Seventh Concordance, Amendment Delta
MS 3575.08 · Documents and ordinances
Seventh Concordance, Amendment Delta is the instrument by which the Seventh Concordance apportioned responsibility for the Paper Shortage of the Lower Stacks and, in the same paragraph, extended the eastern terminus of Annex Delta Place to include the antechamber beyond it. It is dated to the fourteenth day of the ninth Spiral and carries the seal of the Third Scriptorium. It is among the shortest amendments in the Seventh cycle and the most cited, largely because it is the only one that uses the word "regret" in an operative clause.
Text and construction
Amendment Delta runs to four clauses. The first assigns the Shortage to "a procedural error during the Movement of Stacks, late in the seventh Spiral, which error was clerical in nature and not doctrinal." The second schedules the replacement of affected folios without specifying a quantity. The third extends Annex Delta Place eastward, a provision that has since been read as unrelated and is defended as unrelated by the office that drafted it. The fourth regrets.
The drafting office, the Bureau of Annex Boundaries, has maintained since the ninth Spiral that the regret belongs to the fourth clause and governs the whole. The Delta Council has held the contrary in three separate sittings, most recently in the winter of the twelfth Spiral, on the ground that a clause which follows a boundary extension cannot be presumed to speak to a shortage. Both readings are in circulation. Neither has been withdrawn.
The procedural error
The error itself is not described in the amendment, and the descriptive file was lost in the Paper Shortage of the Lower Stacks — an irony noted in the margin of the Bureau's own working copy by a clerk whose hand is unidentified but whose punctuation is not. What survives is a schedule of movement orders for the eleventh through nineteenth days of the ninth Spiral, of which one entry, for a bay of returns from the Ninety-Seventh Amendment recension, is marked "moved twice; count not reconciled."
"Not reconciled at the time of movement, nor at the time of this writing, nor, it is anticipated, at any time hereafter."
— Seventh Concordance, Revision 4, marginal schedule
The Bureau has declined to treat the entry as the error, calling it "an entry of the kind the schedule exists to record." Clerks in the Lower Stacks have treated it as the error for sixty years and are not expected to stop.
Relationship to the Beta-4 designation
The amendment is frequently confused with its own annex. Annex Delta of the Seventh Concordance is the instrument that formally retired the Beta-4 Designation Framework and amended the doctrine of coincidental names; Amendment Delta does neither, though it twice refers the reader to the annex for "the disposition of designations affected by the movement." The reference has been read as incorporating the annex by reference in its entirety. The Office of Retired Designations rejects this reading and has circulated a one-page note to that effect since the eleventh Spiral. The note is now three pages.
Dispute of the eleventh Spiral
A dispute arose over whether Amendment Delta had been properly laid before the reading of Seventh Concordance, Amendment Gamma. The Gamma instrument holds that the Master Index is the instrument of realization; Delta is silent on the Index altogether. Clerk Ovan Merrit argued that a silent instrument could not supersede a speaking one and was sustained. The Bureau appealed to the Concordance of Precedence, which found that the question had been settled the other way in an unreported matter concerning Amendment 22 and remitted it.
The remittal was read aloud on the floor of the antechamber and entered in the day-book. No further step has been taken. The dispute is described in the standing survey returns as open, and in the Bureau's correspondence as concluded, and both descriptions appear on the same folio.
Practical effect
Amendment Delta is the authority under which the antechamber beyond the eastern terminus of Annex Delta Place is maintained, swept, and lit, though no Concordance grants the surveyors a key. The door is bolted on the Annex side each evening at the eleventh bell and opened the following morning by whoever is first to arrive. Persons entering the antechamber are asked to leave the bolt drawn back.
The amendment is also the standard citation for any procedural fault occurring during a movement, whatever the spiral, the stack, or the nature of the fault. This usage is discouraged by the Bureau of Annex Boundaries and resorted to by nearly everyone else.
See also
-
MS 6319.45
Concordance 9,102.44, Amendment Delta
Concordance 9,102.44, Amendment Delta is the instrument by which Concordance 9,102.44 revised the schedule of witnessed instrument…
-
MS 4599.28
Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7
Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7, commonly designated Amendment VII or the Amendment of the Latent Implication, is a supplementa…
-
MS 7198.37
Amendment Delta (Intersection with Flora)
Amendment Delta (Intersection with Flora) is the instrument, ratified on 14 Frostmonth 73 and entered in the Delta register under …
-
MS 6859.28
Concordant Amendment
Concordant Amendment is the formal act by which an existing Concordance is altered, extended, or partially revoked within the juri…
-
MS 4427.22
Shortage of ’55
“The Shortage was not a lack, but an overabundance of a specific kind of absence.”…
-
MS 9976.84
4-C (Procedural)
4-C (Procedural) is the designation given to a class of procedural holdings filed under the fourth spiral of the Procedural Wing a…
Referenced by
- MS 3772.55 Movement of Stacks
- MS 4427.22 Shortage of ’55
- MS 6086.10 Annex Delta, Concordance 44
- MS 9235.69 Lamentation Paper (Grade Delta)
- MS 5658.47 Annex C, Paragraph 4 of Concordance XVII
- MS 7620.79 Concordance 23, Annex Delta
- MS 6696.98 Amendment 3 to Guild Standard 114 Delta 7b
- MS 6884.17 Thirteenth Concordance Annex Delta Delta
- MS 3373.03 Seventh Concordance, Annex Delta
- MS 6319.45 Concordance 9,102.44, Amendment Delta
- MS 1263.53 Concordance 61-Delta
- MS 6735.00 Concordance 47, Annex Delta
Readers also asked
Movement of Stacks: how is it conducted?
“The motion of thought is not the same as the thought of motion. Yet in the Tower, we must file both under the same shelf.” — Attributed to Aris Thorne, annotation in the marginalia of Seventh Concordance, Amendment Delt…
Movement of StacksPaper Shortage of the Lower Stacks: what happened?
Paper Shortage of the Lower Stacks refers to a chronic logistical and philosophical crisis that afflicted sub-basement levels designated as the Lower Stacks during the Year of the Slowed Pendulum. Characterized by a seve…
Paper Shortage of the Lower StacksSeventh Concordance, Revision 4: what does it set out?
The Seventh Concordance, Revision 4 is the penultimate revision of The Seventh Concordance, ratified under Clause 33, Annex Delta on the 11th day of the Ninth Spiral, 742. It is distinguished by the formal chartering of …
Seventh Concordance, Revision 4Master Index: what does it set out?
The Master Index, also known as the Floor-Specific Master Catalog or the Principal Register of Designations, is the definitive, unalterable ledger of all objects, concepts, personnel, and documentary holdings officially …
Master IndexPassages cited from this record
-
Not reconciled at the time of movement, nor at the time of this writing, nor, it is anticipated, at any time hereafter.
Seventh Concordance, Revision 4, marginal schedule
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2095.36 Bureau of Annex Boundaries
- MS 3393.93 Office of Retired Designations
- MS 7847.84 Beta-4 Designation Framework
- MS 3642.53 Seventh Concordance, Amendment Gamma
Because you consulted