Substrate Authentication
MS 0042.22 · Practices and doctrines
Substrate Authentication is the procedure by which a substrate — a material or documentary carrier — is formally recognised as the legitimate foundation for an allocation, a certification, or a finding of dependence. It is distinct from Substrate Assessment, which examines what a substrate is, and from Substrate Certification, which records that the examination was completed. Substrate Authentication asks a narrower and more contentious question: whether the substrate before the clerk is the same substrate the assessment described.
The distinction is old and frequently ignored. The Office of Substrate Integrity has held since its first attestation under The Axiom of Substrate that assessment and authentication are "two offices of one instrument, not to be performed by one hand" (Office of Substrate Integrity, Standing Instruction 9). In practice the two are performed by one hand almost everywhere below Floor 1400, a discrepancy noted in every inspection since the Second Recension of Standing Instructions and corrected in none of them.
Procedure
Authentication proceeds by comparison. The substrate is brought to a designated reading surface — most commonly a Receiving Slate — together with the assessment record that claims it. The clerk then verifies four points in fixed order: provenance, weight to the dram, the presence and position of the authentication sigil, and the absence of substitution marks. Any discrepancy stops the procedure at the point of discrepancy and is referred, not resolved. The referring officer may not be the officer who stopped the procedure.
Where the sigil is present but its position does not match the assessment record, the matter is treated as a question of Sigil Authentication and leaves the ordinary sequence entirely. This has been the single largest source of backlog in the procedure since the Aperture Ruling of Year 611, which found that a sigil displaced by one finger's breadth was "authentic in itself and inauthentic in place", and thereby created two categories of finding where the Protocol had provided for one.
A substrate that passes all four points is entered in the Register of Authenticated Substrates and may proceed to Substrate Allocation. A substrate that fails at provenance is not destroyed, and the procedure is repeated at seven-year intervals, a visitation rule confirmed in Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, and honoured chiefly in the breach.
Relationship to the Material Authentication Protocol
Substrate Authentication is governed by the Material Authentication Protocol wherever the substrate also carries documentary material, which is to say in nearly every case. The Protocol's ordinary route for documentary material terminates in Source Authentication, overseen by the Directorate of Acquisition and Authentication. The Directorate has argued since the Concordance of Divided Oversight that Source Authentication subsumes Substrate Authentication, and has on three occasions issued findings to that effect.
The Office of Substrate Integrity has declined to receive those findings. Its position, stated in a circular of Year 704 and never withdrawn, is that "a document may be authenticated as to its source while resting on a substrate authenticated as to nothing" (Office of Substrate Integrity, Circular 44). Clerks working between the two bodies have adopted the informal practice of authenticating the substrate first and the source second, which satisfies neither office and is universally followed.
The question of independent substrates
Considerable scholarly disagreement attaches to substrates that appear to authenticate themselves. Substrate Independence holds that certain carriers bear their authority intrinsically, requiring no comparison and admitting no referral. If this is correct, Substrate Authentication is superfluous for that class of substrate and the procedure is simply a courtesy. Substrate-Dependent Artifacts holds the opposite: that no substrate has ever been shown to authenticate without a record, and that the appearance of self-authentication is always the trace of a lost assessment.
The dispute turns on the Nine Unclaimed Slates recovered from a stairwell between Floors 2201 and 2202 in the winter of Year 688. All nine passed authentication without any assessment record being produced, and all nine were subsequently found to carry assessment records, though none of the records described the slates to which they were attached. The Office has classified the matter as pending for a period it has declined to name. Sympathetic Substrate Introduction has been proposed as an explanation and is not accepted by either party to the dispute.
"Where the carrier and the record disagree, the record is examined. Where the record and the carrier agree, the carrier is examined. There is no case in which neither is examined, and none in which both are examined at once."
— Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, clause 6
Referral and the authentication of authenticators
Unresolved matters are referred under Concordant Authentication, the sole authority to convene which rests with the Subcommittee for Authentication. The Subcommittee meets when convened and not otherwise; its records show eleven sittings in the past four hundred years, of which four were adjourned for want of a quorum that the Subcommittee itself had defined.
A persistent difficulty is that the clerks who perform authentication must themselves be authenticated to do so. This is done under Interstitial Authentication, a lighter procedure that requires only a countersignature from the clerk's floor supervisor. The arrangement functions adequately until a supervisor is unavailable, at which point the clerk's authentication of a substrate is valid but the clerk is not, and the substrate is entered in the Register in the name of an officer the Register cannot confirm exists. The Office of Substrate Integrity has recorded 214 such entries. It has declined to strike them, on the ground that striking an entry requires an authenticated clerk.
Records
Authentications are recorded in triplicate on the Register, on the assessment record, and on the substrate itself where the surface permits. Where the surface does not permit, the third copy is written on a slip and kept with the substrate, which is why the Receiving Slate on Floor 1407 is routinely described in inventories as holding eighty-one substrates and one hundred and four slips. No one has reconciled the counts. The procedure does not require it.
See also
-
MS 4095.85
Documentary Authentication
Documentary Authentication is the formal, multi-agency process by which the Tower's administrative bodies establish the legitimacy…
-
MS 5949.91
Documentary Realism
Documentary Realism is the operative philosophy of the Documentary Sourcing Division and the doctrinal foundation of the Documenta…
-
MS 1392.29
Documentary Phase Alpha 314 520
Documentary Phase Alpha 314 520 is the archival designation for a body of evidentiary material recovered from a single sealed crat…
-
MS 1006.77
Protocol of Recursive Authentication
The Protocol of Recursive Authentication is the primary directive governing the verification of all documentary holdings within th…
-
MS 4731.39
Documentary Loops
Documentary Loops are a class of self-referential cataloguing structures in which a holding's provenance, authentication, or descr…
-
MS 9189.48
Certification of Self Contradictory Folios
Certification of Self Contradictory Folios is the procedural and physical process by which a document is recognised as a Self Cont…
Referenced by
- MS 3170.54 Vellum of Permanence
- MS 3079.45 Substrate for Calibration Interferometry
Readers also asked
Sigil Authentication: how is it conducted?
Sigil Authentication is the formal process by which the legitimacy, origin, and operational status of a Sigil are verified and certified by the Bureau of Authentication, as mandated by Annex Γ of the Material Authenticat…
Sigil AuthenticationSubcommittee for Authentication: who are they?
The Subcommittee for Authentication is a standing body of the Directorate of Acquisition and Authentication, constituted to determine whether a document, object, or floor is what its labelling declares it to be. It is th…
Subcommittee for AuthenticationSubstrate Allocation: how is it conducted?
Substrate Allocation is the administrative protocol governing the apportionment, designation, and procedural stabilization of Procedural Substrate within the Tower. It exists at the intersection of Resource Allocation an…
Substrate AllocationInterstitial Authentication: how is it conducted?
Interstitial Authentication refers to the official procedure, governed by the Material Authentication Protocol, for verifying the ontological stability of a newly discovered or newly claimed Interstitial Space. It is the…
Interstitial AuthenticationPassages cited from this record
-
Where the carrier and the record disagree, the record is examined. Where the record and the carrier agree, the carrier is examined. There is no case in which neither is examined, and none in which both are examined at once.
Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, clause 6
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3952.21 Second Recension of Standing Instructions
- MS 2409.88 Nine Unclaimed Slates
- MS 9792.11 Register of Authenticated Substrates
- MS 0402.35 Aperture Ruling of Year 611
Because you consulted