The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Specimen 44Γ-01

MS 3278.03 · Objects and instruments

Specimen 44Γ-01 is a designation held, at the time of cataloguing, in abeyance. The number was issued by the Specimen Recovery Division on 11 March of an unrecorded year as part of the 44-series allotment, and no specimen has ever been confirmed to occupy it. The Division nevertheless maintains a full file, a storage cradle in Receiving Bay 107-B, and a standing requisition for its return. The file is among the most consulted in the Division's holdings, on the grounds that an empty designation attracts more correspondence than a full one.

The 44-series is commonly confused with the 44Δ-series, and the confusion is not merely typographical. Soporific Spore Specimen 44Δ-7 is frequently cited in error as 44Γ-01, particularly in the loose citations of the Stair Annex returns; the Annex has twice been asked to correct this and has twice declined, citing Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, which it reads as permitting "approximate designations where the specimen is asleep."

Origin of the designation

The 44-series was opened to absorb material recovered from the upper landings of The Specimen Stair during the third survey of that structure. Twenty-three designations were allotted at the outset. Twenty-two were filled within the season. The twenty-third — 44Γ-01 — was reserved for a specimen described in the survey ledger only as "the one that was counted twice and then not at all."

What this phrase refers to has never been settled. The survey party's foreman, Clerk Amarin Voss-Holt, recorded in her daybook that the party had entered Landing 9 with eleven items and left with eleven items, "though not, I think, the same eleven." She was later examined on this point by the Office of Aperture Works and declined to elaborate, stating that she had written what she had written and that the ledger could speak for itself. The ledger does not speak for itself; it contains a coffee stain and the numeral 11, twice.

The empty cradle

Receiving Bay 107-B holds a cradle for 44Γ-01 at position 14, between the cradle of Specimen 881-1901 and a gap maintained for Specimen 773, which is domiciled adjacent to Cable Vine specimen B4 and has never required a cradle. Position 14 is fitted with a retention strap, a humidity card, and a small brass plaque reading 44Γ-01 — RESERVED. The strap is checked weekly. It has not been fastened since the cradle was installed.

Bay practice requires that reserved cradles be inspected on the same schedule as occupied ones, and the inspection logs for position 14 are complete and unremarkable. The Division's position, stated in its standing note on the 44-series, is that an empty cradle is a form of custody, and that custody once assumed is not discharged by the absence of the object. The Concordance on Custody and Return endorses this view in general terms and has been read to endorse it in every particular.

Dispute with the Specimen Wing Archivists

The Specimen Wing Archivists assert that 44Γ-01 is not a designation but a miscopied cipher, and that the correct reading is 44Γ-07, an entry they hold as a fragment of pressed reed recovered from Floor 1202 and accessioned in the same month. The Archivists point to the letterforms in the survey ledger, which are cramped, and to the fact that a pressed reed requires no retention strap. Their case is weakened by the absence of any specimen 44Γ-07 in the Archivists' own catalogue, a gap they attribute to the Specimen Recovery Division's refusal to release the fragment, which the Division denies holding.

"The Division holds no fragment of reed, pressed or otherwise, under any designation in the 44-series, and would be glad to say so in writing were it asked in writing, which it has not been."

— Specimen Recovery Division, reply to Archivist memorandum 88-C

The memorandum 88-C was in writing. This discrepancy has been noted by the Office of Concordance Review and set aside as immaterial, since both parties agree the fragment is not in the Bay. The Archivists' custody dispute over Specimen S-12 is widely regarded as a rehearsal for the present disagreement, and the two files are stored adjacently for that reason.

The 44Γ-01 Question

In the Division's internal usage, a designation that has been allotted but never filled is said to be "in question." The 44Γ-01 Question has come to mean, more broadly, the problem of whether an allotment precedes or follows a recovery — that is, whether the Tower numbers things in order to find them or finds them in order to number them. Third Concordance, Article 9, holds that "the number is given at the door and not before," while Fifth Concordance, Article 9 (a later amendment bearing the same number, a coincidence the Office of Concordance Review has declined to treat as significant), holds that "the door is opened by the number." Both are cited daily in the Bay.

Clerk Voss-Holt, asked in her final examination whether she believed a specimen had been lost, recovered, or never present, answered that she believed all three and saw no contradiction. Her answer is reproduced on a card above position 14. Visitors to the Bay are asked not to lean on the cradle.

Status

Specimen 44Γ-01 remains in abeyance. The Division reviews the designation each year and each year renews it, on the reasoning that a designation once issued is cheaper to keep than to withdraw and considerably cheaper than to explain. The cradle at position 14 is inspected weekly. The strap is in good condition.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Specimen 773: what is it for?

Specimen 773 is a catalogued holding of the Tower, classed under the Specimen Recovery Division as an entry in the "Resonant Furnishings" series and presently domiciled on Floor 1202 adjacent to the recovered segment kno…

Specimen 773
Cable Vine specimen B4: what is it for?

Cable Vine specimen B4 is the accession designation applied to the severed tendril of Tonoscandens structuralis recovered from Floor 1202 on 14 Sigma, 1149, and thereafter the most litigated fragment of vegetable matter …

Cable Vine specimen B4
Specimen Stair (Annex): where is it?

Specimen Stair (Annex) refers to a designated auxiliary chamber appended to The Specimen Stair within the Anechoic Galleries of Floor 107, officially catalogued under Vertical Aperture 107-δ-1, Annex 7. Its primary funct…

Specimen Stair (Annex)

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.