The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Lattice Alignment Check

MS 6187.00 · Practices and doctrines

The Lattice Alignment Check is the procedure by which a floor's structural lattice is verified to occupy the position the Floor Register assigns it, rather than merely the position in which it is presently found. Unlike the Dimensional Calibration Check, which measures a lattice's dimensions, the Lattice Alignment Check measures its fidelity — the correspondence between the lattice as built and the lattice as catalogued. It is administered by the Bureau of Spatial and Temporal Alignment under warrant of Concordance XXVII, Annex 6, and is recorded as a sub-stage of the Epistemic Alignment Check wherever the subject under examination is load-bearing.

Origin

The Check was instituted in the winter of the year the register records as 44 after the Second Recension, following the discovery that the Ninth Ascending Corridor had been filed at a pitch of three degrees against the vertical, and had been so filed for nineteen years. No masonry had moved. The error lay entirely in the record, and the record, being the only authority on where corridors stand, had made the corridor wrong. Librarian Ottilie Vance, then junior registrar of the Floor Register, observed in her dissent that "a lattice which does not know its own angle is a lattice in transit, whatever its stones believe" (Dissents of the Register, vol. iv). The Bureau adopted the phrase as a standing maxim and the Check as its enforcement.

The incumbent overseer of lattice affairs is Hesper Mull, who has held the post since the Third Recension and who signs every certificate in the lower left corner, a convention she has described as "load-bearing."

Procedure

The Check proceeds in three passes. In the first, the surveyor fixes the lattice's nominal datum by reading the floor's number aloud at each of its four corners; the numbers are expected to agree, and where they do not, the disagreement is not resolved at this stage but recorded on the Discrepancy Sheet and permitted to travel with the file. In the second pass, a plumb-line of standard braided construction, not less than nine ells, is lowered from the aperture above and permitted to settle for the length of one Forenoon Interval. In the third pass the surveyor compares the settle against the register entry and certifies one of four dispositions: aligned, aligned with note, provisionally aligned, or retired to the Register of Provisional Structures.

The plumb-line must be of standard braided construction. Four of the six failures recorded between Concordance XXIV and Concordance XXVII trace to lines plaited on the site by surveyors who considered the standard line too slow to obtain.

Where a floor's lattice is found provisionally aligned, it is not corrected. It is marked with a provisional tag in pale green, which must be renewed every nine years or the floor reverts to unaligned and may not be entered by two people at once.

Relationship to other Checks

The Lattice Alignment Check is not a stage of the Check protocol proper, a distinction the Bureau has defended at length and to no great effect. It is instead a precondition: no floor may be submitted to the Procedural Harmony Check until its lattice certificate is current, and no certificate is held current if the floor has been resurfaced, relabelled, or — as happened on Floor 22,187 in the spring of the Year of the Long Inventory — repainted.

Practitioners have long noted an unhelpful overlap with the Crossreferential Stability Check, which also concerns whether a thing is where its references say it is. The two are distinguished by subject: the Lattice Alignment Check concerns masonry, the Crossreferential Stability Check concerns citations. Where a citation is carved into masonry, as in the case of the Inscribed Index on the Eleventh Descending Landing, both Checks are convened and the surveyors are required to work in separate shifts. No satisfactory ordering of precedence has been established, and the Bureau's position is that none is needed, since a properly built floor should not require both.

Lattice certificates are among the prerequisites for convening the Second Verification Amp Concordance Check, though not, the Bureau insists, formative of it.

Contested readings

The principal scholarly dispute concerns the tolerance of the second pass. Annex 6 of Concordance XXVII states that the settle "shall not exceed the breadth of a thumb in nine ells." Concordance XXXI, promulgated eleven years later, states that it "shall not exceed the breadth of a thumb in nine ells, inclusive of the thumb." The two cannot both be satisfied: the inclusive reading leaves no tolerance at all, since any measured error is by definition within the breadth of the thumb that measures it.

The Bureau of Spatial and Temporal Alignment maintains the exclusive reading, on the ground that Annex 6 is the more specific instrument. The Office of the Register maintains the inclusive reading on the ground that Annex 6 is older and older instruments are more specific by default. The Guild of Surveyors has resolved to apply the exclusive reading in the ascendant halls and the inclusive reading in the descendent ones, a compromise that has satisfied no one and has required the Guild to maintain two sets of plumb-lines.

"The inclusive reading is not a tolerance. It is a prohibition on measurement. I have said so in writing eleven times and I expect to say it a twelfth."

— Hesper Mull, marginalia to the Surveyors' Circular of the Fourth Recension

A minority position, associated with the late registrar Ambrose Kettle, holds that the Check is misnamed and ought to have been called the Lattice Confirmation Check, since in his survey of four hundred floors the lattice never moved and only the paperwork did.

Failure conditions

A lattice fails the Check when the aperture above cannot be located, when the plumb-line is lost or knotted, or when the floor's number is disputed and the surveyor has begun reading from the wrong corner. In failure the floor is not closed. It is affixed with a closed floor notice and remains in use until the notice is observed.

Certified lattice alignments by recension, upper floors only:

RecensionFloors examinedAlignedProvisionally alignedLost lines
Second1,2041,19860
Third1,9111,877313
Fourth887792
Bureau of Spatial and Temporal Alignment, annual return, Floor Register annexe

The low count for the Fourth Recension is not a decline in alignment but a decline in surveyors, two of whom remain unaccounted for below the Twelfth Descending Landing and whose plumb-lines were recovered without them.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of the Register: who are they?

The Office of the Register is the Tower's oldest continuously seated authority on the distinction between rulings, statutes, and ordinances. It occupies the western half of Floor 118, a suite of rooms whose windows face …

Office of the Register
Epistemic Alignment Check: how is it conducted?

The Epistemic Alignment Check is the fifth and terminal stage of the Check protocol, conducted after the Crossreferential Stability Check and before the dossier is returned to the originating floor for sealing. Its purpo…

Epistemic Alignment Check
Check: how is it conducted?

The Check, governed by Concordance 7.4.12 and detailed in Annex G, is the formal process of procedural verification required before any subject or object is accepted for cataloguing within the Tower. A Check comprises th…

Check
Second Verification Amp Concordance Check: how is it conducted?

The Second Verification Amp Concordance Check is the third-stage instrument by which a document already verified once may be verified again against the text of the Second Concordance, and is distinguished from every othe…

Second Verification Amp Concordance Check

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.