The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ruling 712

MS 2448.55 · Practices and doctrines

Ruling 712 is a Librarians' ruling concerning the custody, legibility, and eventual retirement of instruments that have been superseded but not withdrawn. Issued from the Seventh Scriptorium in Cycle 1914 and revised twice since, it is best known for the doctrine of standing remainder: the principle that a repealed ruling continues to bind any party who has not been formally notified of its repeal. Ruling 712 is the ruling most frequently cited in disagreements about which ruling applies, a distinction it shares with almost nothing in the archive and which its drafters did not intend.

Origins

Ruling 712 was drafted in response to the Affair of the Two Hundred Supersessions, in which the Office of Continuing Precedent withdrew two hundred and six rulings in a single afternoon and neglected to inform the four floors then relying on them. The floors continued to comply with withdrawn rulings for eleven days, and the resulting backlog of incorrect compliance occupied three clerks through the winter of that cycle.

The ruling's operative clause is brief and has been quoted in every subsequent dispute on the subject:

"A ruling does not cease to bind on the day it is withdrawn. It ceases to bind on the day it is known to be withdrawn, and not one day sooner."

— Ruling 712, operative clause 1

The Concordance of Repeals, Annex 9, records that the drafters considered and rejected a simpler formulation — that a withdrawn ruling binds no one — on the ground that it would reward inattention. Clerk Miren Halveth, who served as amanuensis to the drafting bench, noted in her working commentary that the ruling "makes ignorance expensive and calls this fairness," a remark that has been reproduced in the margin of every recension since.

The Standing Remainder

Under Ruling 712, a superseded instrument survives as a remainder until notification has been served on every party bound by it. The remainder is not enforced and not cited, but it is not void, and a party who acts on it is held to have acted correctly. This produces the characteristic difficulty of the ruling: two obligations may run side by side, one living and one merely unburied.

Ruling 712 anticipated the objection and met it in clause 4, permitting a remainder to be extinguished by general proclamation rather than individual notice, provided the proclamation is read on three separate floors. The Third Concordance, Annex 6, requires instead that notice be delivered in writing and signed for, and the two instruments have never been reconciled. Disputes of Recursive Jurisdiction treats the conflict at length without resolving it.

The practical effect is that a clerk may lawfully comply with a ruling that no longer exists. In Cycle 2033, Floor 1188 submitted a return computed under Ruling 301.45 four years after that ruling's withdrawal; the return was accepted, and the Office of Continuing Precedent issued a note confirming that acceptance was correct under Ruling 712, which the Office described in the same note as "an ongoing inconvenience."

Relationship to Other Rulings

Ruling 712 is not the only instrument to address concurrent obligation. Ruling 4117-γ/Appellate held that a ruling contradicting an earlier ruling creates two concurrent obligations, which is close to the standing remainder in effect but quite different in reasoning: Ruling 712 locates the second obligation in the failure of notification, whereas the daughter ruling locates it in the contradiction itself. The Ferrant Counter-Ruling proposes a third account, and the three have never been harmonised.

The ruling has also been read alongside Ruling 511.03, which established Categorical Finality. That ruling provides that a matter finally determined is determined for all purposes; Ruling 712 provides that a ruling not finally withdrawn is not withdrawn for any purpose. Verification Ruling 4117 considered both and declined to say which prevails, noting only that the question "has been referred onward." It has been referred onward four times.

Ruling 88.45 is sometimes cited in remainder disputes on the strength of a marginal annotation in the Ninth Recension, but Ruling 88theta treats that annotation as a point of confusion and states that Ruling 88.45 has no bearing on notification. The Ruling on Residual Rhetoric modifies Ruling 712 only in respect of instruments sealed and never written, which are governed instead by the terms set out in Ruling 2007-σ.

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal dispute concerns whether the standing remainder is a rule of law or merely a rule of forbearance. The Bureau of Doctrinal Consistency maintains that Ruling 712 creates a genuine second obligation, and cites Bench Ruling 45 on the admissibility of ephemeral evidence as support for treating unwritten notice as effective notice. The Office of Continuing Precedent maintains the opposite, that Ruling 712 merely declines to penalise an error and creates nothing.

The disagreement has practical consequences. If the Bureau is right, a clerk who ignores a remainder is in breach; if the Office is right, the clerk is merely unlucky. Ruling 188-A was thought to settle the matter in favour of the Office, but its circulation was interrupted at Floor 604 in Cycle 2061 and the ruling has never completed its rounds. Two floors continue to hold the Bureau's view in writing, and the Office has stopped asking them to stop.

Amendment and Current Standing

Ruling 712 was amended in Cycle 1988 to extend the remainder to instruments never formally issued but circulated in draft, and again in Cycle 2077 to exclude instruments circulated in error by a clerk acting alone. The second amendment arose from the Halveth Grievance, in which a draft notice of repeal was copied to eleven floors by a junior clerk and complied with on six of them; the ruling now provides that a remainder created by a single clerk's error subsists until the clerk's error is corrected, which on the record has never happened.

Ruling 712 remains in force and is reproduced in full in the Seventh Scriptorium, shelf 712, where it is shelved between Ruling 711-b and Ruling 713. It has been amended more often than it has been read, a figure the Scriptorium records without comment.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Seventh Scriptorium: who are they?

The Seventh Scriptorium is the conventional name for the Archivist foundation occupying Floor VII-144, and the administrative body seated there, the Archivists of the Seventh Scriptorium. The name attaches both to the fl…

Seventh Scriptorium
Ferrant Counter-Ruling: how is it conducted?

The Ferrant Counter-Ruling (Vertical Register, Ninth Revision, entry 4,441-C) is the standing instruction by which any ruling issued under the name of Maude Ferrant may be met, within the same session, by a ruling issued…

Ferrant Counter-Ruling
Ruling 88.45: what does it set out?

Ruling 88.45 is a bench ruling of the Spiral 88 series concerning the presumptive validity of an instrument that a party has, through accident or neglect, performed in the wrong building. It is a short ruling: a single o…

Ruling 88.45
Ruling on Residual Rhetoric: what does it set out?

The Ruling on Residual Rhetoric (Formal Designation: Verification Ruling 4117-) is an appellate pronouncement issued by the Judiciary Arm of the Librarians on 17 Sonder, Year 15,302. It addresses the procedural and ethic…

Ruling on Residual Rhetoric

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.