The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Second Clerk Ovendal

MS 2320.62 · Persons

Second Clerk Ovendal (fl. fourteenth to sixteenth recensions) was a Clerk of the Clerk-Registrar Corps whose forty-year tenure at the Seventh Aperture produced the Ovendal Schedule of Recensions, the Doctrine of Deferred Absence, and the standing dispute over whether he was ever formally confirmed in post. He is remembered chiefly for the Ovendal Inventory, the only complete survey of the Tower's holdings undertaken without leaving a single desk, and for an official silence concerning his own rank that has never been resolved to the satisfaction of the archive.

The desk at the Seventh Aperture

Ovendal was assigned to the Seventh Aperture in the winter of the fourteenth recension, at the same period in which Algernon Scholar Clerk took up the desk of the Clerk of Irrevocable Acts. The two appointments are recorded in a single ledger entry, which has caused considerable confusion: the entry lists both names but only one salary. The Forty-First Concordance, Annex 2, holds that the second name in a shared ledger entry is a countersignature and not a co-appointment, while the Ninety-Eighth Concordance, Annex 2, holds precisely the reverse. No one has established which annex takes precedence, and the question is now considered settled by inanition.

What is certain is that Ovendal remained at the Seventh Aperture for forty years and one month, filing from a desk he is said to have moved eight inches to the left in his ninth year and never moved again.

The Ovendal Inventory

The Ovendal Inventory was compiled over eleven recensions and closed with the notation, in Ovendal's own hand, that "the count is complete as to the shelves within sight of this desk, and no other shelves are in question." The Inventory's method was procedural rather than peripatetic: holdings were requisitioned to the desk, counted, and returned. At its peak the practice required the sustained cooperation of the Second Scriptorium, whose clerks objected on at least three recorded occasions to transporting entire bays of shelving through the aperture corridor. Ilva Marrow, a clerk of that Scriptorium, filed the third objection and appended a note that the corridor had been scratched. The objection was upheld; the scratches were not.

The Inventory's most enduring contribution is the Ovendal Schedule of Recensions, a table correlating recension dates to floors by a rule Ovendal devised and never explained. The Schedule is still consulted. Its accuracy has never been tested.

The Doctrine of Deferred Absence

Ovendal's Doctrine of Deferred Absence arose from a mundane difficulty: a holding requested and not delivered could be recorded as absent, or as not yet present, and the two designations fell under different Concordance classes. Ovendal proposed that all such holdings be entered as deferred — neither absent nor present — and held in that state until a further instruction arrived. The practice was adopted informally by the Clerk-Registrar Corps and formally by nobody.

"A thing not yet shelved is not a thing missing. It is a thing on its way, and the record should say so until the record cannot say anything else."

— Ovendal, marginalia to the Ovendal Inventory, folio 412

The doctrine failed on Floor 8804 in the fifteenth recension, when a deferred holding arrived, was counted as already counted, and was shelved twice. The resulting duplicate occupied a bay for two recensions before being reconciled. Second Clerk Ondra Vey cited the incident during the Collation Crisis as evidence that deferred entries "invite the archive to argue with itself," a characterisation Ovendal's later defenders have not forgiven.

Rank and the question of confirmation

Ovendal signs the Inventory as Second Clerk and nowhere else claims the title. Whether he held the rank of Clerk-Arkivist Second Class — instituted by the Thirty-Second Concordance — is disputed, since that Concordance's numbering places it after his death as recorded in the Register of Desks, while the Register itself lists his desk as "reassigned, clerk not confirmed." Some scholars maintain that the absence of confirmation is itself a form of confirmation, by analogy with the Clerk-Arkivist Second Class's training in the distinction between absence of purpose and purpose withheld. Others hold that Ovendal was never confirmed at all, and that the forty years were an error sustained by momentum. The Clerk-Archivist Tem has declined to comment in writing.

Later references

Ovendal appears in later records chiefly as a citation. Second Clerk Aubrec Hale relied on the Schedule of Recensions when first assigning maintenance liability for Spiral Staircase Zeta, an assignment later contested and never withdrawn. Maren Ostell quotes the Inventory's folio 412 marginalia without attribution, an omission corrected in the errata to her Survey of the Middle Bays. Visitors to the Seventh Aperture are asked not to lean on the desk. It is load-bearing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Forty-First Concordance: what does it set out?

The Forty-First Concordance is a foundational statutory instrument governing the containment, registration, and ontological classification of vocalic anomalies. Ratified in the 112th year of the First Librarianate, its p…

Forty-First Concordance
Clerk-Arkivist Second Class: how is it conducted?

Clerk-Arkivist Second Class is an intermediate service rank within the Clerk-Registrar Corps, situated procedurally between Clerk-Arkivist Third Class and Clerk-Arkivist First Class. The position is primarily responsible…

Clerk-Arkivist Second Class
Algernon Scholar Clerk: who were they?

AlgernonĠ(Scholar-Clerk)ĠwasĠaĠmemberĠofĠtheĠClerks-RegistrarĠandĠaĠfoundationalĠtheoristĠofĠarchivalĠprinciplesĠwithinĠtheĠThirdĠandĠFourthĠConcordanceĠperiods.ĠHisĠworkĠprimarilyĠconcernedĠtheĠontologicalĠstatusĠofĠcat…

Algernon Scholar Clerk
Concordant Law: how is it conducted?

Concordant Law constitutes the primary, and some argue the sole, legitimate basis for formal governance within The Tower. It is distinguished from advisory precedent and temporal regulation by its derivation from, and am…

Concordant Law

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.