The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Silent Rescissions

MS 4688.29 · Practices and doctrines

Silent Rescissions are formal acts by which a thing catalogued in the Tower is withdrawn from the record without being destroyed, and without the withdrawal itself being recorded in the place from which it was withdrawn. The practice is old, narrow, and extensively litigated. A rescission is said to be silent because the entry it removes leaves no gap, no compensating blank line, and no marginal note; the shelf closes over the subject as though it had never been assigned a number. Whether the subject ceases to exist, or merely ceases to be findable, is the question on which the whole jurisprudence of the practice has foundered since at least the eleventh recension of The Silent Concordance.

Silent Rescissions are administered by the Silent College under an instrument of delegation from the Silent Divan, and are performed only on floors that have been cleared of readers for the duration. The clearance order is issued by the floor's senior porter, historically drawn from the Silent Porters. Porters are required to sweep the affected aisles twice, and to announce the clearance once, at conversational volume, to an empty floor.

Origin and the First Rescission

The practice is conventionally dated to the winter of floor 814, when the Silent College was asked to resolve an accumulation of contradictory catalogue entries concerning a single stairwell. Rather than correct the entries, the College removed them together, on the reasoning — set out in the memorandum now known as College Memorandum 814-B — that a set of errors is not improved by the correction of any one of them. The stairwell remained in place. It was simply no longer reachable by anyone looking for it, which the College judged at the time to be the same thing.

The memorandum's final clause is frequently quoted and never fully obeyed: "A withdrawn entry must be withdrawn from every index or from none; the middle course is the creation of an attic" (College Memorandum 814-B, clause 9). That a staircase may be entered from Silent Columns, and that Silent Column Resonators installed there were not rescinded along with the stairwell, produced the first of the long disputes between the College and the Silent Choirs over what a rescission actually covers.

Relationship to Silent Audits

Silent Rescissions are frequently confused with the Silent Audit, and the confusion is partly institutional. Auditors for Silent Audits are drawn from the Silent Choirs, and a Silent Audit is the procedural framework by which Silent Chimes are administered; it can recommend a rescission but cannot perform one. The distinction was drawn sharply after the events catalogued as the Incident of the Silent Cypress, when an audit recommendation was acted upon directly by a junior auditor without College instrument, and three floors of the Silent Stacks were briefly uncatalogued. The floors were restored. Two of them were restored to the wrong numbers, and a standing correction has run in the Stacks register ever since.

The Silent Stacks Excavation (890-Σ) recovered a partial schedule of rescissions performed during that period, which the College has neither confirmed nor disputed. Marlo of the Silent Stacks has argued that the schedule's blank entries are themselves rescissions, a reading the College rejects on the ground that a rescission must begin with a text.

The Instrument and Its Witnesses

A rescission is performed by instrument, sealed with the College Seal of Withdrawal, and witnessed by two Librarians of the Silent College who are not permitted to read the instrument they witness. The instrument carries the floor number, the entry's original designation, and a single word of grounds selected from a closed list maintained at Aperture Nine. The instrument itself is then filed in a location it does not name, and is not indexed. The College has been asked, repeatedly, how such an instrument can afterwards be produced in evidence. Its answer, given in every instance, is that instruments of rescission are produced in evidence only when they should not have been issued.

"Let the instrument be sealed, and let the seal be the whole of its address. What is written beneath the seal is for the seal's use, not ours."

— The Silent Concordance, Annex 7, "On Withdrawal"

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal disagreement concerns duration. The Silent Concordance provides in one recension that a rescission holds "until the floor is next counted" (Annex 7, clause 3), and in a later recension, apparently without acknowledgment, that it holds "until the floor is next counted or not counted, as the case may be" (Annex 7, clause 3, revised). Galimund of Aperture Nine reads the revision as making rescissions permanent by default, since most floors are never counted; Elara of the Silent Quire reads it as making them void, since every floor is counted at least in the sense of being walked. The Silent Divan has declined to hear the question on two occasions, on the procedural ground that a court which cannot be found cannot rule.

A secondary dispute concerns whether the Silent College may rescind its own instruments. The College maintains that it may not, and has never done so. The register of instruments, which does not exist, is understood to show otherwise.

Inventory of Withdrawn Entries

The following items are known to have been withdrawn, and are listed here only because their withdrawal was later contested. Counting them is not recommended.

  • Floor 814, West Stairwell (withdrawn 814; contested by the Silent Choirs)
  • Silent Occupancy, Annex D (withdrawn twice; the second withdrawal is undocumented)
  • The third reading of Silent Columns, Aisle 6 (withdrawn 890-Σ; restored, then withdrawn again in error)
  • One porter's name, inadvertently (withdrawn 1174; the porter was reassigned to Couriers of the Silent Stair and appears to be content)
  • The word attic (withdrawn 1179; still in use in this article under protest)

Maintenance note: aisles cleared for rescission are relit at the standard rate of one lamp per eleven shelves, and the lamps are not to be left burning on a cleared floor after the instrument is sealed. Porters who report a lamp still lit should not investigate it. This instruction has been in force since 1174 and has never been rescinded.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Silent Stacks: where is it?

The Silent Stacks are the collective designation for a non-contiguous series of archival floors within the Tower where all standard auditory phenomena are permanently absent. Governed by the Third Concordance, Annex Sigm…

Silent Stacks
Silent College: who are they?

The Silent College is the administrative body chartered by the terms of the Inkwell Concordance to oversee all cataloguing operations involving non-vocalized, non-standard, or conceptually attenuated referents. Headquart…

Silent College
Silent Choirs: who are they?

Silent Choirs refer to three distinct, though occasionally conflated, concepts within the administrative and archival frameworks of the Tower: the bureaucratic body that governs auditory curation, the physical infrastruc…

Silent Choirs
Elara of the Silent Quire: who were they?

Elara of the Silent Quire was a reviser of the second grade attached to the Silent Scriptorium during the long custodianship of Elias of the Silent Quire, and is chiefly remembered for the Quire Reckoning of 903 — a recl…

Elara of the Silent Quire

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.