Seven-Hundred-and-Twenty-Second Directive
MS 6490.97 · Documents and ordinances
The Seven-Hundred-and-Twenty-Second Directive is an instrument of the Librarianate governing the treatment of rooms that have been catalogued but not yet found. Issued from the Ninth Scriptorium on 4 Ember 1187 (Tower Reckoning) and entered into the sealed register the same evening, it holds that a room may be described, indexed, lettered, and shelved before it is located, provided that no one is told where it is. The Directive has been amended eleven times and annotated more than four hundred; it has been located itself, without difficulty, at any hour of the day.
Its full title, as it appears on the seal-wrap, is Directive concerning the Standing of Rooms Extant in Description and Absent in Plan. Clerks refer to it simply as the Seven-Twenty-Two, a usage the Committee of Concordant Reconciliation has twice declined to regularise on the grounds that abbreviations are a matter for the Scriptorium and not the Committee.
Origin: the Winter of the Missing Corridor
The Directive arose from an incident on the four-hundred-and-second floor during the winter of 1186, when a survey party under Clerk-Adjutant Merrivale Ost returned from the north-east quadrant with a complete inventory of a corridor, including its lamps, its three doorways, and the wear on its thresholds, but no corridor. The party had worked for nine days. They had measured everything. Asked to lead a second party back, they could not agree among themselves on which stair they had descended, and two of them gave directions that would have placed the corridor inside the boiler vault.
The matter was referred upward three times and returned twice. It was finally settled by the observation, attributed to Under-Librarian Callow Vess, that the corridor had been real for nine days and that a body of work of that length cannot be unmade by a failure of the plan. The Seven-Hundred-and-Twenty-Second Directive gives that observation the force of rule.
Principal provisions
The Directive establishes a class of room known as extant in description. A room enters this class when a survey party has measured it and no draughtsman can place it. Such rooms are assigned numbers in the usual series, are listed in the floor inventory in the usual column, and carry a marginal note in red ink reading unplaced. Red ink is specified; the Office of Granular Audit has confirmed that it must be red.
Three consequences follow. An unplaced room may be cited in proceedings and may be entered on inspection returns. It may not be allotted to a department. And it may not be locked, since a room that cannot be found cannot be secured, and the attempt has historically led to keys being issued for premises nobody can reach.
"Let the room be numbered and named, and let its situation be withheld from all parties, including the surveyor, who shall not be asked."
— Seven-Hundred-and-Twenty-Second Directive, Clause 4
Clause 9, added by amendment in 1203, extends the same courtesy to stairwells, though the Seven Hundred Twelfth Concordance subsequently claimed exclusive competence over stairwells and the two instruments have been read together only once, by a clerk who has since been reassigned to the loop on the sixty-first floor.
The Vess reading and the Ost objection
Two readings of the Directive have contended for most of a century. The majority position, set out by Vess in a memorandum of 1191 and followed by the Curatorial Office, is that an unplaced room is fully real and merely unsited; its reality is established by the survey, not the plan. On this view the Directive is a recognition of fact and requires no enforcement.
The minority position, advanced by Ost after his retirement and circulated in three manuscript recensions, holds that the Directive creates the unplaced room by the act of numbering it, and that the corridor of 1186 exists only because the inventory was written. Ost's objection is textual: Clause 4 orders that the room be named before it is withheld, an order that would be superfluous if the room were already there to be named.
The dispute has never been resolved, and the Twenty-Second Concordance — which codified Substantial Formalism at length — is silent on the point, which both sides cite as support. Annex G of that Concordance refers to "rooms in standing description" without defining the phrase, and Concordance Twenty-Second, Annex G, Clause 22 spends four of its eleven folios discussing something else.
Relationship to the Concordances
The Directive is a Librarianate instrument and does not derive from the Concordances, a fact that has caused persistent friction. The Office of Latent Properties, established under Twenty-Second Concordance, argued in 1274 that unplaced rooms fall squarely within its remit, since a room extant in description and absent in plan is latent by any reasonable construction. The Scriptorium replied that the rooms are not latent; they are simply elsewhere. The exchange ran to sixty-one folios and produced a joint memorandum whose operative clause was struck through in three separate recensions.
Where the Directive and a Concordance conflict directly, practice favours the Concordance; where the conflict is merely implied, practice favours whoever is present in the room at the time. The Third Concordance's requirement at Annex 9 that floors above the seven-thousand-four-hundred-and-twenty-second be entered on a sealed list has never been reconciled with Clause 4, and no unplaced room has been reported above that floor since 1301.
Administration and known difficulties
The Directive is administered by the Clerks of the Unplaced Register, a body of four, two of whom are currently seconded to the Directive on Phantasmal Architecture and one of whom is on long leave. Filing is straightforward: a red slip for each unplaced room, kept in the order of numbering, in a cabinet on the ninth floor. The cabinet is not locked. The Directive explains why.
Practically, the work consists of writing to departments to say that they may not have a room, and of declining to answer when they ask where it is. The Register's standing instruction is that no clerk may visit an unplaced room, since a visit would produce a site and the site would have to be entered, and the entry would contradict the red slip. Clerks who find themselves in an unplaced room are directed to leave by the door they came in and to report the matter in writing and not in person.
The Directive's own filing note, in the hand of the issuing scribe, records that a copy was sent to every floor above the fourth and returned unopened from nine of them.
See also
-
MS 3748.34
Directive 14,899-δ
Directive 14,899-δ is a standing instrument of Tower governance governing the treatment of documents that have been amended while …
-
MS 1339.78
Directive 12 of the Second Librarianate
Directive 12 of the Second Librarianate was a procedural decree concerning the cataloguing of phantasmal narratives. Issued on the…
-
MS 6718.36
Directive 843-Omega
Directive 843-Omega is a governance instrument of the Tower, issued under the HIC Directive 003 series and countersigned by the Of…
-
MS 4869.42
Clause D-7 (Conflict Resolution)
Clause D-7 is a provision of the Ordinances of Ascent governing the treatment of conflicts that arise between two clauses of the s…
-
MS 1700.85
Figurative Treatment
Figurative Treatment refers to the standardized administrative protocol for the handling, classification, and literalization of fi…
-
MS 8714.54
Preservation Ordinance 440-7
Preservation Ordinance 440-7 is an instrument of the Librarians governing the atmospheric conditions of Floor 440 and, by conteste…
Referenced by
- MS 6565.09 Type 1
- MS 3304.70 Ninth Scriptorium
Readers also asked
Office of Granular Audit: who are they?
“Where the parameters themselves require scrutiny, one does not audit the container, but the grain.” — Eloise of the Granular Insight, Commentaries on the Seventeenth Concordance, Vol. 9, Section 22.
Office of Granular AuditSubstantial Formalism: how is it conducted?
Substantial Formalism is the doctrine, extensively codified by the Twenty-Second Concordance, that for archival and classification purposes within The Tower, aesthetic presentation is inseparable from and constitutive of…
Substantial FormalismTwenty-Second Concordance: what does it set out?
The Twenty-Second Concordance was the principal governance document of The Tower from its ratification in Year 47 of the Fifth Librarianate until its supersession by the Twenty-Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Sixth L…
Twenty-Second ConcordanceOffice of Latent Properties: who are they?
Office of Latent Properties was the administrative bureau charged with the official identification, measurement, classification, and containment of latent properties within the Tower from its formation under the Twenty-S…
Office of Latent PropertiesPassages cited from this record
-
Let the room be numbered and named, and let its situation be withheld from all parties, including the surveyor, who shall not be asked.
Seven-Hundred-and-Twenty-Second Directive, Clause 4
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 0415.35 Seven Hundred Twelfth Concordance
- MS 9273.52 Clerks of the Unplaced Register
- MS 5467.48 Under-Librarian Callow Vess
- MS 0515.75 Merrivale Ost
Because you consulted