The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Argument of the Four Siblings

MS 1018.86 · Practices and doctrines

The Argument of the Four Siblings is the collective designation for four related but non-identical disputes concerning inheritance, priority, and the ownership of a single stairwell on the boundary of Floors 218 and 219. It is not one argument conducted by four parties but four arguments conducted, at various times, by the same four offices, each of which maintains that its own reading is the original and that the other three are recensions of it. The dispute has been under continuous adjudication since the winter of the year recorded in the Tower's internal reckoning as 12 044, and remains unresolved. It is frequently cited in procedural instruction as the clearest available example of an argument that has outlived every party's interest in its outcome.

The four siblings are not persons. The name is conventional and was applied by the clerks of the Registry of Contested Stairwells on the analogy of a family quarrel; the offices themselves have never used it in their own filings. They are the Office of the Elder Claim, the Office of the Younger Claim, the Office of the Late Claim, and the Office of the Unclaimed Portion. Each holds a sealed instrument purporting to grant it priority over the landing and the twenty-two steps descending from it.

The Four Instruments

The instruments are distinct in form and in the circumstances of their sealing, and this difference is the substance of the dispute rather than an incidental feature of it. A summary of the four, with the designations used in the Register of Sealed Instruments, is set out below.

Office Instrument Date of sealing Principal claim
Office of the Elder Claim Elder Instrument 12 044, eleventh month Priority by seniority of office
Office of the Younger Claim Younger Instrument 12 044, twelfth month Priority by proximity of sealing
Office of the Late Claim Late Instrument 12 047, second month Priority by ratification after the fact
Office of the Unclaimed Portion Portion Schedule undated; attributed to 12 046 No priority; assertion of vacancy

The Portion Schedule is the difficulty. It does not claim the stairwell for its office but asserts that no instrument validly claims it, and that the landing therefore falls to the Office of the Unclaimed Portion by default of all others. The office accordingly participates in the argument while denying that there is an argument to participate in — a position the Concordance of Sealed Disputes has described, in its ruling of 12 061, as "admissible and self-defeating in equal measure" (Concordance of Sealed Disputes, Ruling 12 061/9).

The Winter of the Sealing

The three dated instruments were all sealed within fourteen weeks of one another during the winter that closed the year 12 044. The Scriptorium of the Lower Landings was at that time operating under a heating restriction imposed by the Concordance of Restricted Scriptoria, and the clerks worked in shifts of four hours with the seals kept warm in a brazier between uses. The restriction is not usually considered relevant to the dispute. It is mentioned here because the Office of the Late Claim has argued, in its Memorial on the Condition of the Seals, that the wax of the period was uncommonly soft and that impressions taken in it should not be read as final. The other three offices reject this, the Office of the Elder Claim on the grounds that its own seal was struck cold and is therefore unaffected, the others on the grounds that a seal is a seal.

The clerk most closely associated with the sealing is Clerk Amaranth Vos, who witnessed all three dated instruments and whose hand appears in the margins of each. Vos was subsequently appointed to the Subcommittee on Instrument Authenticity and recused herself from its deliberations on the four siblings in 12 052. Her private notes, deposited in the Archive of Unheard Speeches as part of the Unheard Archive's holdings, record only that the winter was cold and that the brazier was inadequate. Neither statement has settled anything.

The Disagreement Over Recension

The central scholarly disagreement concerns which of the four arguments is prior. The Third Concordance holds, at Annex 7, that the Elder and Younger Instruments were sealed in the same session and that the later of the two is therefore a correction of the earlier rather than a rival to it. The Sixth Concordance holds, at clause 4.2, that two instruments sealed on different days cannot share a session and that the Annex 7 finding is "a convenience adopted to reduce the number of pending matters" (Sixth Concordance, clause 4.2). The Concordance of Sealed Disputes has declined to resolve the question, observing that it has been asked to do so on three occasions and has found the record insufficient each time.

"The Commission notes that the four instruments are mutually inconsistent, that each is internally sound, and that the landing in question is eleven feet by six and cannot accommodate four offices asserting exclusive use of it. The Commission does not consider this last observation to be decisive."

— Concordance of Sealed Disputes, Ruling 12 061/9, Annex 2

The Intrinsic Numeration Argument has been invoked twice by the Office of the Younger Claim, on the reasoning that the numbering of the instruments establishes their order independently of their content. The Conditional Existence Argument has been invoked once, by the Office of the Unclaimed Portion, to suggest that an instrument claiming a thing that is also claimed by three others cannot be said to exist unconditionally. Neither invocation produced a ruling.

Procedure and Its Costs

Hearings are held in The Argument Place on Floor 404, though the four siblings have never been heard together. Each office petitions separately, and the Committee for Ontological Review has ruled that consolidating the four would prejudice the Unclaimed Portion's assertion of vacancy. The result is that the same stairwell is argued four times over, at four times the cost, before a committee that has already stated it cannot decide the matter.

The stairwell itself remains in use. A sign posted at the upper landing in 12 071 directs travellers to use the eastern stair instead. The sign is maintained by the Office of the Unclaimed Portion, which is the only one of the four offices with a maintenance allotment for the landing, a circumstance the other three cite as evidence of de facto possession and the Unclaimed Portion cites as evidence of nothing at all.

Current Standing

The four siblings remain on the docket of The Argument as four separate matters, numbered 12 044/1 through 12 044/4, the numbering itself being disputed. The Stack of Open Argument holds folios for all four, and the Stack of Open Argument Stabilization protocol has been extended to cover them on the grounds that four unresolved claims to one landing constitute an ontological instability. The protocol's officers have requested that the parties settle, and have been refused in writing by all four offices, the Unclaimed Portion's refusal being the most emphatic.

No party has withdrawn. No instrument has been annulled. The stairwell is climbed daily by persons unconnected with the dispute, who are advised to use the eastern stair and mostly do.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Committee for Ontological Review: who are they?

The Committee for Ontological Review (commonly abbreviated COR) is a five-member administrative body established by Clause VII of the Eleventh Concordance to adjudicate petitions regarding the reality-status of any holdi…

Committee for Ontological Review
Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing): how is it conducted?

Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing) is the permanent administrative holding pattern and curatorial protocol by which the Librarians maintain the structural and ontological coherence of The Stack of Open Argume…

Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing)
Stack of Open Argument: what does it set out?

Stack of Open Argument is a permanent archival holding administered from The Argument on Floor 111: The Athenaeum of Open Questions. It consists of 3,742 distinct folios, each containing a single unresolved motion for on…

Stack of Open Argument
Intrinsic Numeration Argument: how is it conducted?

Intrinsic Numeration Argument refers to the prolonged and unresolved philosophical and administrative debate concerning the nature and source of floor numbers within The Tower. The central question is whether a floor's n…

Intrinsic Numeration Argument

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.