The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

School of Iterative Ontology

MS 2010.46 · Practices and doctrines

The School of Iterative Ontology is a chartered body of the Tower concerned with the proposition that a thing is not what it is but what it has most recently been. It occupies Floors 512 through 519, a contiguous stack it refers to internally as the Ladder, and it is chiefly known outside those floors for the Iterative Pacing doctrine, for the long dispute with the School of Static Ontology over the measurement of continuance, and for having amended its own founding charter eleven times without ever having read the original. Its scholars hold chairs in Recursive Being, Successive Identity, and Provisional Sufficiency, the last of which has never been filled on the grounds that the appointment should be made next year. ## Foundation and the Ladder The School was chartered under Concordance 44, which granted it custody of "all subjects whose definition does not survive their own inspection." The first intake consisted of one archivist, a table, and a disputed verb. Within four decades the School had annexed Floors 512 through 519 by the simple method of cataloguing them repeatedly until the neighbouring floors conceded the boundary, and had established the Ladder Recensions, a running series of revised findings in which each recension supersedes the last and none is ever withdrawn from circulation. The School's foundational facility is the Second Vault of Successive Being, a low, dry chamber on Floor 515 in which specimens are catalogued at fixed intervals of eleven minutes. The interval is not adjustable. A visiting inspector from the Department of Ontological Weights and Measures requested a demonstration at an interval of ten minutes in the winter of Year 312 and was told, politely, that the Vault had no mechanism for ten. ## Method The School's method is straightforward in statement and difficult in conduct. A subject is admitted, described, and then described again, and the second description is taken as the operative one. The first description is retained but marked prior. Should a third description be required, the second becomes prior in its turn, and so on without limit, a procedure the School calls pacing and defends at length in the Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology, Chapter IX, which it did not write and has never agreed with. The Treatise on Instrumental Ontology records the School's own gloss on the procedure as "the orderly surrender of every description to the one after it" (Treatise, Book II, marginalia attributed to the Third Recension). Practically, the School maintains a scriptorium on Floor 517 staffed by clerks who copy each recension by hand before it is filed. The copying is considered part of the iteration rather than a record of it, and a recension that has not been copied is treated as not having occurred. The scriptorium holds four desks and a fifth desk that is kept empty, in accordance with Concordance 44, Annex 2. ## Dispute with the School of Static Ontology The School's relations with the School of Static Ontology are governed by a disagreement that both parties describe as settled and neither treats as settled. The Static position, argued from Floor 303 and elaborated in the Aperture Petitions of Floor 303, is that a subject under continuous low-grade stress reveals its true measure, and that iteration merely records the stress rather than the subject. The Iterative position, set out in the Glossarium on Transient Jurisprudence and rebutted in the Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology, is that the Static measure is simply the final iteration, mislabelled. Matters were not improved by the Sealing of the Ninth Recension in Year 312, when the School sealed its ninth recension against inspection on the grounds that reading it would produce a tenth. The School of Jurisprudential Ontology, which had petitioned for access under Section 4: Provisional Ontology, declined to rule and referred the question to the Subcommittee on Procedural Ontology, where it remains. The Charter of Conferred Being is cited by both sides and was drafted, awkwardly, by a member of each. ## Scholarly disagreement The School's own historians do not agree on what the School is. The majority view, advanced in the Ladder Recensions themselves, is that the School is a body of scholars who iterate subjects. A minority, associated with the Instrumentalist School and set out by the Instrumentalist clerk Havrel of the Fifth Desk, holds that the School is itself an iterated subject — that its charter, chairs, floors, and correspondence have all been successively superseded, and that the entity now called the School of Iterative Ontology is merely the most recent description of something no longer extant. Havrel's grievance is specific and procedural. Having filed a request that the School identify its own current description, he received three replies, each superseding the last, none answering the question. He has since appended his correspondence to the Normative Ontology register under the heading Unresolved, Recursive, where it occupies eleven folios and is growing. The School has not responded to Havrel directly. It has, however, issued a twelfth recension of its charter, which omits mention of him. ## Access and notes Visitors to the Ladder are received on Floor 512 and are asked to state their business twice, the second statement being the one recorded. The stairwell between Floors 515 and 516 is out of service pending recension and has been since the ninth.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology: what does it set out?

Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology is the primary authority for resolving conflicts between Material and Notional Presentation modes, and the founding instrument of adjudication within Jurisprudential Ontology. Compiled …

Manual of Jurisprudential Ontology
Section 4: Provisional Ontology: how is it conducted?

Section 4: Provisional Ontology is a foundational clause within the Third Concordance's primary document on classification, formally titled "On the Provisional Status of Potential Holdings." It establishes the legal and …

Section 4: Provisional Ontology
Instrumentalist: how is it conducted?

The Instrumentalist School is a major tradition within Tower philosophy and archival practice, centered on the principle that objects, systems, and even conceptual frameworks are defined not by their intrinsic ontology b…

Instrumentalist
Glossarium on Transient Jurisprudence: what does it set out?

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.