The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Protocol 5-Echo (Containment)

MS 6548.40 · Documents and ordinances

Protocol 5-Echo (Containment) is the standing instrument governing the treatment of echo phenomena adjudged too faint to warrant full sequestration and too persistent to be safely disregarded. First drafted in the winter of the year recorded as Floor 2,118 and amended eleven times since, it occupies the narrow middle ground between the general machinery of Echo Containment and the heavier quarantine provisions of Containment Protocol Theta. Its distinguishing feature is a distinction not of intensity but of audibility: an echo that can be heard only when sought is treated differently from one that announces itself.

The Protocol is administered jointly by the Office of Residual Resonance and the Echo Containment office, an arrangement that has produced four recorded disagreements and one unresolved one, discussed below.

Origins and the Casside Revision

Protocol 5-Echo originated as a marginal annotation to Echo Archive Protocol 7.19-B, which had classified all echo material into two grades: verified and discordant. That binary proved unworkable on Floor 2,118, where the archivist Miren Casside recorded what she termed "a low and continual return, not locatable to any single source, present in every corridor and in none of them." Casside's submission of eleven pages of observation was returned to her twice for want of a category; on the third submission she appended a note reading "I am not asking that it be catalogued. I am asking that it be somewhere." The Librarian of the Middle Register permitted the creation of a provisional third grade by instrument dated 14 Ember 6, and the annotation was expanded into the Protocol we have.

Casside was subsequently transferred to Floor 61 for reasons recorded only as "reassignment in the ordinary course." The Protocol retained her name in its preamble until the seventh amendment, when it was replaced by the formula "the observing officer of record."

The Three Grades

Under Clause 4, echoes within the Protocol's remit are assigned to one of three grades according to the conditions under which they become perceptible. The grades are not ranks of danger, and the Aggregate Echo has twice declined to treat them as such, though practice on the lower floors frequently does.

  • Grade A — perceptible only to an observer actively seeking the echo, and not to an observer seeking something else.
  • Grade B — perceptible without seeking, but only in the absence of other sound.
  • Grade C — perceptible in ordinary conditions, but not twice in the same place.

Grade C is the source of most subsequent difficulty. A grade C echo is by definition unverifiable in situ, since its second occurrence will be elsewhere; the Protocol resolves this by requiring that the observation be recorded immediately, in the corridor, and countersigned within the hour by any officer of the Register. Where no officer can be found within the hour the record is sealed unopened and filed under Annex B of Containment Protocol 7-Alpha.

"An echo observed once and recorded twice is a datum. An echo observed twice is a coincidence. The Protocol is concerned only with data."

— Containment Protocol 7-Alpha, Annex B, preliminary note

Relation to Echo Containment

Protocol 5-Echo does not itself contain anything. It classifies, and passes its classifications to the Echo Containment office, which applies the sequestration measures set out in Echo Archive Protocol 7.19-B. In practice the boundary is imperfect: the dissolution of Echo Crystal in neutralized phlogistic aether is an act of containment, but the decision to dissolve a Grade B crystal is taken under 5-Echo, and the resulting records are filed in two places. The Bureau of Quantitative Esoteria has objected to this on three occasions, noting that Form V-7α cannot accommodate a classification that precedes containment and postdates sourcing. The objection remains open.

Gratuitous linking of 5-Echo records to unrelated holdings has been cited more than once as a violation of the guidelines established under Echo Containment, most notably in the matter of Artifact 306-λ-05 ("The Echo's Source"), where a filing clerk's cross-reference to eleven floors was found to have created a navigational hazard on Floor 44.

The Dispute with the Theta Office

The unresolved disagreement concerns whether an echo that has passed from Grade B to Grade C during observation should be escalated under Containment Protocol Theta (θ), which establishes a quarantine radius for phenomena of confirmed extent. The Office of Residual Resonance holds that escalation is automatic, since a grade that changes under observation indicates an extent not yet measured. The Echo Containment office holds that escalation requires a fresh determination, since the Protocol's grades describe audibility and not extent, and that the Theta radius cannot be drawn around something that has not been located.

The Third Concordance appears to support both positions. Annex 4, clause 9, provides that "a thing that moves is measured where it is found," while Annex 4, clause 11, provides that "nothing is measured until it is still." The Seventh Recension of the Concordance, which prints both clauses on facing pages, adds no reconciliation. Clerks on Floor 89 have adopted the practice of filing such cases in duplicate and letting the second copy remain unopened, which the Librarian of the Middle Register has neither approved nor forbidden.

Practical Provisions

Officers observing under the Protocol carry a sealed notebook and a single pencil. The pencil may not be sharpened in the corridor of observation; the reason is not given in the text, but Clause 2 is generally taken to require it. Notebooks are surrendered at the end of each shift whether or not they contain an entry, and the surrender of an empty notebook is recorded in the same register as the surrender of a full one.

Protocol 5-Echo is reviewed every seven years alongside the operational standards of the Aggregate Echo. The most recent review made no changes and sat for nine days.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Containment Protocol Theta (θ): how is it conducted?

Containment Protocol Theta is the procedural framework by which the Tower responds to spatial and ontological anomalies exhibiting an elevated Selvage Constant. It is the principal instrument of the Theta series — the co…

Containment Protocol Theta (θ)
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Containment Protocol Theta: how is it conducted?

Containment Protocol Theta is a specialized procedural framework governing the initial response to spatial and ontological anomalies exhibiting an elevated Selvage Constant. It operates as a primary-tier contingency plan…

Containment Protocol Theta
Containment Protocol 7-Alpha: how is it conducted?

Containment Protocol 7-Alpha is a foundational protocol governing the procedural and physical containment of cognitohazardous flora within the Moss Growth Spirespur 7 Alpha. It represents a dual-track system, integrating…

Containment Protocol 7-Alpha

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.