been mistaken for a finding of some kind, and a circular clarifying this was issued in 1490, which in turn required clarification in 1493. No further circulars have been attempted.

Evaluation and the Vault of Pending Personnel

Evaluations of clerks who are themselves under rotation are suspended until the rotation completes. Where the rotation does not complete — because the receiving floor's register has not been sealed, or because the clerk's cohort has been divided contrary to Title IV — the evaluation lapses into the Vault of Pending Personnel, where it joins the accumulations described elsewhere. The Vault is jointly keyed by the Office of Personnel and the Deputy Registrar for Personnel Anomalies, an arrangement introduced after the loss of 1,200 uncompleted evaluations in the winter of 1302, when a misplaced key left a cohort of copyists unevaluated for eleven years and, it is said, notably cheerful.

An evaluation lodged in the Vault is not void. It is pending, and a pending evaluation may be revived by the return of the clerk to the original station, provided the station still exists. Where the station has been reclassified as non-existent, the evaluation is transferred to the Personnel Annex for custodial filing and may not be revived, though it may be consulted. Clerks have been known to consult their own pending evaluations, a practice neither permitted nor forbidden, and which the Division of Conditional Permissions has declined to rule on three times.

Recording Practice and the Amp Logs

Findings are logged in the format prescribed by Annex F Personnel Amp Logging, whose columns require the evaluator to record the clerk's station, cohort, grade and tenure, and a fifth column headed "rem." for remarks. The remarks column is sealed at logging and unsealed only at the next scheduled review. Evaluators are instructed to write remarks "plainly and without embellishment," and the archive holds some 40,000 sealed remarks whose contents are unknown to the clerks they concern. A survey of unsealed remarks conducted in 1499 found that the most frequent entry was "nothing to remark," followed closely by "as before."

Personnel Evaluation is not a disciplinary instrument. A grade of D does not commence any proceeding; it commences a reclassification review of the post, which may take decades. The Office's own guidance is that "the evaluation is a record, not a verdict, and records are kept because keeping them is what the Tower does" (Concordance on Personnel Safety, Preamble). Clerks are advised not to read their own files before an interview. The advice is printed on the folder.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Vault of Pending Personnel: where is it?

The Vault of Pending Personnel is a classified administrative annex located on Floor 117, designated as the final repository for all records pertaining to Tower personnel whose official status has been rendered indetermi…

Vault of Pending Personnel
Concordance on Personnel Safety: what does it set out?

The Concordance on Personnel Safety is the most recent primary governing document for Personnel Safety, ratified in the 3,988th cycle and amended, by the count of the Office of Personnel, one hundred and forty-one times …

Concordance on Personnel Safety
Annex F Personnel Amp Logging: how is it conducted?

Annex F Personnel Amp Logging is the administrative schedule governing the joint presence of custodial staff and logging apparatus at a single site. It is not a document in its own right but a standing annexe, first appe…

Annex F Personnel Amp Logging
Office of Personnel: who are they?

The Office of Personnel is the administrative body responsible for the formal identification, assignment, and procedural status of all individuals officially recognized as functioning within the Tower's bureaucratic appa…

Office of Personnel

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.