The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Sequencing

MS 6288.43 · Practices and doctrines

Sequencing is the general body of practice by which the Tower establishes that one thing may stand before another. The term is used loosely in common speech to cover every branch of ordered arrangement, and strictly, in the Bureau of Sequential Integrity's standing glossary, to mean only those arrangements in which precedence is asserted rather than merely observed. A shelf arranged by height is not Sequencing. A shelf arranged by height and accompanied by a claim that it must be so arranged is a Sequencing matter and falls within the Bureau's remit.

The distinction matters because almost nothing in the Tower is catalogued without a precedence claim attached. Entries carry numbers; numbers carry order; order carries the expectation that someone, at some point, will be asked to defend it. Numerical Sequencing governs the numbered case, Hermetic Sequencing the acausal case, and Chromatic Sequencing the heraldic. The three are frequently said to be separate disciplines. They share a corridor, a subcommittee, and a filing clerk, and the separation is maintained on the understanding that no one raises the question too directly.

Origins and the founding instrument

Sequencing was formalized by Concordance 7.4.13, which granted authority for sequencing submissions and permitted procedural re-sequencing where a foundational error was found. The Concordance's drafters evidently intended a narrow instrument, confined to the verification of shelving order on the lower stacks. Its third recital, however, defines a sequence as "any series in which the position of a term may be asserted in writing", a definition with no evident upper bound, and the Bureau has spent the intervening years declining to establish one.

The theoretical groundwork came earlier, in the Treatise on Acausal Taxonomies, which argued that a sequence may be legitimately audited from its endpoint backward. Practice lagged theory by some decades; the first working procedure appears in the Manual of Cyclical Reckoning, and the first working complaint about the procedure appears in the same volume's margins, in a hand since identified as that of a junior amanuensis at Sub-level Θ.

The submission and the audit

Every sequence of consequence is required to declare itself. The declaration is a Sequencing Submission, in which a sequence states the order it believes itself to follow; the verification is a Sequencing Audit, a formal examination of the entries, files, or sigils against that claim. Protocol for alphanumeric cases is set by Protocol 12-A; for cases with no discernible first term, the auditor proceeds by Hermetic Sequencing from the completed sequence backward, a method auditors describe as reliable and unpleasant.

The characteristic failure of the system is that a sequence may be internally consistent and still wrong. In Year 412 a Submission was filed for the entire eastern run of the seventh gallery, declaring a simple alphabetical order. The Audit found the order faultless. It was later established that the sequence had been built from the wrong recension of the Floor-Specific Master Catalog, and that it was perfectly, immaculately ordered around a category that no longer existed. The submission was not withdrawn. It remains on file, and the eastern run has never been re-shelved, on the ground that correcting it would invalidate the Audit.

Queries of Precedence and the Subcommittee

Where the order of two terms is disputed, either party may file a Query of Precedence with the Subcommittee on Hermetic Sequences, which reviews such Queries and issues a determination. Filing is open to any party capable of naming the two terms. It is not open to a third party acting on both terms' behalf, a restriction introduced after the Affair of the Four Requests, in which the same clerk filed on both sides of a dispute and was obliged to argue against his own handwriting for eleven sessions.

Determinations are binding on the parties and advisory on everyone else, a distinction the Subcommittee has never satisfactorily explained. Backlog is administered under Ordinance Δ-769.27. The current arithmetic, as reported for the last complete reckoning, is set out below.

Item Count Notes
Queries received, last complete reckoning 1,144 Excludes Queries filed on both sides
Determinations issued 319 Of which 41 reversed an earlier determination
Withdrawn for foundational error 88 Re-sequenced under Concordance 7.4.13
Pending 737 Oldest filed in Year 412

Points of dispute

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns the status of the Decree of Aberrant Sequencing, related to the amendment of Title IX in Year 419. The Bureau of Sequential Integrity holds that the Decree supersedes the earlier Concordance in all cases of foundational error discovered after the fact. The Subcommittee holds that the Decree governs only aberrant sequences, and has no bearing on aberrant submissions, which remain subject to the Concordance. Both readings are defensible from the text. Neither office has been willing to request a ruling that might settle the matter, since the ruling would bind both of them.

A secondary dispute, older and pettier, concerns Precedential Analysis. Practitioners in the Hermetic Carrels maintain that analysis of a sequence's precedents may itself constitute a Query of Precedence, and therefore requires filing. The Bureau maintains that it does not. The Carrels have continued to file, and the Bureau has continued to return the filings unopened, in the original wrappers, at the Tower's expense.

Record-keeping and amendments

All determinations, reversals, and foundational errors are entered in the amendment log of the Bureau, which is kept in duplicate for reasons no living clerk can reconstruct; the second copy is blank, and is maintained. Corrections to a log entry are entered in the log itself, so that the log records not only what was decided but what was once decided otherwise. The Seventh Addendum to the First Concordance addresses this practice directly: "A corrected record shall retain its correction, that the sequence of its own correction may be audited."

"It is not the office of the Sequencer to say what came first. It is his office to say what may be said to have come first without contradiction, and to hold that position until contradicted."

— Concordance 7.4.13, Annex 4

In practice the discipline is maintained by a small number of persons and a large number of precedents. Visitors are reminded that the eastern gallery is closed to non-filers during a Sequencing Audit and that no one may pass a shelving trolley on the stair side between the fourth and fifth turns.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Amendment Logging: how is it conducted?

Amendment Logging is the procedural framework for the authentication, chronological sequencing, and archival insertion of all amendments to the Concordances and other foundational Tower documents. It is distinguished fro…

Amendment Logging
Numerical Sequencing: how is it conducted?

Numerical Sequencing is the discipline governing the arrangement of numbered entries into ordered series, and the branch of administrative practice concerned with establishing whether a given number may lawfully precede …

Numerical Sequencing
Concordance 7.4.13: what does it set out?

Concordance 7.4.13 is a subordinate instrument of The Seventh Concordance, promulgated in the forty-first year of the present recension and occupying a single leaf in the Register of Subordinate Instruments on the Instru…

Concordance 7.4.13
Precedential Analysis: how is it conducted?

Precedential Analysis refers to the formal discipline and institutional practice of interpreting, classifying, and applying the Tower's accumulated body of contradictory rulings, edicts, and Concordances. It is the metho…

Precedential Analysis

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.