The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Register of Refused Inscriptions

MS 4934.42 · Documents and ordinances

Register of Refused Inscriptions is a bound record, presently in nine volumes with a tenth in preparation, maintained by the Office of Inscriptions to document inscriptions that have been presented for entry and declined. It is not a register of errors. An inscription enters the Register of Refused Inscriptions only when it is judged valid in form, legible, and properly witnessed, and is nonetheless refused entry to the record for which it was submitted. Refusal is thus a positive act, requiring a countersignature and a stated ground; the grounds are drawn from a closed schedule of eleven, of which the fourth ("term already occupied") and the ninth ("term not yet available") account for roughly three refusals in five.

The Register is frequently confused with the Register of Refused Objections, which records objections that were themselves refused, and with the much larger Register of Active Inscriptions, to which refused inscriptions are emphatically not transferred. The distinction is stated on the flyleaf of every volume in the same clerical hand: an inscription refused is not an inscription withdrawn, and only withdrawal closes a file.

Procedure and the eleventh ground

A refusal is entered in the same sitting as the petition that prompted it. The officiating clerk writes the inscription in full, strikes through the operative clause with a single line in red ochre, and records the ground, the date, and the names of two witnesses. The petitioner retains no copy; this has been litigated and the practice upheld (Seventeenth Concordance, Annex 9).

The closed schedule of eleven grounds has been amended once. The eleventh, "presentation in a hand not yet recognized," was added by clerical vote in the winter following the Folio 720 inquiry, when the Office found itself unable to refuse a submission on any existing ground and was obliged to enter it. The volume for that year shows the difficulty plainly: the inscription appears in the Register of Refused Inscriptions with the ground left blank, and a marginal note by Archivist-Proctor Silas of the Lower Scriptorium reads, "It could not be declined. Nothing here says why. I have kept the space open." The space remains open in all subsequent printings, a small unruled rectangle at the foot of each page.

The ink question

The Register's physical history is bound up with questions of hand and medium. Entries before the Fourth Recension were made in lamp-black; afterwards, in iron-gall, in a clerical hand comparable to that of the Register of Refused Inscriptions for the same period — a formulation that appears in the Office of the Declarative Parser's 11-month review and has never been improved upon, chiefly because no one has established which register it refers to. The Bureau of Appointments has twice petitioned to regularize the wording and twice withdrawn.

Bindings vary without pattern. Volume V is quarter-bound in a leather no tannery in the Tower now claims, and the tower's copyist guild has ruled that rebacking it would constitute a re-inscription rather than a repair. The volume has not been rebacked.

Relationship to primary instrumentation

The Register occupies an awkward position in the Tower's hierarchy of evidence. Under the practice of Primary Inscriptions, an inscription entered first against its own record is the measure against which all subsequent inscriptions are tested. A refusal, however well documented, is not such an entry. The Office of the Declarative Parser has argued, in a memorandum of 1,208 words that has been answered in 4,000, that a refusal is a negative primary inscription and should be so treated; the Office of Inscriptions maintains the older view, that a refusal is ancillary and that the Concordance of Ancillary Acts settles the matter. Neither document says what either office claims it says, and the Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register classifies the dispute itself as a benign echo — that is, a recurrent event requiring no intervention.

"A refused thing is not absent from the Tower. It is present in the place where it was not permitted to be."

— Concordance of Ancillary Acts, clause 6

Notable entries

Certain entries are consulted more often than the volumes that house them are consulted for anything else.

  • Entry 4,411 — an inscription offered against a term already occupied by an entry since struck from the Register of Active Inscriptions; the term has remained void for eleven years, and no office will now release it.
  • Entry 4,417 — the objection of Ardon Vex to the shelving of On Knots That Do Not Close, refused on the ground that an objection is not an inscription; Vex's counter-petition is recorded in the Register of Refused Objections as entry 4,417, the number having been reused by a clerk who has since transferred.
  • Entry 6,002 — a memorial inscription refused entry on the ground of term already occupied, then entered in identical terms three days later under the Principle of Permanence versus Accessibility. The two entries stand facing one another, in the same hand, and are not reconciled.
  • Entry 7,319 — marked with the Unattributed Hand, no petitioner named. The entry is complete but for its ground, which reads simply "see above." Nothing is above.

Access and custody

Volumes I through VIII are held in the closed stacks of the Cartulary of Fixed Points and may be consulted by petition, in the presence of a custodian, with no pen. Volume IX is mistrusted by everyone and is read only on a table by the north window, where the light is good. A tenth volume was commissioned in the spring and has not been delivered; the binder reports that the schedule of grounds has been amended and requires a wider margin, and that he will not proceed until he is told which amendment is current. He has been told three times.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register: what does it set out?

The Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register (FAAR) is the principal tabulated record by which the Office of Volumetric Assessment distinguishes faint marks of uncertain provenance from inscriptions of known authorship. Ent…

Frequency Anomaly Assessment Register
Principle of Permanence versus Accessibility: how is it conducted?

Principle of Permanence versus Accessibility is the standing doctrinal antinomy governing the Tower's obligation to preserve inscriptions indefinitely against its obligation to make those same inscriptions retrievable by…

Principle of Permanence versus Accessibility
Ardon Vex: who were they?

Ardon Vex (Spiral 1,906 – Spiral 1,981) was a Librarian of the Second Aperture and the founder of the Circularist faction, a schism in shelving methodology that persists in the upper spirals to the present day. He is chi…

Ardon Vex
Fourth Recension: what does it set out?

The Fourth Recension is the fourth of the numbered recensions of the floor rolls, and the oldest recension still held in working custody. Its opening date is not recorded directly; the Concordances fix it only by negativ…

Fourth Recension

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.