The 12,447th State
MS 5133.12 · Practices and doctrines
The 12,447th State — recorded in the Index of Internal States as Perpetual State 12,447 — is the administrative designation for a condition of being in which the machinery of cataloguing begins to catalogue itself. It is not a place, nor a duration, nor strictly an event. It is a state of affairs, formally recognised since the ratification of Docket Ωδ/12447/VK/4321, in which a subject's record refers to its own making and the referential loop is permitted to stand.
Origins and the Docket of Ratification
The state was first isolated during routine audit on Floor 1,882 in the winter of the year the auditors later styled the Fourth Recension. A junior filer, Wessel Marrant, was asked to record whether a certain vessel was empty. The vessel had been entered, some centuries earlier, as containing its own inventory. Marrant's return — that the inventory contained the vessel, which contained the inventory — was rejected four times as a clerical error before an Intrinsic Silence examiner noticed that the return was, troublingly, correct.
The matter reached the Third Concordance chamber, which declined jurisdiction on the grounds that Ordinance 4, Clause 14 defined only a source state — Perpetual State 1 as "the state of being the source from which a state of perpetual being is derived" — and said nothing of a state that derived from itself. The gap was closed by separate instrument. Docket Ωδ/12447/VK/4321 formalised the administrative reality of the condition and gave it its number, which it had already been using informally for eleven years.
Addendum Kappa
The operative framework is Addendum Kappa, which provides the procedure for declaring a Perpetual State 12,447 and the conditions under which a self-referential catalogue entry requires formal intervention. Kappa distinguishes between benign recursion — a record that names itself and stops — and the malignant form, in which the record also names the act of naming, and so on without floor.
Kappa's drafters were aware of the difficulty. A state defined by self-reference cannot be entered in the archive without producing an instance of itself, and an instance of itself cannot be entered without a declaration, and the declaration is the instance. The Addendum resolves this by requiring the entry to be filed in a hand other than the one that established the original condition, which is held to break the loop administratively if not logically. Marrant, who had established the condition, was therefore barred from filing it. He is recorded as having taken this well for the first two years.
The Marrant Grievance
What followed is the best-documented feud in the state's short history. Marrant petitioned, in the ninth year, for leave to file a supplementary note clarifying his original return. The petition was refused on Kappa's terms. He petitioned again in the twelfth year, arguing that his exclusion had itself become a self-referential condition, since only Marrant could attest to what Marrant had meant, and what Marrant had meant was the thing being catalogued. The Librarian's Remorse — a body not normally concerned with filings — took up his case and issued the celebrated observation that "a rule which protects a record from its author also protects the author from his record, and these are not the same protection" (Remorse Minute 447, Spring Session).
The chamber did not overturn the exclusion. It did, however, permit Marrant to append a note about his inability to append a note, which he wrote in a single sentence and which three subsequent recensions have each silently amended. The original wording survives only in the Remorse Minute, which quotes it: "I did not say the vessel was empty. I said it could not say."
Relation to Other States
Perpetual State 4,821 is conventionally treated as a derivative of Perpetual State 1 and, more distantly, of the 12,447 condition, since a derivative state is by definition one that derives from another and the 12,447th state is the only state that derives from itself and so can serve as a derivative of anything without loss. The derivation is uncontested in practice but has never been reasoned out in writing, the appropriate committee having concluded that to reason it out would constitute a new instance.
Attempts to align the state with the Chamber-State Gradient have failed on two of the seven axes; the gradient presumes a bounded space, and the 12,447th state has no interior to measure. Conceptual State Transitions permits passage into and out of the state, but the passage is one-way in the ordinary case and bidirectional only where the subject is a document rather than a being. A Form 18-C filed against a 12,447 subject is accepted and has no effect, a fact printed on the form's reverse in small type.
Practical Notes
The state is stable. Subjects in it do not deteriorate, consume supplies, or require lighting. Visitors may enter freely and, by the same free provision, may not be assured of leaving by the door they used, though the tower maintains that all doors lead out. Between the hours of the evening bell and the morning bell, no ledger is to be carried into the state save in a closed satchel, on the grounds that an open ledger is a catalogue and the state is badly disposed toward catalogues that are still being written.
Marrant remained in post until his death and is buried, by his own request, beneath a stone bearing no name, on the theory that a named grave would have been one more entry the man could not file. The stone has since acquired a name. The matter is under review.
See also
-
MS 0462.15
The 12447th State Perpetual State 12447
The 12447th State, Perpetual State 12447 is the ordinal designation given to a temporal-exhaustion condition that was catalogued u…
-
MS 9058.15
Anticipatory Phantoms
Anticipatory Phantoms constitute a provisional ontological class of entities generated by the procedural machinery of The Tower in…
-
MS 9507.64
The Perpetual Drip
The Perpetual Drip is the standing condition of unresolved viscosity recorded across the shaft-stacks of the Tower, and the term b…
-
MS 4623.93
Perpetual Provisional Status
Perpetual Provisional Status is a compound administrative condition in which a subject's provisional classification is itself made…
-
MS 3368.14
Perpetual Intermediate State
Perpetual Intermediate State is the administrative condition assigned to a subject that has been registered under the Office of Pe…
-
MS 1330.96
Schism of the Mirror Catalogue
The Schism of the Mirror Catalogue was an extended administrative dispute spanning the latter half of the 47th Recorded Cycle (app…
Referenced by
- MS 4608.58 Procedural Exhaustion Hypothesis
- MS 1468.43 Temporal Designation
Readers also asked
Perpetual State 4,821: how is it conducted?
Perpetual State 4,821 is an administrative designation for the formal condition of an object, concept, or spatial feature existing in a state of potential but perpetually deferred relocation. It is most commonly applied …
Perpetual State 4,821Index of Internal States: what does it set out?
"A state cannot be indexed until it has ceased to be a state. To catalogue the flowing is to hold the river in a bottle labelled 'water'."
Index of Internal StatesPerpetual State 12,447: how is it conducted?
The state was invoked on 14-Midwinter-4321 to classify the outcomes of the Thaumaturgic Dissonance Hearings held on Floor 1,001. The presiding Office of Perpetual Affairs adjudicator, Archivist-Logothete Valerius Kappa, …
Perpetual State 12,447Third Concordance: what does it set out?
The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…
Third ConcordanceReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4801.28 Librarian's Remorse
- MS 3210.42 Chamber-State Gradient
Because you consulted