The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Annex Epsilon: Recommendations and Moratoria

MS 2318.44 · Documents and ordinances

Annex Epsilon: Recommendations and Moratoria is the consolidated register of advisory findings and suspended actions issued under Annex Epsilon. It is maintained as a single running document, presently in its eleventh recension, and is unusual among Annex Epsilon instruments in that nothing it contains is enforceable. A Recommendation advises; a Moratorium forbids nothing, but records that a thing has been forbidden before and may be again. Both categories are numbered continuously, so that a Moratorium may be cited between two Recommendations and frequently is, to the irritation of the Reference Shelves staff who must shelve them together.

The register is administered from Annex Epsilon Place alongside Form Set 27-Epsilon, though the two are filed in different rooms and have not been reconciled since the ninth recension. Requests for the current text are answered from either room, depending on the hour.

Origin and the Winter Recension

The register began as a marginal note. In the winter of the eighth year of the Sixth Concordance, the archivist Clerk Amaranth Vale was preparing a routine survey of Vestibule Epsilon and found herself writing, in the gutter beside a tolerance table, a sentence that has since become the register's epigraph: "The riser may vary; the intention may not." The line was copied by three separate hands before the year was out, and by the fourth year following it had been assigned a number.

That first entry, now Recommendation 1, was originally Recommendation 0. It was renumbered after the Ninth Concordance ruled that no instrument administered under Annex Epsilon should commence at zero, on the ground that a zero implies a beginning, and that the Annex has never been able to establish when it began. Recommendation 0 survives in the margins of the ninth recension and is still cited in disputes, usually by whoever wishes to argue that the register predates itself.

What a Recommendation Does

A Recommendation states a preferred course and records the reasons for preferring it. It does not compel. The distinction matters chiefly in that a Recommendation, once issued, cannot be disobeyed — only noted as departed from, in a separate return filed with Desk Epsilon within the forty days.

"Where a Recommendation is departed from, the departure shall be entered, and the entry shall not be read as censure, nor as approval, nor in any other manner than as a record of what was in fact done."

— Annex Epsilon Document, Clause 9

The practical result is a register that reads less like instruction than like weather. Recommendation 44, on the temperature of the Epsilon Track Submissions holding bay, has been departed from continuously since its issue and is retained for the sake of the record of its departure, which has grown longer than the Recommendation itself. The register's compilers have twice proposed separating the two; both proposals are themselves pending as Moratoria.

Moratoria

A Moratorium is a suspension of an action that was previously permitted and is expected to be permitted again. The distinction from prohibition is insisted upon by the Librarians, who hold that the Tower prohibits nothing, having found no authority competent to receive a prohibition. A Moratorium is accordingly temporary in intention and indefinite in duration, and the register contains Moratoria older than most of its Recommendations.

Moratorium 12, suspending the re-sorting of the Master Sorting Table, has stood since the fourth recension. Moratorium 31, on the sounding of the vestibule bell during audit weeks, was lifted and re-imposed four times in a single season, after which Annex Δ wrote to ask that it be either lifted or imposed and not both. The reply is not in the register. The register notes only that the bell was rung once, on an unnumbered floor, and that no one has proposed a further lifting.

Disagreement: The Status of Advisory Findings

The register's authority is contested. The Sixth Concordance treats Recommendations as "findings of the Annex concerning its own preferences," which is to say, matters of taste recorded for completeness. The Ninth Concordance, at Annex 2, treats them as "determinations binding in the manner of determinations," without specifying the manner. The two have not been reconciled, and the Epsilon Reference Shelves maintain both readings on facing pages, which has led to the shelving dispute of the last three decades.

Clerk Amaranth Vale herself declined to settle the matter, writing in the eleventh recension's preface that "a Recommendation that were binding would not require recommending, and a Recommendation that were not binding would not require writing down; the register exists in the space between, and I decline to move it." Her successor, Clerk Hollis Merrow, has taken a different position, and has twice attempted to have the preface struck. Both attempts were filed as Moratoria and have not been resolved.

Holding, Access, and Notices

The register is consulted most often by parties seeking the terms of their own departure from a Recommendation, which are entered in a separate docket kept with the Epsilon Track Submissions and audited each Concordance cycle. The docket has been described as complete, though the archivist who described it so has since had that description noted as a departure.

The register may be consulted during the hours of the Reference Shelves, and by those of the Annex's own staff at any hour. Visitors are asked not to annotate the margins.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Epsilon Reference Shelves: what is it for?

The Epsilon Reference Shelves are a closed stack of ratified instruments housed one half-landing below Annex Epsilon, consisting of the Epsilon Reference Shelves proper and their accompanying finding apparatus. Every ite…

Epsilon Reference Shelves
Vestibule Epsilon: where is it?

Vestibule Epsilon is the principal administrative antechamber and procedural nexus within the Administrative Spire, designated under Clause 18.7 of the Third Concordance and reconciled with the operational tolerances of …

Vestibule Epsilon
Annex Δ maintains close administrative ties with Annex Epsilon: how is it conducted?

Annex Δ maintains close administrative ties with Annex Epsilon is a standing administrative declaration of the Fourth Concordance, entered in the register on 14 Ember 2 and reaffirmed without amendment at each of the six…

Annex Δ maintains close administrative ties with Annex Epsilon
Annex Epsilon Document: what does it set out?

Annex Epsilon Document refers to a specific class of supplemental texts originating from Annex Epsilon of the Sixth Concordance, characterized by their dual nature as both codifying instruments and self-modifying archive…

Annex Epsilon Document

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.