The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Procedural Impossibility

MS 1265.15 · Practices and doctrines

Definition

Procedural Impossibility is the condition under which a required step in an archival or administrative process cannot be completed as written, whether by contradiction of its own terms, absence of its necessary material, or dependence on a determination that only the completed step itself can supply. It is distinguished from ordinary obstruction in that the step does not fail intermittently or under load; it fails in principle, in the same way, on each attempt, and its failure is reproducible by any clerk of ordinary competence. The subject is catalogued here as a condition rather than as a document, practice, or body, though it has been all three at various points. The classification itself is disputed; see Class Alpha: Contradictory Mandates and the note under Disputes below.

Recognition

Procedural Impossibility is not self-announcing. A process that cannot be completed tends, in its early stages, to look exactly like a process that is merely difficult. The Tower's standing test for recognition, codified in the Manual of Contradictory Protocols, holds that a step is procedurally impossible when three consecutive attempts to complete it, each by a differently assigned clerk, produce three failures for reasons that do not overlap. The third failure must be recorded in writing before the second is read aloud. Where the step involves certification of an entity's own status, a further test applies: if the certification requires a finding that the certification exists, and the certification's existence is the matter being certified, the condition is met on the first attempt. The Certificate of Verified Absence is the standard illustration and remains the most frequently cited precedent. Two conditions are expressly excluded from recognition. Absence of the clerk is not impossibility of the step; and a deadline that has passed is not a contradiction of the work, merely a disappointment. Both exclusions were added by amendment and are widely regarded as addressing specific historical grievances rather than principle.

History

The condition was first named in the Eleventh Recension of the Manual of Contradictory Protocols, although earlier clerks had described its effects for generations without agreeing on whether they were describing a thing or an inconvenience. The earliest unambiguous entry concerns a requisition for a form that could only be obtained by submitting the requisition, filed and abandoned on Floor 61 in the winter of UC 411. Formal recognition changed the Tower's handling of such matters considerably. Prior to the Eleventh Recension, an impossible step was ordinarily reassigned, then reassigned again, and eventually left on a shelf with a note. Afterward it was expected to be entered in the register and assigned a case number, which introduced the secondary problem that a condition defined by the impossibility of its own registration cannot easily be registered. The workaround adopted — registration in the second person, "a step exists which cannot be completed" — persisted for two centuries and is still visible in older volumes of the Procedural Anomaly Validation ledger. The East Unbound Stacks Sub-basement of Unanswerable Petitions has, by long custom, received the physical remainder of matters closed on this basis: the unanswered originals, the triplicate copies, the notes.

Classification disputes

The principal dispute concerns whether Procedural Impossibility is a single condition or a family of conditions sharing a name. The Office of Primary Determinations maintains that it is a single condition with two branches — self-referential and material — and that any apparent third branch is an instance of one of these poorly described. The Department of Jurisprudential Anomalies maintains that material impossibility (the absent form, the unobtainable seal) is not impossibility at all but scarcity, and should never have been admitted. The Department of Marginalia holds the opposing view on both counts, in writing, at length. A third position, associated with the annotator Hesper Calloway and never formally adopted, is that Procedural Impossibility admits of degrees, and that the degrees run not from impossible to possible but from impossible-to-attempt to impossible-to-abandon. Matters in the second category, on this view, are the more serious, since they consume attention indefinitely without ever producing a failure that can be filed. The Concordances do not settle the matter. The Eleventh Concordance refers to "the impossibility" in the singular throughout Annex 3, while the Fourteenth Concordance uses the plural in every clause of its Article 9 and then reverts to the singular in the Article's own closing sentence.

Relation to other holdings

Procedural Impossibility should not be confused with Auto-Refutative Holdings, which are texts that argue against their own truth rather than steps that cannot be performed. A Möbius Folio may be perfectly completable and still be impossible to finish; see Möbius Folio. Similarly, the condition recorded on Floor Forty-Seven as a descending ramp of alternating necessity and impossibility is a manifestation of the Spiral of Unending Debate and is not, on the ruling of the Sixteenth Concordance, a Procedural Impossibility, though visitors frequently assume otherwise. Where a Procedural Impossibility has been recognized and closed, the matter is typically reclassified as an instance of the Doctrine of Convergent Impossibility if the failure was plural, or simply recorded as exhausted if it was singular. Neither reclassification restores the step.

Standing notes

Clerks assigned to matters closed on this basis are reminded that re-attempting the step is not prohibited, but that a re-attempt which fails will be recorded as a new matter rather than as a reopening, and will therefore require a new case number. Requests for case numbers cannot be processed while the original matter remains open. The corridor lamp outside the register office on Floor 12 has been reported out since the spring of UC 604. This is not considered related.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Office of Primary Determinations: who are they?

The Office of Primary Determinations (OPD) is the central bureau within the Office of Verification responsible for adjudicating applications for Primary Citizenship. Located on Floor 6,491 (the Hall of Initial Commitment…

Office of Primary Determinations
Certificate of Verified Absence: what does it set out?

A Certificate of Verified Absence (CVA) is a substrate, issued by the Realized Absence Guild, used as a standard for measuring the deformation caused by bibliostatic pressure and for attesting to the conceptual mass of u…

Certificate of Verified Absence
Department of Marginalia: who are they?

The Department of Marginalia is the formal administrative unit within the Tower responsible for the oversight, collation, and systematic analysis of marginalia appended to official documents. Initially an informal design…

Department of Marginalia
Manual of Contradictory Protocols: what does it set out?

The Manual of Contradictory Protocols is the foundational procedural document governing the identification, classification, and archival processing of materials that exhibit logical impossibility or ontological inconsist…

Manual of Contradictory Protocols

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.