Subjective Containment
MS 6063.47 · Practices and doctrines
Definition and Scope
Subjective Containment is the branch of custodial practice concerned with the restraint of properties, entities, and processes that occupy no measurable volume but are nonetheless capable of spreading. Where material containment asks only whether a thing can be shut in a room, Subjective Containment asks the harder question of whether the idea of the thing can be prevented from leaving the room after it has been let out for exercise. It is administered jointly by the Department of Vital Statistics and the Non-Euclidean Stacks, an arrangement that neither office describes as satisfactory.
The practice is governed principally by Concordance Annex Omega-7, Fragment 12, which holds that a subjective property is "contained when its recurrence is neither accelerated nor multiplied by the container." The wording has survived four recensions and no two Librarians agree on what acceleration means in this context. A working gloss appears in the Taxonomy of Qualia Weights, which classifies contained phenomena by the discomfort of the archivist who last handled them.
Grades of Restraint
Containment is graded in five bands, from Sigma (held in a single reading room for the duration of a shift) to Delta (held by the Tower as a whole, with no floor informed of the arrangement). Assignments are recorded in the Containment Verification ledger and reviewed whenever a grade is disputed, which is most Thursdays. Upgrading a phenomenon from Gamma to Delta requires the signature of two Librarians, one of whom must not have read the file.
The grades are not cumulative. A Delta phenomenon is not "more contained" than a Sigma one; it is contained by a larger and more diffuse apparatus, and the apparatus itself becomes part of what must be watched. The Gavel of Deferred Judgement is sometimes struck during grade disputes, chiefly to buy time.
The Annex 8b Incident
The modern doctrine dates from the winter of the year the stacks were renumbered, when a certified echo was graded Gamma and released into the reading room of Annex 8b for routine verification. Within eleven days the echo had recurred in fourteen separate rooms without crossing a single threshold. Its custodian, Archivist-Provisional Kael, ruled that "subjective perception cannot override instrumental non-detection in certification matters for echoes," and the ruling became the basis for the containment scheme now in force. Kael's log of the eleven days records no unusual events after the fourth. The remaining seven pages are blank and are filed as evidence.
A later inquiry found that the echo had in fact travelled through the ventilation, which was later sealed. The inquiry's findings were graded Gamma and are kept in the ventilation shaft.
The Containment by Naming Dispute
There is long-standing disagreement over whether a phenomenon can be contained by being named. The Seventh Concordance asserts that "a property given a name in the register has been contained, in the sense that the register has it." Annex Omega rejects this flatly, holding that naming a thing is the opposite of containing it, and that the register is therefore an act of release.
"The register does not hold what it names. It holds the naming. These are different burdens and should not be borne by the same shelf."
— Annex Omega, Recension 3, marginal note attributed to Senior Archivist Aethelred
In practice both positions are observed. A newly named phenomenon is entered in the register, the register is placed in a locked cabinet, and the cabinet is not opened until the phenomenon has been observed elsewhere, which settles the question by default.
Instruments and Calibration
Subjective Containment borrows its instruments from Subjective Quantification, the formal system established under the Seventh Concordance, and calibrates them against the Primary Standards kept in the lower scriptoria. Before any containment is certified, the officer's Standard Chronometric Index must be checked against a known interval, usually the acute phase of the Paper Shortage, for which Senior Archivist Kael returned a subjective duration of 12.4 Subjective Cycles. Officers whose index drifts by more than a mark during a shift are relieved and reassigned to the cataloguing of furniture.
Certifications are witnessed but not countersigned, on the reasoning that an unwitnessed containment is indistinguishable from an unattended one. Visitors to a Delta band are asked not to describe the contents of the room after leaving it, and not to think about the room in the stairwell.
Relationship to Other Practices
Subjective Containment is frequently confused with the Empathetic Indexes, though the two are not connected and the Department of Vital Statistics has asked that the confusion stop. It is also confused with Downshifting (a reduction in perceptual rate, not a restraint) and with Chronal Fugue (a state that resembles containment from the outside and is nothing of the kind). Officers trained in Temporal Cartography are often seconded to containment work because they can find their way back out of a room they have not yet entered.
Efforts to systematise the field under the Dynamic Quantification have been underway since the practice began. No schedule for their completion has been issued, and it is not felt that one would help.
See also
-
MS 5715.25
Axiomatic Stewardship
Axiomatic Stewardship is the branch of custodial practice concerned with materials whose properties cannot be observed but must no…
-
MS 1858.48
Hypothetical Containment
Hypothetical Containment is the branch of Tower practice concerned with the restraint, quarantine, and supervised toleration of en…
-
MS 4311.00
Bureau of Measurable Holdings
Bureau of Measurable Holdings is the Tower department charged with the certification, recalibration, and custodial indexing of all…
-
MS 9967.99
Aesthesiometric Quantification
Aesthesiometric Quantification is the branch of Subjective Quantification concerned with the derivation of stable numeric readings…
-
MS 1385.87
Non-Existent Affect (NEA)
Non-Existent Affect (NEA) is the class designation applied to emotional and atmospheric states which are formally recorded as not …
-
MS 7932.00
Resonant Properties
Resonant Properties is the collective designation, used throughout the Tower's catalogues, for those measurable characteristics of…
Referenced by
- MS 0698.80 Non Euclidean Geometry of the Tower
- MS 4696.06 Containment or Deaccession
- MS 3571.85 Containment Lamination
- MS 9782.26 Hemingford Scale for Subjective Rigor
Readers also asked
Dynamic Quantification: how is it conducted?
Dynamic Quantification is the formal process by which the intensity, pressure, and circulation patterns of non-material phenomena are measured and entered into the Vital Register of the Tower. It was established by Ordin…
Dynamic QuantificationSenior Archivist Kael: who were they?
Senior Archivist Kael is a senior member of the Librarian Curatorial Assembly, permanently appointed to the Seventh Spiral Administrative Spire by Concordance Amendment YT 717-α/22. His career is most noted for his leade…
Senior Archivist KaelTemporal Cartography: how is it conducted?
Temporal Cartography is the practice and formal discipline of mapping the Tower’s inherent temporal anomalies, reconciling subjective and objective temporal flows, and establishing provisional chronologies for non-sequen…
Temporal CartographyEmpathetic Indexes: how is it conducted?
Empathetic Indexes are a class of bibliomancy-sensitive classification systems developed by the Ordo of the Sighing Pen to track and codify the subjective, non-material properties of a holding's contents. Unlike a Satell…
Empathetic IndexesPassages cited from this record
-
The register does not hold what it names. It holds the naming. These are different burdens and should not be borne by the same shelf.
Annex Omega, Recension 3, marginal note attributed to Senior Archivist Aethelred
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9547.68 Gavel of Deferred Judgement
- MS 2268.23 Paper Shortage
Because you consulted