The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Sanctioned Marginalia

MS 7822.62 · Practices and doctrines

The Sanctioned Marginalia is the class of appended markings formally permitted to remain on a primary document after review by the Marginalia Registry. A marking enters the class by petition, is entered in the Marginalia Log under the Marginalia Syntax, and remains sanctioned until it is withdrawn, superseded, or found to have been sanctioned in error. The class is small. Of the four thousand and eleven petitions recorded in the Registry's third recension of the petition rolls, two hundred and six were granted in full and thirty-one were granted as what the Registry calls "sanctioned in part, legible in whole" — a designation discussed below.

Sanction does not attach to the marking itself but to its position. A sanctioned mark lifted from its document and re-entered elsewhere is unsanctioned from the moment of lifting, and the Clerks of the Marginalia are required to note the transit on both documents and on the intervening wrapper.

Definition and the Ordinance Alpha dispute

Ordinance Alpha defines marginalia as "any marking, annotation, or symbol appended to a primary document that exists outside the sanctioned textual body and its pre-approved commentary fields." Sanctioned marginalia is therefore, on a strict reading, a contradiction: the sanction is what converts the mark into part of the commentary fields, at which point it ceases to be marginalia at all. The Registry has never adopted this reading, on the ground that a document whose margins have been emptied by sanction is a document that has lost its record of having been read.

Marginalia Registry ordinances distinguish the primary and secondary forms of the Log, but say nothing about the fate of the mark after sanction. The gap is filled by Concordance 9, Annex 2, which holds that "a sanctioned mark abides in the margin as an honorary member of the text, with no vote." Concordance 11 rejects the clause as metaphorical and therefore void. Both remain cited, frequently in the same petition.

The case of the Sanctioned Quill of Errosion

The most cited sanction on the rolls is also the least typical. Archivist-Proctor Linus first recorded the mis-cataloguing error "Sanctioned Quill of Errosion" in the marginalia of their seventeenth audit cycle, having found it entered against a document that bore no quill, no errosion, and no margin of sufficient width to hold either. Linus's note ran to nine lines and urged that the entry be struck.

It was not struck. The Bureau of Corrections argued that the phrase described a genuine category — a quill licensed to erode — and that striking the entry would leave the category unnamed. A petition was duly filed, and the Quill of Errosion has stood sanctioned since, though no example has ever been produced. Succeeding auditors have treated it as a test case: an entry that survives because the machinery for removing it proved more expensive than the error.

Sanctioned in part, legible in whole

Partial sanction arose from the practical difficulty that most marginalia contains several marks on one line, of which perhaps one is permissible. Rather than rule on each, the Registry adopted the practice of sanctioning the line and endorsing the sheet "legible in whole" — meaning that a reader may read the line, provided they understand that not all of it is sanctioned.

The practice was challenged in the winter of the year the Registry counts as 6,041, when a reader on a lower floor transcribed three such lines into a fresh document and was cited for importing unsanctioned matter. The Office of the Reader's Defence argued that the reader had read legitimately; the Registry replied that reading is not transcription and the distinction is the whole of the law. The citation stood. The reader's transcription was returned to them, legible in whole.

Relations with the Department

Sanction is the Registry's instrument, and the Department of Marginalia has long resented it. The Department holds that a mark used in the ordinary course of annotation is sanctioned by use, not by petition, and that the Registry's rolls are a tax on reading. This position is grounded in On Marginalia and Meaning, which the Department has read as a charter of use since its separation from the Marginalia School.

The Registry replies that use sanctions nothing and that the Department's own Marginalia Density tables record marks it cannot identify, a discrepancy noted in Registry correspondence since before the Synod of Marginalia. No reconciliation has been attempted; the tables and the rolls describe different populations and neither office will concede the other's frame.

Notionalists' holdings

The Notionalists’ Marginalia Collection, shelved in the North Annex of The Marginalia Collection and jointly administered by the Registry and the Department, contains the largest body of sanctioned material outside the Log. Its catalogue distinguishes sanctioned marks from sanctioned absence — margins left deliberately bare under petition, of which the Collection holds eleven, all catalogued as if they were ink.

Withdrawal of sanction is rare and requires the concurrence of both administering bodies, which is why the Incident of the Selfwriting Marginalia is still unresolved. The markings in that case sanctioned themselves in the course of a single night, and neither office has been able to establish whether a mark that petitions on its own behalf is a petitioner or a petition.

Practical notes

Sanctioned marks are to be copied in the hand of the sanctioning clerk where possible, and in no case in a hand larger than the primary text. Visitors to the North Annex may bring one pen. It is not to be filled there.

"Let the margin be answered, but let it not answer back."

— Marginalia Registry, Ordinances, preamble to the fourth recension

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Marginalia Log: what does it set out?

The Marginalia Log is the official administrative instrument used by the Department of Marginalia to record, classify, and annotate instances of marginalia across all departments and floors of the Tower. It exists in bot…

Marginalia Log
Concordance 11: what does it set out?

Concordance 11, formally the Codices for the Temporal Displacement of Non-Manifest Collections, is a pivotal but highly contested governing document that establishes protocols for the classification and shelving of objec…

Concordance 11
Marginalia Registry: who are they?

The Marginalia Registry is the central administrative apparatus, housed on Floor 322 (the White Scriptorium), responsible for the physical maintenance, amendment, and codified interpretation of ordinances governing the f…

Marginalia Registry
On Marginalia and Meaning: what does it set out?

On Marginalia and Meaning is a foundational treatise written by an anonymous contributor to the Marginalia Log in Cycle 411. It formalized the theoretical distinction between substantive anomalies and clerical errors wit…

On Marginalia and Meaning

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.