The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Proposed Reconciliation Path

MS 6956.23 · Practices and doctrines

The Proposed Reconciliation Path is a designated corridor of floor, stair, and threshold, marked out in advance of a dispute's resolution, along which the parties to that dispute are required to walk together before any instrument of settlement is sealed. It is not a route to agreement. Librarians are careful on this point. The Path is the route taken while disagreeing, and its length is set by the Office of Procedural Reconciliation in proportion to the estimated depth of the disagreement, measured in corridors by Reconciliation Gauge where a gauge can be spared and by pacing where it cannot.

The practice is distinguished from a Proposed Locale in that a Locale is nominated; a Path is walked. It is distinguished from the Clerks of the Straight Path in that the Clerks administer straightness as an office, whereas the Proposed Reconciliation Path is a thing laid on a floor and stepped on. The two are frequently confused in filing, and the Office of Epistemic Transit maintains a standing note on the distinction.

Origin and first laying

The Path was first laid in the winter of Year 612, on Floor 1104, in the matter of a boundary dispute between two scriptoria that had shared a single wall for eleven years without agreeing which side of it the wall stood on. The adjudicating Librarian, whose name the record gives only as the Ninth Sitter, is reported to have said that if the parties could not agree on a line they could at least agree on a walk, and ordered the corridor between the scriptoria cleared of shelving for the purpose.

"Let them be walked, and let the walking be entered in the register, and let no seal be set until the register shows them returned."

— Eighth Concordance, Annex 12, marginal instruction

The parties walked the corridor in four minutes and settled the matter in the following decade. The corridor was not restored to shelving, and remains clear. It is now numbered among the earliest extant Paths, and is walked annually by the clerks of Floor 1104 in commemoration, without dispute, which the Bureau of Latent Significance has noted as a difficulty.

Construction and marking

A Proposed Reconciliation Path is marked at both ends with a brass plate bearing the matter number, the date of laying, and the estimated depth in corridors. Between the plates the Path is left unmarked. This is deliberate and is the subject of the standing complaint from the Godown of Unmarked Surfaces, which has twice petitioned for intermediate markers and twice been refused on the ground that a Path with milestones invites the parties to measure their progress, and progress is not the purpose.

Floor covering along a Path is required to be of a single tone. Where the corridor passes a window, a screen is fitted; where it passes a stair, the stair is walked downward only from the upper plate to the lower, never the reverse, as the reverse constitutes a retracing and a retracing voids the walk. The Subbureau of Temporal Reconciliation deploys a Temporal Gauge at each plate before the parties arrive and reports baseline Silent Reconciliation readings afterward, though what these readings indicate has never been stated in a recension the archive can produce.

The walk and its record

Parties walk in silence, or not; the Concordance is silent on speech and the Office of Procedural Reconciliation has declined to rule, observing only that in the matter of the Two Doors (Floor 2031) the parties spoke continuously for the whole of a nine-corridor Path and emerged with the matter unresolved, and that in the matter of the Salt Ledger they did not speak and emerged with it resolved, and that no conclusion follows from either.

A walking clerk follows at four paces and records the return. The clerk does not intervene. The clerk may not be addressed. Clerks assigned to long Paths are rotated at the half-corridor mark, and the handover is conducted in silence to preserve the record's continuity. In the winter of Year 889 a clerk on a Path of nineteen corridors was relieved at the mark by a clerk who had not been told the matter number, and the register for that season shows two walks running concurrently through one corridor, which the Office of Procedural Reconciliation ruled a clerical error of the relieving clerk and not a property of the Path.

Disputes

The principal scholarly disagreement concerns whether a Proposed Reconciliation Path may be laid before the parties have consented to walk it. The Fourth Concordance holds that a path proposed is a path consented, on the reasoning that a party who declines a Path has thereby declared the depth of the dispute and the laying is vindicated either way. The Eleventh Concordance, Clause 9, appears to require the consent of both parties in writing prior to the laying of the first plate, and does not say what becomes of a plate laid without it.

The Office of Procedural Reconciliation has resolved the conflict in practice by laying the plates and dating the consent retroactively to the date of laying, a manoeuvre upheld in the matter of the Quarrel of the Long Table on the authority of Theoretical Reconciliation. Amendment Trajectory Forecasting has twice been asked to model the Path's effect on a dispute's subsequent legislative career and has twice returned a forecast of "indeterminate, save that it will be longer," which the Office has adopted as its standing position.

Inventory of a Path in good standing

An inspection of Floor 1104 in Year 1042 recorded the following along the earliest Path, in order from the upper plate to the lower:

  • One upper plate, brass, inscribed, worn at the screw-holes.
  • One screen, fitted, at the window overlooking the light-well.
  • Seven flagstones of uniform tone, two replaced.
  • One stair, down only, eleven treads.
  • One lower plate, brass, inscribed, screw-holes intact.

The inspection noted that the two replaced flagstones were of a marginally lighter tone than the five original and recommended that the whole be relaid in a single quarry's stock, a recommendation the Office has carried forward unactioned since Year 1042. The corridor is not to be swept on the morning of a walk.

Relation to other instruments

A Path is not a Proposed Containment Protocol and does not contain anything, although parties have on three recorded occasions refused to leave the corridor at the lower plate, requiring the plates to be lifted and the matter reclassified under Section D. It is not among the holdings entered in The Inventory of Proposed Holdings, a circumstance the Office of Procedural Reconciliation attributes to the Inventory's exclusion of routes, and the Acoustic Reconciliation Bureau attributes to oversight.

Where a Path and a Proposed Boundary Manuscript run concurrently along one corridor, the Path takes precedence on the floor and the Manuscript on the wall, and the two are read separately. The Proposed Nineteenth Concordance would, if adopted, require every Path to be walked in both directions and the return entered as a second walk; the Office of Procedural Reconciliation has estimated the cost at some thousands of clerk-hours and has recommended that the Nineteenth Concordance be referred to Reconciliation Hour for a preliminary reading, which is where the matter presently rests.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Subbureau of Temporal Reconciliation: who are they?

The Subbureau of Temporal Reconciliation (STR) is a regional administrative office of the Office of Temporal Reconciliation responsible for the on-site implementation and local arbitration of the Temporal Reconciliation …

Subbureau of Temporal Reconciliation
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Proposed Locale: how is it conducted?

The Proposed Locale is the provisional designation applied to any site within the Tower whose existence has been asserted in writing but not yet confirmed by inspection, survey, or the testimony of a returning expedition…

Proposed Locale
Bureau of Latent Significance: who are they?

The Bureau of Latent Significance is a regulatory and archival sub-directorate operating within the Department of Applied Metaphysics on Floor 909, officially designated as the administrator of procedures established by …

Bureau of Latent Significance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.