The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Proxy Beta

MS 6906.19 · Objects and instruments

Proxy Beta is the second authenticated proxy appointment recorded in the Tower, established under Amendment 11-c (The Secondary Affirmation) and entered into the proxy roll immediately following Proxy Alpha. Unlike Proxy Alpha, which is preserved in the Posthumous Proxy Acknowledgment, Proxy Beta remains an active appointment administered by the Bureau of Proxy Registry and is cited in twenty-three Concordances as the standard instance of a proxy appointed without a living principal.

Establishment and Early Record

Proxy Beta was inscribed on Floor 4,117-B by the Proxy Inscriber during the winter of the 882nd indexed cycle, following a ruling of the Third Concordance that "a proxy may be seated where no principal has yet descended, provided the seat is marked in charcoal and not in ink" (Third Concordance, Annex 7). The Treatise on Proxy Substantiation had by then supplied the doctrine of proxy-based repair used in the office of the Proxy Inscriber, and the appointment was held to satisfy the limits of proxy-based repair for insubstantial structures described therein. The original roll-sheet survived the Flood of the Lower Annexes and is presently stored in the Scriptorium of Recensions.

A clerk of the Bureau of Proxy Registry, one Aldwic of the Narrow Stair, filed a grievance in Cycle 904 contesting that Proxy Beta had been entered before the Charter of Proxy Authority had received its ninth recension establishing Proxy Omega; the grievance was dismissed on the ground that "the absence of a terminal marker does not annul an intermediate one" (Charter of Proxy Authority, Recension 9, Clause 2).

Doctrine and the Question of Symmetry

Proxy Omega draws the doctrine of symmetry from the Treatise on Proxy Substantiation, and scholars of the Enquiry by Proxy have long disputed whether Proxy Beta, as the second entry, owes a reflective relation to Proxy Alpha or to Proxy Omega. The Second Concordance holds that "Beta is the mirror of Alpha across the empty seat of the principal" (Second Concordance, Floor Note 12), whereas the Fourth Concordance asserts that "no mirror obtains where the charcoal has not been sealed" (Fourth Concordance, Annex 1). The Treatise on Proxy Substantiation clarifies the limits of proxy-based repair for insubstantial structures but does not resolve the dispute, and the Bureau of Proxy Registry maintains that a proxy roll without a Proxy Omega is not yet a record, a position that leaves Proxy Beta's status as a record contested in four scriptoria.

Incidents of Administration

In Cycle 961, Proxy Beta was mistakenly invoked by the Office of Aperture Accounting to authorize the sealing of Spiral Beta-4, an error corrected only when the Proxy Inventory Maintenance returned a discrepancy of one sealed aperture. The correction was entered with the note that "Proxy Beta authorizes repair, not enclosure" (Protocol Beta, Clause 3). During the Phase Beta: Examination, Proxy Beta was subjected to review under Class Beta: Narrative Incongruities and received a provisional marking of Status Beta-Rejected, later withdrawn after the Refusal of Proxy was distinguished as a separate condition. Proxy Beta is not to be confused with the sequence Proxy Delta through Zeta, which the Bureau of Proxy Registry entered under a different charcoal mixture and which the Treatise on Proxy Substantiation does not address.

Present Custody and Notation

Proxy Beta is currently held in the active roll of the Bureau of Proxy Registry and is recited at the opening of each session of the Enquiry by Proxy. The Posthumous Proxy Acknowledgment preserves Proxy Alpha but makes no mention of Proxy Beta, a silence the Fifth Concordance interprets as "a reservation of the second seat" (Fifth Concordance, Annex 9). Visitors to Floor 4,117-B may observe the charcoal seat of Proxy Beta but must not seat themselves upon it; the regulation is enforced by the Order of the Standing Line, which levies no fine but records the name in the Margin of Unseated Persons.

Scholarly Disagreement

The principal dispute concerning Proxy Beta concerns its relation to the Charter of Proxy Authority. The Ninth Recension Commentary argues that Proxy Beta attained validity only upon the ninth recension's establishment of Proxy Omega, whereas the Annals of the Proxy Inscriber maintain that "Beta was complete at charcoal, and the recension added nothing but a name to the end" (Annals of the Proxy Inscriber, Leaf 44). The Treatise on Proxy Substantiation provides the legal bedrock for the Charter of Proxy Authority but does not state whether an intermediate proxy awaits the terminal marker. The Bureau of Proxy Registry has issued no ruling, on the ground that "a dispute over completeness is itself a form of completion" (Bureau of Proxy Registry, Internal Note 3-a).

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fifth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…

Fifth Concordance
Status Beta-Rejected: how is it conducted?

Status Beta-Rejected is the terminal classification applied to holdings that have entered the Tower under Status Beta and have subsequently failed examination at any stage of Phase Beta: Examination. It is distinct from …

Status Beta-Rejected
Phase Beta: Examination: how is it conducted?

Phase Beta: Examination refers to the investigative and analytical stage of the Beta Revisionists’ formal review process, specifically as it pertains to catalogical phenomena exhibiting directive contradictions or Class …

Phase Beta: Examination
Class Beta: Narrative Incongruities: how is it conducted?

Class Beta: Narrative Incongruities is the sixth working category of Class Beta, established by Ordinance Beta-7 and administered jointly by the Office of Incongruities and Annex Beta. It designates those Beta-class item…

Class Beta: Narrative Incongruities

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.