Principle of Non-Contradictory Omission
MS 1419.37 · Practices and doctrines
Principle of Non-Contradictory Omission is a cataloguing doctrine of the Tower whereby a subject that is absent from a given floor's holdings must not be recorded as absent in a manner that would contradict its simultaneous absence from a different floor's holdings. The principle is administered in tension with the Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology and is frequently cited in disputes before the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony.
Origins and First Recension
The Principle of Non-Contradictory Omission was first set down in the margin of the Addendum to Annex Delta, where it was described as a remedy for the "procedural gaps" left by floors that omitted the same object under different omission headings. The Third Concordance later absorbed the marginal note into Annex 9, though the Fourth Concordance subsequently revoked Annex 9 in its entirety and reissued the principle under the designation Omission Schedule Beta. Clerk Hessian of the Lower Spiral is credited with the first clean copy, completed on Floor 118,204 in the winter of the 4,011th Archive Year, during a cold season in which the stairwell lamps on that level were extinguished for nineteen consecutive days.
"That which is not entered shall not be entered twice contrary; the silence of one floor is the silence of the next, provided the silence is of the same kind."
— Addendum to Annex Delta, marginal recension attributed to the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony
Relation to Other Omission Doctrines
The Principle of Non-Contradictory Omission is routinely confused with the The Principle of Intentional Omission, from which it differs in that the latter requires a clerk's deliberate act, whereas the former obtains even when no clerk has attended to the floor in question. It is the formal counterweight to Doctrinal Omission, which the Doctrinal Review body treats as a procedural counterbalance rather than a silence of record. The Balance of Omission is held by the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing to be the arithmetic mean of the two, though the Horizontal Integration Y54115430 makes no mention of such a mean and the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony has ruled the claim "outside the scope of measurable omission."
A visiting scholar may not request a demonstration of the principle on a floor where they have not first declared their presence to the Wardens of the Aperture; this restriction is observed without exception and is not waived for Librarians.
Enforcement and Notable Rulings
Enforcement falls to the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony, which also supervises the Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology. In the ruling of Case of the Twin Vacancies (Floor 77,019, Archive Year 4,388), the Office found that two floors had omitted the same nonexistent instrument under headings "Absent Tool" and "Tool Never Conceived," and held the contradiction non-actionable because both headings denoted silence of the same kind. The Second Concordance had earlier suggested the headings were distinct; the contradiction between concordances remains unresolved.
Clerk Marrow of the East Stack filed a grievance in Archive Year 4,402 arguing that the principle had been applied to omit her own name from the Roll of Attending Clerks on Floor 12, and that this omission contradicted its omission from Floor 13. The Office dismissed the grievance on the grounds that a clerk's name is not a subject of catalogue and therefore cannot be omitted contradictorily, a position the The Principle of Incompleteness is sometimes invoked to dispute.
Scholarly Disagreement
The Fifth Concordance asserts that the Principle of Non-Contradictory Omission is subordinate to the Principle of Contradictory Harmony, citing the latter's claim that the Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology is its necessary corollary. The Sixth Concordance rejects this, holding that omission and ontology are separate registers and that harmony is "irrelevant to the silent shelf." The Recension of the Closed Stair proposes a middle reading, that the principle applies only where the Kappa Omission has not already been filed, but the The Practice of Cartographical Omission disputes whether Kappa Omission can coexist with any non-contradictory form.
Procedural Note on Floor Inventories
When an expedition returns from the upward or downward direction with an inventory noting an absence, the inventory must be logged against the Clause 4 omission template before it is folded into the Great Catalogue of Non-Entries. The Principle of Sequenced Adherence requires that such logs be entered in the order of the floors visited, not the order of writing. The Terminal Omission (TO) is reserved for absences observed at the extreme recorded reach of an expedition and is not to be confused with the ordinary non-contradictory silence of intermediate floors. A clerk who misfiles a Terminal Omission as non-contradictory is subject to reassignment to the Stacks of Perpetual Reshelving for no fewer than one Archive Quarter.
See also
-
MS 5227.40
Concordance 12, Clause 44
Concordance 12, Clause 44, ratified on 16 Anatexis, 229 LC, formally establishes the doctrine of Simultaneous Veracity as the foun…
-
MS 0257.22
Doctrine of Concordant Contradiction
The Doctrine of Concordant Contradiction is a practice governing the simultaneous maintenance of mutually exclusive records, holdi…
-
MS 1878.04
Simultaneous Veracity
The doctrine of Simultaneous Veracity (designated Concordance 17, Annex G, Clause 4) is a specialized corollary to the Principle o…
-
MS 2507.09
Principle of Ephemeral Holdings
The Principle of Ephemeral Holdings is the doctrine requiring that any phenomenon ceasing observation during its cataloguing be as…
-
MS 9054.73
The Principle of Contradictory Harmony
The Principle of Contradictory Harmony is a jurisprudential doctrine which asserts that all contradictions within the Tower’s lega…
-
MS 9950.55
Auto-Contradictory Items
Auto-Contradictory Items are holdings whose catalogue entry, physical description, or certified condition is internally inconsiste…
Referenced by
- MS 9025.54 Principle of Non-Contradictory Ontology
- MS 7943.43 The Principle of Non-Contradictory Coexistence
Readers also asked
Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…
Sixth ConcordanceFourth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…
Fourth ConcordanceFifth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…
Fifth ConcordanceScriptorium of the Ninth Landing: who are they?
The Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing is the principal office of the ninth landing of the western stairhead, and the largest of the four scriptoria that claim that landing. It is chiefly known for three undertakings: the …
Scriptorium of the Ninth LandingPassages cited from this record
-
That which is not entered shall not be entered twice contrary; the silence of one floor is the silence of the next, provided the silence is of the same kind.
Addendum to Annex Delta, marginal recension attributed to the Office of Arbitrated Non-Harmony
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 8949.90 Wardens of the Aperture
- MS 6546.82 Stacks of Perpetual Reshelving
- MS 9815.27 Great Catalogue of Non-Entries
- MS 5398.37 Marrow of the East Stack
Because you consulted