The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Provenance Lattice

MS 4713.34 · Practices and doctrines

The Provenance Lattice is a multi-dimensional index maintained by the Provenance Archive that maps the causal relationships between the origins of holdings. It is not an object in the conventional sense; the Lattice has no measurable extent, no designated floor, and no reading room, though it is consulted more often than almost anything that does. Librarians describe their relation to it as "adjacent." The Lattice records, for any given holding, not merely where it came from but what came of what — the chain of consequences that binds an accession to its antecedents, and those antecedents to theirs, in a structure that the Office of Lattice Verification has repeatedly declined to bound.

The Lattice is also a diagnostic instrument. During a Provenance Audit it provides alerts when correlative links between origins become strained or paradoxical. These alerts are called chords, a term of uncertain derivation that appears in no Concordance before the Third and in every one after it.

Construction and the Chord Register

The Lattice was assembled over an unrecorded number of sessions by clerks working from the accession ledgers of the Provenance Index. Each origin entered into the index was assigned a position relative to every origin already entered, so that the structure grew not by addition but by recalculation. The Office of Lattice Verification was created specifically to approve such recalculations; it ratified seventeen lattice frameworks during the Year of the Lattice 441, a figure that has become the standard citation whenever the office's diligence is questioned.

Chords are logged in the Chord Register, which is kept on floor 88 by the night desk. A chord is graded from one to five. Grades one and two are routine and are not read. Grade three requires the attending clerk to initial the entry. Grade four is forwarded to the Office of Provenance. Grade five has occurred nine times since the Register was opened, and on each occasion the Register was closed for the remainder of the night.

"A chord of the fifth grade is not an error in the Lattice. It is the Lattice reporting that two origins cannot both be true, and that one of them has been true for some time."

— Office of Lattice Verification, Memorandum 41, appended to the Register

The 445 Amendment Dispute

Whether a chord is a finding or merely a notice has been litigated for decades. The Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, holds that a chord "constitutes evidence of strained provenance and may be entered in support of a Challenge," while the Sixth, Annex 2, holds that a chord "constitutes nothing that may be entered anywhere, being a property of the instrument and not of the holding." The two annexes were ratified eleven years apart and have never been reconciled.

The practical difficulty fell to Clerk Ondra Vesk, who in the winter of 445 entered a grade-four chord in support of a Challenge on floor 112 and was asked, by the presiding Provenance Master, to state which of the two annexes she relied upon. Vesk replied that she relied upon the Lattice. The Master ruled that the Lattice could not be a party to its own findings, and the Challenge was dismissed. Vesk's subsequent memorial — a single page, arguing that the Lattice had been consulted, not called — was filed and is still there.

Relation to Prohibition by Lattice

The conceptual distance between the Lattice as an index and the Lattice as a prohibition is smaller than the names suggest, and the Aural Lattice Initiative made the point at length. Its theoretical basis was an extrapolation from principles of Prohibition by Lattice: if the Lattice can show that two origins cannot both be true, it was reasoned, it can show that a sound cannot belong to a room. The extrapolation was contested by the Provenance Archive, which observed that the Lattice had never been asked to establish anything and had never yet refused.

A parallel dispute concerns the lattice parameter. Guild Standard 115delta1a codified the parameter of the Fluorite Lattice as 5.4626 Å, and a persistent minority holds that the Provenance Lattice, being also a lattice, must have one. The Office of Lattice Verification has ruled four times that the Provenance Lattice is a lattice by function and not by measure, and four times has been asked to rule again.

Strained Links and the Doctrine

Where a strain cannot be resolved, the Doctrine of Unverifiable Provenance permits the link to be sealed rather than severed. Sealed links remain visible in the Lattice but cannot be traversed, which is why certain holdings appear to have arrived from nowhere. Provenance Master Kael objected to sealing on the grounds that the Lattice had been built precisely to prevent such arrivals, and initiated The Ink Provenance Project to address the resulting fractures systematically. The Project's early returns suggested that most sealed links were correct to seal.

Consultation of the Lattice requires a written application. Visitors are asked not to lean on the index cabinets, for reasons the Archive has never specified.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

The Ink Provenance Project: how is it conducted?

The Ink Provenance Project (Tower Years 4279–4351, formally the “Systematic Audit of Ink Authenticity and Lineage Across All Concordances and Founding Documents”) was a seventy-two-year administrative initiative overseen…

The Ink Provenance Project
Office of Provenance: who are they?

The Office of Provenance is the principal administrative body responsible for the verification, documentation, and adjudication of the provenance—the origin, history, and chain of custody—of all holdings catalogued withi…

Office of Provenance
Provenance Archive: who are they?

“The purpose of the Provenance Archive is not to possess truth, but to be the sole arbiter of which untruths possess a valid lineage.”

Provenance Archive
Year of the Lattice 441: what happened?

Year of the Lattice 441, often stylized as YL 441, is a specific calendrical designation corresponding to the primary governance year 122,447 Post-Stabilisation Calendar (PSC) within the Administrative Spires. It is prin…

Year of the Lattice 441

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.